CD Reviews

Joni Mitchell

Shine | Hear Music

By JEFF TAMARKIN | November 6, 2007

2.5 Stars

Joni Mitchell’s first album for Starbucks’ Hear Music label isn’t being hyped as a concept album, but that’s what it is. Almost every song wags a finger at the impending environmental apocalypse, rampant political evils, and those who would allow such badness to thrive. Hopeful glimmers —“Hana,” a stoic call for volunteerism and keeping the faith — cut through the gloom, but Mitchell’s not making any long-term plans. “We have poisoned everything and oblivious to it all/The cellphone zombies babble through the shopping malls,” she sings in “Bad Dreams.” The title song rails against both “Frankenstein technologies” and “assholes passing on the right,” among other modern-day bummers; even the remake of “Big Yellow Taxi” takes on a discomforting 11th-hour hue absent from the original. Mitchell produced the album and played most of the instruments (including the cheesy disco-era drum machine). The arrangements are stark and lean, relying on ominous, droning washes of ambient sound, subtle jazzy guitar and keyboard, well-placed sax bursts, and honeyed pedal steel to provide coloring. Subdued but not entirely resigned, Mitchell sings in a strong, assured voice that’s still warm and welcoming, though lowered by decades of ecologically unhip tobacco smoke. Closing with “If,” with lyrics adapted from Rudyard Kipling, she assures, “I know you’ll be all right.” Then again, maybe not.

Herbie Hancock
River: The Joni Letters | Verve
Various Artists: Wayfaring Strangers: Ladies from the Canyon
Numero Group
Praise the Lord
Mary Lou’s star rises from the Red Line Platform
More

Topics: CD Reviews , Joni Mitchell , Joni Mitchell , Pop and Rock Music , More

Comments

Add a Comment

ARTICLES BY JEFF TAMARKIN

I GOT THE FEELIN': JAMES BROWN IN THE '60S | August 04, 2008
Shout! Factory

LOVE STORY | July 22, 2008
Love Story | Start

ALL YOU NEED IS LOVE | July 01, 2008
Voiceprint

RY COODER | June 24, 2008
I, Flathead | Nonesuch/Perro Verde

RACHID TAHA | June 17, 2008
Rock El Casbah: The Best Of . . . | Wrasse

See all articles by: JEFF TAMARKIN

Most Viewed

Most Emailed

FIEDLER ON THE SPOT
Having taken the reins of BU’s contentious College of Communication, Pulitzer winner Tom Fiedler learns to navigate the thorny world of academia

PHOTOS: RADIOHEAD IN BOSTON
August 14, 2008 at the Comcast Center, Mansfield, MA

WOMEN ON THE VERGE
Clinton die-hards have created a new-girls’ network bent on remedying decades of sexism by putting women in elected office

TIGER TRAP
Sports blotter: "Walking in Memphis" edition

PHOTOS: NORTH KOREA'S SURREAL MASS GAMES
While everyone else watches the Olympics, Asia's weirdest sporting event transpires in the world's most secretive country

WOMEN ON THE VERGE
Clinton die-hards have created a new-girls’ network bent on remedying decades of sexism by putting women in elected office

FIEDLER ON THE SPOT
Having taken the reins of BU’s contentious College of Communication, Pulitzer winner Tom Fiedler learns to navigate the thorny world of academia