CD Reviews

Replacements | Rhino Reissues

Tim + Pleased To Meet Me + Don’t Tell A Soul + All Shook Down | Rhino (2008)

By ZETH LUNDY | October 1, 2008

3.0 Stars

Rhino’s second and concluding batch of Replacements reissues (the first four albums were released earlier this year) charts the Minneapolis band’s Great Descent from the heights of rock-and-roll nihilism to the pit of MOR blah. Between the release of Tim (1985), the ’Mats’ greatest record and a raggedy piss-take on success, love, and post-whatever, and All Shook Down (1990), a Paul Westerberg solo album in everything but name, lead guitarist Bob Stinson was made a scapegoat for the band’s chemical indulgences and fired, and Westerberg’s songwriting became boring. That said, Pleased To Meet Me (1987) remains a potent, if polished, rock record, whereas Don’t Tell a Soul (1989) boasts some of the best examples of Westerberg’s ready-for-prime-time revamp (“Achin’ To Be,” “I’ll Be You”). Rhino’s editions sound fantastic, shining up “Kiss Me on the Bus” and putting the knuckles back into Tommy Stinson’s bass. PTMM has the best selection of bonus tracks, like the dunderheaded raver “Bundle Up” and the disheveled wail ’n’ blooze “Election Day.” DTAS, a more sober affair by ’Mats standards, gets the last laugh with a hidden rehearsal snippet of a cover of a certain dead-ape song by one of their contemporaries. Westerberg, still snotty and entitled, hollers, “If the Pixies are seven, then the ’Mats are eight!”

Topics: CD Reviews , Paul Westerberg, Paul Westerberg, Tommy Stinson, More

Comments

Add a Comment

view all

[ 11/24 ] Boston Symphony Orchestra conducted by Sir Andrew Davis @ Symphony Hall

[ 11/24 ] Fenway Jazz Jam @ Tiki Hideaway @ Howard Johnson

[ 11/24 ] Berklee Jazz/World String Orchestra @ St. Paul's Cathedral

[ 11/24 ] Jimmy Buffett & the Coral Reefer Band @ Mohegan Sun Arena

[ 11/24 ] Baliset @ O’Brien’s

ARTICLES BY ZETH LUNDY

AC-DC | BACKTRACKS | November 10, 2009
How easy is it to admire AC/DC?

MORRISSEY | SWORDS | November 06, 2009
Morrissey — begrudging patron saint of all that is emotionally desolate and otherwise comfortably bummed — is but a mere mortal, as his recent collapse on stage proves.

DAVID BOWIE | SPACE ODDITY: 40TH ANNIVERSARY EDITION | October 30, 2009
David Bowie’s 1969 album Man of Music/Man of Words was retitled a few years after its debut, most likely because it was quickly becoming known as Space Oddity and Those Other Eight Songs We Could Care Less About .

SPIRAL STAIRS | THE REAL FEEL | October 21, 2009
As his former band prepare to stage their much-ballyhooed reunion next year, Scott Kannberg is breaking his five-year recording silence with what is arguably his least cryptic post-Pavement release.

FLIGHT OF THE CONCHORDS | I TOLD YOU I WAS FREAKY | October 14, 2009
The New Zealand “folk-comedy” duo Flight of the Conchords transcended folk and comedy on their debut LP, a soundtrack to the absurdist HBO show of the same name, with genre parodies that were great songs in their own right.

See all articles by: ZETH LUNDY

Most Viewed

Most Emailed

WE'RE KILLING THE OCEANS
I meet world-renowned undersea photojournalist Brian Skerry at Legal Seafoods, across from the New England Aquarium, where he's the explorer in residence. He orders a chicken Caesar salad.

REVIEW: THE TWILIGHT SAGA: NEW MOON
Chris Weitz comes on board to direct Twilight ’s hotly awaited sequel, New Moon , but the second bite doesn’t sate quite like the first. Bella (Kristen Stewart) celebrates her 18th birthday with vampire boyfriend Edward (Robert Pattinson); when she gets a paper cut at the party.

MISSING PERSONS SINGER DALE BOZZIO JAILED
Missing Persons singer Dale Bozzio is sitting in an Ossipee, New Hampshire, jail after dropping her appeal of a March animal-cruelty conviction.

REVIEW: THE BLIND SIDE
It’s tough for any self-respecting critic to refrain from joyously tackling a Sandra Bullock movie — so it’s a good thing The Blind Side isn’t one.

REVIEW: THE ROAD
John Hillcoat doesn't stray from Cormac McCarthy's Road For those who found the Coen Brothers' adaptation of Cormac McCarthy's No Country for Old Men too lighthearted, John Hillcoat's relentlessly faithful version of the author's post-apocalyptic Pulitzer-winning novel might hit the spot.

WE'RE KILLING THE OCEANS
I meet world-renowned undersea photojournalist Brian Skerry at Legal Seafoods, across from the New England Aquarium, where he's the explorer in residence. He orders a chicken Caesar salad.

GLENN BECK'S UNHINGED SWEATER SAGA
Hello, America. A special Glenn Beck Program tonight: I'm speaking to you from somewhere in the North Pole, and let me tell you [adopts cartoonish yokel voice with rubbery exaggerated shiver] it is coooooooold up here.

COAKLEY TAKES A STAND
Massachusetts Attorney General Martha Coakley this week separated herself from the gang of essentially like-minded candidates seeking to fill Senator Ted Kennedy's Washington seat by rejecting the US House of Representatives compromise that traded approval of a health-care-reform bill for greater restrictions to abortion access. Good for Coakley.

GROUP EFFORT
If you're inclined to play punk rock, chances are you've got a self-esteem problem. It's not an æsthetic that attracts the well-adjusted. Exhibit A: Mark Lind. As bassist and frontman of the Ducky Boys, he's opened for Rancid, U.S. Bombs, and Flogging Molly.

REVISITING THE GREATEST HARVARD-YALE GAME
It takes some doing to make Harvard look like an underdog in anything. But Harvard Beats Yale, 29-29 — Kevin Rafferty's 2008 movie (out now on DVD) and new book (released this past month) about the famous football rivalry — does just that.

HOT TOPICS

Aerosmith , Brian Eno , Johannes Brahms , American League (Baseball) , Gustavo Dudamel , AL East Division , The Beatles , Dropkick Murphys , Benjamin Zander , Danger Mouse

CD Reviews

Replacements | Rhino Reissues

Swollen Members | Armed to the Teeth

Them Crooked Vultures | Them Crooked Vultures

Annie | Don't Stop

AC-DC | Backtracks

Pink Martini | Splendor in the Grass