Notes on a scandal

Published May 14 2008, 02:34 PM by Adam Reilly

In last week's Phoenix, I suggested that the Herald stake its future on a beefed-up sports section. In the wake of today's front-page Herald apology, though, I'm not so sure that's a good idea.

Here's the apology in question:

On Feb. 2, 2008, the Boston Herald reported that a member of the New England Patriots video staff taped the St. Louis Rams’ walkthrough on the day before Super Bowl XXXVI. While the Boston Herald based its Feb. 2, 2008, report on sources that it believed to be credible, we now know that this report was false, and that no tape of the walkthrough ever existed.

Prior to the publication of its Feb. 2, 2008, article, the Boston Herald neither possessed nor viewed a tape of the Rams’ walkthrough before Super Bowl XXXVI, nor did we speak to anyone who had. We should not have published the allegation in the absence of firmer verification.

The Boston Herald regrets the damage done to the team by publication of the allegation, and sincerely apologizes to its readers and to the New England Patriots [team stats]’ owners, players, employees and fans for our error.

Online comments in response to the apology have not been generous. Basically, a lot of people are promising that they'll never read the Herald again. They're also calling for reporter John Tomase to be fired.

I praised Tomase in the aforementioned article, and thought he might still be vindicated even after we learned that former Patriots employee Matt Walsh hadn't given NFL commissioner Roger Goodell a tape of the walk-through in question. But based on the Herald's apology, it doesn't look like any vindication is forthcoming.

A few other points:

--The Herald apology says its Feb. 2 story was based on "sources that it believed to be credible." Tomase's story only mentioned a single source.

--Some commenters at BostonHerald.com have complained that Tomase didn't issue his own apology. But he shouldn't have, since the paper's editors bear responsibility for the story running, too.

--At Boston Sports Media Watch, Bruce Allen makes a pretty compelling case that, by dismissing Bob Kraft and Bill Belichick's contrition early in Spygate, the Herald made today's apology harder to accept.

--The Globe is giving prominent play to the Herald's apology over at Boston.com. If Mike Reiss and his colleagues are feeling some Schadenfreude, I guess I can't blame them. Still, it's worth remembering that one good liar can lead even the best newspapers to report stories they shouldn't.

--Since Tomase's source(s) apparently provided bad information, I don't think Tomase has any responsibility to keep his/her/their identity secret. But if the Herald's lawyers think that outing the source(s) could pose a legal risk--or if doing so would simply add to the paper's current embarrassment--it may not happen.

New in the Phoenix: 10 McCain stories worth reporting

Patrick vs. DiMasi: whose ear is tinnier?

Follow the Boston Phoenix

All Blogs

On The Download (2,167)
Phlog (1,425)
Dont Quote Me (520)
Talking Politics (1,524)
Laser Orgy (34)
Outside The Frame (305)

more by Adam Reilly

Goal rush! | December 04, 2009

Greg Epstein, Atheist Superstar | November 27, 2009

Unmaking a bad federal law | November 27, 2009

Collateral damage? | November 13, 2009

Holy terror? | November 13, 2009

See all articles by: Adam Reilly

Latest Comments

Senate Race Tightening... Or Not - My money is on Coakley dropping. She doesn't seem to be getting any traction and she seems to be hoping...

By tumble4ya on 12-02-2009 in Talking Politics

GodHatesFags.com Invades Greater Boston - This just another proof of religion promoting hate. Hate that gives excuse to some to commit horrible...

By Rachel Galindo on 12-02-2009 in Phlog

The Globe, Scott Brown, and abortion - Thanks for checking back in, Spilot. That wasn't my intention. The Globe description didn't seem to jibe...

By Adam Reilly on 12-02-2009 in Dont Quote Me

American Hi-Fi covers Miley Cyrus's "The Climb" - Watch The Twilight Saga New Moon Online for Free. Download The Twilight Saga: New Moon. The Twilight...

By abanicewafe on 12-02-2009 in On The Download

RIP, Mike Penner / Christine Daniels - O-FISH-L - just a quick point - it used to be a disorder to be homosexual. The treatment for women suffering...

By offal o-fish-l on 12-02-2009 in Dont Quote Me

Latest Comments from Media Log

Notes on a scandal

Leave a Comment