Guys and Dolls on the Cape
By IRIS FANGER | July 25, 2006
 Garrett Long and Jarrod Emick |
If there’s a God in show-biz Heaven, she’s no doubt relieved that the folks at Cape Playhouse in Dennis had enough theatrical smarts to mount Guys and Dolls (through July 29) without messing around. Rather than impose a new concept or update the classic American musical, which opened on Broadway in 1950 and ran for nearly three years, director Mark Martino has imported a high-gloss cast of New York–based veterans to re-create the lovable sinners looking for action along the by-ways of Times Square, in an era when sin meant gambling and alcohol rather than drug dealers and fears of backpack-toting bombers.The Dennis miracle lies in shoehorning 19 performers with an 11-piece orchestra to back them onto the venerable summer theater’s minuscule stage — not to mention devising room for the dance numbers created by John MacInnis. I counted five couples in the “Havana” number and 10 men in the line-up of the “Luck Be a Lady” ballet, which means that the actors in their multiple roles were as precisely choreographed in their costume changes as in their dance numbers.
Then as now, the characters swell with the humor and joie de vivre of Damon Runyon’s characters as enhanced by the book of Jo Swerling and Abe Burrows and Frank Loesser’s glorious score. There’s not a less-than-delightful moment, from the opening ballet in Times Square as the citizens come out to play beneath the lighted marquees of the theaters (the signature staging that was reverentially borrowed for The Producers) to the finale in the Save-a-Soul Mission where the cordially rotund Nicely-Nicely Johnson (Richard Ruiz) leads his fellow lowlife pals through the rousing “Sit Down, You’re Rockin’ the Boat.”
Garrett Long as Miss Sarah Brown must have jolted the folks in nearby Yarmouth and Barnstable off their front porches when she let loose on the opening high notes of “I’ll Know (When My Love Comes Along).” She’s the good girl, the Mission “doll,” in contrast to the slightly frazzled but wistfully loyal Liz Larsen as Miss Adelaide, the centerfold leading the ladies of the chorus at the Hot Box Nightclub while waiting for crap-game organizer Nathan Detroit to marry her. This is one of the choice roles in the annals of stellar musicals, and Larson does not disappoint. Despite looking more boyish than dangerous, Jarrod Emick’s Sky Masterson meets matinee-idol expectations, and Jason Graae makes Nathan Detroit into a lovable louse. But it’s Gerry McIntyre’s Benny Southstreet, one of Nathan’s flunkies, who gives the production its pizzazz.
Guys and Dolls remains a tangible treasure of the golden age of Broadway musicals, a reminder of the days when audiences could leave the theater with the newest hit songs stuck in their heads rather than images of the latest stage technologies.
Related:
Maid in America, Musical man, Music and fashion, More
- Maid in America
Caroline, the African-American maid of Caroline, or Change , spends most of her days doing laundry in a basement in Louisiana, circa 1963.
- Musical man
When holographic projection technology gets perfected, you can be sure that Mel Brooks’s The Producers will be one of the first holograms released.
- Music and fashion
Since it turns out that the Evil Empire actually does suck this year, let’s start this summer preview off with Joe Boyd’s famous Faustian bargain
- Killing grounds
Chekhov wrote to a friend while composing The Seagull , first of his Big Four, that he was writing a “comedy with three female parts, six male parts, four acts, a landscape (a view of the lake), much talk about literature, and five tons of love.”
- After the fall
The evil is boiled down in the revival of Sweeney Todd, the Demon Barber of Fleet Street, and that makes for a stew far tastier than Mrs. Lovett’s human-hamburger pies.
- That’s amore
The Light in the Piazza is an ambitious if old-fashioned musical.
- Power playing
Theatre by the Sea is staging a slick rendition of Evita that gets across much of the power of the personalities and social forces involved.
- No sex please, we’re bookish
A not so funny thing happened on the way to the Huntington Theatre Company’s planned run of A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum : the lead actor accepted a part in a Broadway show.
- Dashing debut
The wickedly dark, clever, and all-deprecating satire Urinetown receives a sonorous production by the newly formed Vacationland Theater Company, in Sanford, directed by Hunter F. Roberts.
- Poster children
The freshly painted mural built on the wall outside Anthony’s Italian Kitchen is pretty convincing.
- Crimes and misdemeanors
There are more echoes in Dirty Rotten Scoundrels than rattle around the Grand Canyon.
- Less

Topics:
Theater
, Entertainment, Performing Arts, Musicals, More
, Entertainment, Performing Arts, Musicals, Theater, Broadway Shows, Nicely-Nicely Johnson, Nathan Detroit, Abe Burrows, Damon Runyon, Frank Loesser, Less