Features

Are we grading on a curve?

Peter Keough’s Oscar Scorecard

By PHOENIX STAFF | January 23, 2008

It’s a solid B, which isn’t bad considering the vagaries of the Academy of Motion Pictures Arts & Sciences. In our January 11 issue, Phoenix film editor Peter Keough, after protecting his critical credentials by writing who and what should be nominated for Oscars this 80th time around, offered his predictions as to who and what would make the final cut this year in the big-ticket categories.

Keough scored 24 out of 30 — that’s 80 percent — which he claims is “about par the for course with these things.” He is, however, proud to have nailed the nomination results for best supporting actor and actress — 10 for 10.

And now, so our readers can debate the relative wisdom of backing directors Sean Penn and Sidney Lumet over Juno’s 30-year-old Jason (Thank You for Smoking) Reitman and Michael Clayton first-time director Tony Gilroy (screenwriter for all three Bourne blockbusters), we present (without envelope) the results.

And the nominees are . . .	Peter’s predictions were . . .
BEST PICTURE (4 for 5) Atonement Juno Michael Clayton No Country for Old Men There Will Be Blood	Sweeney Todd Juno Michael Clayton No Country for Old Men There Will Be Blood
BEST DIRECTOR (3 for 5) Paul Thomas Anderson (There Will Be Blood) Joel and Ethan Coen (No Country for Old Men) Tony Gilroy (Michael Clayton) Jason Reitman (Juno) Julian Schnabel (The Diving Bell and the Butterfly)	Paul Thomas Anderson (There Will Be Blood) Joel and Ethan Coen (No Country for Old Men) Sean Penn (Into the Wild) Sidney Lumet (Before the Devil Knows You're Dead) Julian Schnabel (The Diving Bell and the Butterfly)
BEST ACTOR (3 for 5) George Clooney (Michael Clayton) Daniel Day-Lewis (There Will Be Blood) Johnny Depp (Sweeney Todd) Tommy Lee Jones (In the Valley of Elah) Viggo Mortensen (Eastern Promises)	George Clooney (Michael Clayton) Daniel Day-Lewis (There Will Be Blood) Johnny Depp (Sweeney Todd) Ryan Gosling (Lars and the Real Girl) Denzel Washington (American Gangster)
BEST ACTRESS (4 for 5) Cate Blanchett (Elizabeth: The Golden Age) Julie Christie (Away From Her) Marion Cotillard (La Vie en Rose) Laura Linney (The Savages) Ellen Page (Juno)	Angelina Jolie (A Mighty Heart) Julie Christie (Away From Her) Marion Cotillard (La Vie en Rose) Laura Linney (The Savages) Ellen Page (Juno)

BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR (5 for 5 — Bingo!)
Casey Affleck (The Assassination of Jesse James . . .)
Javier Bardem (No Country for Old Men)
Philip Seymour Hoffman (Charlie Wilson’s War)
Hal Holbrook (Into the Wild)
Tom Wilkinson (Michael Clayton)

BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS (modesty forbids)
Cate Blanchett (I’m Not There)
Ruby Dee (American Gangster)
Saoirse Ronan (Atonement)
Amy Ryan (Gone Baby Gone)
Tilda Swinton (Michael Clayton)

Related: The Oscars go to Hell, War zones, The Boston Phoenix–Alumni Film Critics’ Poll, More

Topics: Features , Celebrity News, Entertainment, Michael Clayton, More

Comments

Add a Comment

Today's Event Picks

[MUSIC] Boston Philharmonic Orchestra conducted by Benjamin Zander, with soprano Linda Watson

Plus 7 more >>

ARTICLES BY PHOENIX STAFF

SKI AND SNOWBOARD GUIDE 2010 | November 19, 2009
Get ready for another great year on the slopes with the Phoenix 's guide to powder

SLIDESHOW: SNOW AND SKI ART CONTEST 2010 | November 19, 2009
Finalists from our annual illustration contest

SLIDESHOW: INSIDE TODAY'S GRAPHIC NOVELS | October 14, 2009
Images from graphic novels like World War 3 , Drunk , Asterios Polyp , and more.

PHOTOS: THE NATIONAL PARKS: AMERICA'S BEST IDEA | September 24, 2009
Scenes from The National Parks: America's Best Idea , a six-part, 12-hour film by Ken Burns and Dayton Duncan, George Masa.

PORTLAND FALL ARTS GUIDE 2009 | September 17, 2009
Sink your teeth into the best music, movies, arts and more.

See all articles by: PHOENIX STAFF

Most Viewed

Most Emailed

WE'RE KILLING THE OCEANS
I meet world-renowned undersea photojournalist Brian Skerry at Legal Seafoods, across from the New England Aquarium, where he's the explorer in residence. He orders a chicken Caesar salad.

REVIEW: THE BLIND SIDE
It’s tough for any self-respecting critic to refrain from joyously tackling a Sandra Bullock movie — so it’s a good thing The Blind Side isn’t one.

REVIEW: PLANET 51
The opening for the latest animated kids’ fantasy is promising — but it’s for another movie.

TAVERN AT THE END OF THE WORLD
They say there's no accounting for taste, though most folks will agree that if your tastes and mine are similar, then we both have good taste. This occurred to me as I scanned the jukebox at Charlestown's Tavern at the End of the World, a neighborhood bar/restaurant just outside Sullivan Square.

CITY TABLE
I'm enjoying this restaurant recession more than the last one.

WE'RE KILLING THE OCEANS
I meet world-renowned undersea photojournalist Brian Skerry at Legal Seafoods, across from the New England Aquarium, where he's the explorer in residence. He orders a chicken Caesar salad.

TAXING CATHOLICS
Should the Roman Catholic Church, and the various subsidiary groups and organizations that exist under its umbrella and operate at its direction, be entitled to state- and federal-tax exemptions?

REVISITING THE GREATEST HARVARD-YALE GAME
It takes some doing to make Harvard look like an underdog in anything. But Harvard Beats Yale, 29-29 — Kevin Rafferty's 2008 movie (out now on DVD) and new book (released this past month) about the famous football rivalry — does just that.

HOLY TERROR?
On the afternoon of November 5, Army Major Nidal Malik Hasan walked into a building at Fort Hood, the sprawling military base in central Texas; sat briefly in solitary silence; and then opened fire with a semi-automatic pistol, shooting roughly a hundred rounds and killing 12 soldiers and one civilian.