Phoenix Editorial: McNamara's Lessons

Published Jul 08 2009, 05:24 PM by David Scharfenberg

Lost in the Michael Jackson mania of recent days: the death of Robert McNamara, architect of the Vietnam War. This week's Phoenix editorial suggests a lesson, in McNamara's failures, for an Obama administration still coming to terms with Iraq and Afghanistan. From the editorial:

As secretary of defense under President Lyndon B. Johnson, Robert McNamara prosecuted the Vietnam War on a day-to-day basis, just as Donald Rumsfeld orchestrated the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq for George W. Bush. The details may appear strikingly different — a Communist threat in the jungle as opposed to an Islamist menace in the desert — but the rotten policy core has a painful consistency: miscalculation fortified by rampant arrogance.

McNamara's death on Monday at age 93 should serve as a prompt, a trigger, for President Barack Obama and his foreign-policy team. It presents an unspoken invitation to consider the common denominators of Iraq, Afghanistan, and Vietnam.

He's Ba-aack

New Executive Director For Providence Community Library

Follow the Providence Phoenix

All Blogs

On The Download (2,174)
Dont Quote Me (525)
Talking Politics (1,529)
Outside The Frame (307)
Phlog (1,430)
Laser Orgy (35)

more by David Scharfenberg

News worth paying for? | December 04, 2009

Will Caprio’s early ad spree work? | November 27, 2009

Kennedy, Catholic Church, and Politics of Compromise | November 20, 2009

Fight for your right to party | November 13, 2009

Newspapering the hard way | November 06, 2009

See all articles by: David Scharfenberg

Latest Comments

City Council Forums - Наш сайт - самый легкий и быстрый способ найти партнера, имеющего схожие с вашими сексуальные предпочтения...

By Merbactibrape on 12-04-2009 in Talking Politics

Totten trial chairwoman: the fix wasn't in - Hi !. You re, I guess , probably curious to know how one can make real money . There is no initial capital...

By EpirummomoHug on 12-04-2009 in Dont Quote Me

Recommended reading: Charlie Pierce on Tiger Woods - Mike Hunt's Q&A Session: Q: What is only way Tiger will get thru this? A: Tiger will have to go on...

By Mike Hunt on 12-03-2009 in Dont Quote Me

Confirmation Of Contradiction - If Coakley's poll was a smaller margin, but still bigger than what Capuano's poll is seeing it would...

By This guy on 12-03-2009 in Talking Politics

Recommended reading: Charlie Pierce on Tiger Woods - @ Mike Harter: Mike, Charlie's point is that USGA bows daily at the altar of El Tigre, the man-child...

By Mike Saunders on 12-03-2009 in Dont Quote Me

Latest Comments from Not For Nothing

Phoenix Editorial: McNamara's Lessons

Leave a Comment