Traveling Man

Published May 31 2007, 07:49 PM by Wendy Kaminer

        With key facts still in dispute, I hesitate to judge the conduct of public health officials in the case of the man with drug resistant TB who flew back and forth to Europe in early May. But there seems to be no dispute that the man had been informed of his diagnosis and advised not to travel before he boarded the plane, so I don’t hesitate to blame him for knowingly exposing other people to infection.

        Virtuecrats may attribute his behavior to what is often (and sometimes rightly) critiqued as a cultural ethic of self-centeredness, but getting on a plane knowing you have drug resistant TB requires a malevolent thoughtlessness in which passengers who bellow banalities into their cell phones may never indulge.

        The irony is that, from a civil liberties perspective, there are far fewer objections to cell phone bans on planes than to strict quarantine laws. It’s true that cell phone abusers could assert a First Amendment right to use their phones, but their interest in free speech is weightless compared to the liberty interests apt to be violated by quarantine laws.

        Quarantines involve very difficult conflicts between liberty and public health, which I do not propose to discuss, much less resolve here. I just wonder whether any laws can save us from the selfish stupidities of others, especially when the laws themselves are likely to be administered by people who are no better, if no worse, than the miscreants they seek to control.

Filed Under: public health

Read this Speech

Aborting Speech

Follow the Phoenix

All Blogs

On The Download (2,306)
Talking Politics (1,646)
Laser Orgy (107)
Phlog (1,545)
Outside The Frame (339)
Dont Quote Me (581)

Filed Under: public health

Boston Phoenix
Big Tobacco’s health research: What are these university folks smoking, anyway?
Published 3/31/2008 by Harvey Silverglate
Just when you think you’ve heard the last politically correct, holier-than-thou pronouncement coming out of our university campuses for a while, you open the morning’s...

Boston Phoenix
Made in China: The Silent Critique
Published 7/6/2007 by Harvey Silverglate
Only two words are necessary to say all tha...

more by Wendy Kaminer

Second Lady | August 30, 2008

Hillary's Harpies | August 27, 2008

No We Can't | July 10, 2008

Anti-Noose Laws | May 19, 2008

It's a Crime to Lie to MYSpace? | May 16, 2008

See all articles by: Wendy Kaminer

Latest Comments

Another HBO trailer, this time for "Boardwalk Empire" - HI ALL Here you can buy all the pills. <a href= http://www.pills.s-m2.com /map.html>All">www.pills...

By bunderbergoff on 03-18-2010 in Phlog

Gang Starr legend GURU out of coma, issues press release - So, The acknickulous one, you saying Solar is a closer relative to Guru than guru's OWN nephew and...

By dumbass on 03-17-2010 in On The Download

Looking For The Dumbest SXSW Fashion Trends - hahahahahhhaha - I love you Phoenix.

By Meghan on 03-16-2010 in On The Download

Tron Legacy: Serious Business - Haha. All right, fine.

By Maddy Myers on 03-15-2010 in Laser Orgy

WIN tickets to see the Black Eyed Peas - I love them soooooo much. <33333333 They ROCK!!!!<33333333333333333333

By Mickie on 03-15-2010 in On The Download

Latest Comments from Free For All

Traveling Man

Leave a Comment