Review: Pom Wonderful Presents: The Greatest Movie Ever Sold

Reviews

P.S. I Love You

A middling effort for Hilary Swank

By ALICIA POTTER | December 19, 2007

2.0 Stars

Hilary Swank and Gerard Butler

From misty-eyed to crumple-faced, Hilary Swank weeps with the best in her second consecutive middling effort for director Richard LaGravenese (Freedom Writers). Tears aside, she’s stiff and offputting as Holly, a young widow mourning the charismatic Gerry (Scottish actor Gerard Butler, all twinkly in shamrock boxer shorts because he’s playing an Irish guy). Imp that he is, Gerry has arranged to send Holly 10 letters, post-mortem, to ease her grief — and her bitchy streak. Gerry is the perfect dead man, showing up shirtless à la Ghost or in stagy flashbacks. (The couple’s meet-cute recalls those old Irish Spring commercials.) But soon the missives don’t arrive swiftly enough, and the pile-up of female stereotypes and fantasies evokes little that’s fresh or moving. The kicker, though, is Holly’s love of Bette Davis movies. More than a contrivance, it’s a rueful reminder of all that this “women’s pic” isn’t. 97 minutes | Boston Common + Fenway + Fresh Pond + Circle/Chestnut Hill + suburbs

Related: Nim's Island, Are you kidding us?, Body dabble, More

Topics: Reviews , Celebrity News, Entertainment, Movie Stars, More

| More

ARTICLES BY ALICIA POTTER

REVIEW: FRIENDS WITH KIDS | March 08, 2012
There are only so many baggy vagina jokes one can take. And writer/director Jennifer Westfeldt's disappointing film about how parenthood changes a Manhattan circle of friends has its share.

REVIEW: DECLARATION OF WAR | February 16, 2012
A baby with a brain tumor is no laughing matter.

REVIEW: YOUNG ADULT | December 13, 2011
A baby, a high school, and esoteric pop culture references once again figure prominently — albeit less glibly — in director Jason Reitman and screenwriter Diablo Cody's first re-teaming since Juno.

REVIEW: A DOLPHIN TALE | September 20, 2011
Winter the dolphin gamely plays herself in this loose re-telling of her fight for survival after a crab trap mangles her tail.

REVIEW: AFRICAN CATS | April 25, 2011
To their credit, directors Alastair Fothergill and Keith Scholey don't cut away from a downed gazelle or a hippo mid evisceration.