A lawyer known for representing Maine activists arrested during protests is compiling a database of civil-disobedience cases to help him argue a lighter sentence for one of his clients. Phil Worden, an attorney based in Northeast Harbor, sent an e-mail to members of the progressive Maine Indymedia Web site on November 30, asking whether “anyone who has engaged in civil disobedience in the last five years would contact me with a brief description of what you did, what you were convicted of, which court it occurred in (and the name of the judge if you can remember it), and what sentence you received.” Worden hopes the information he culls from the rap sheets of Maine activists will convince an Augusta judge to sentence his client, Hillary Lister, to community service rather than 48 hours in jail.Lister, the president of the group Citizens Against Pollution in Town, chained herself to the gallery of the Maine Legislature during an April 2006 protest against plans to build a construction debris incinerator in Athens. Lister, 25, was charged with disorderly conduct and obstructing government administration. This is her first arrest; both charges are misdemeanors.
Worden hopes to prove that Maine’s nonviolent activists arrested for the first time are usually sentenced to community service. But, even with the database, Worden can’t guarantee Lister or any of his future nonviolent clients won’t spend time behind bars.
“When you get to sentencing issues, one judge isn’t bound by what another judge did,” Worden explains. “But it can be what we call persuasive authority that the more we can say, ‘This judge gave somebody who chained herself up community service and so did that judge and that judge,’ at a certain point it seems to me that becomes pretty persuasive that that’s what ought to happen. Unless there’s something particular in the case that justifies a jail sentence that makes it different than the other ones, there should be some kind of uniformity in sentencing.”
The Maine State Law Library does not have a database on civil-disobedience cases and Worden says he is not aware of any similar resource covering state activism. So far, Worden has received, he says, “five or six” responses. To contribute, e-mail Worden atpworden@igc.org.
Related:
More trouble in the Supermax, Arbitrary imprisonment, Prison sentences, More 
- More trouble in the Supermax
A hunger strike has ended at the Maine State Prison in Warren, but all is not well at the state’s largest house of corrections.
- Arbitrary imprisonment
Joseph Steinberger thought he had won one of the most important trials of his legal career.
- Prison sentences
On a recent Sunday, in the visiting room of the Bay State Correctional Center in Norfolk, a child darted between rows of green vinyl chairs in a flurry of giggles.
- Dangerous waits for psychiatric evaluations?
State officials admit delays for jail-inmate psychiatric evaluations have increased considerably.
- The 11th Annual Muzzle Awards
Freedom of expression may be guaranteed by the Constitution. But it’s an idea we have to fight for every day.
- Cracks in the armor
A couple of cracks have opened in the state’s armor of prison secrecy.
- Unspeakable
Just when you thought Hillary Clinton couldn’t be more vile or shameless, along comes her remark about Bobby Kennedy’s assassination on the campaign trail.
- Robojudge
Judge Stephen Breyer, Bill Clinton's latest pick for the Supreme Court, has attracted support so broad that it spans ideological and political differences.
- Budget cuts
“Things are as tough at the prison right now as I’ve seen them in a long time,” state Corrections commissioner Martin Magnusson told the Legislature’s Criminal Justice and Public Safety Committee on July 29. He spoke about the consequences of the staff cuts that the 915-inmate, 410-employee Maine State Prison in Warren has had to endure.
- French fries strike back!
P&J consider it amazing that this story from the Washington Times (via MSNBC), forwarded by our friend Tommy from Queens, didn’t get wider national front-page coverage.
- The 10th Annual Muzzle Awards
Mitt Romney will say or do anything if he thinks it will help him become president.
- Less
Topics:
This Just In
, U.S. Government, U.S. State Government, Criminal Sentencing and Punishment, More
, U.S. Government, U.S. State Government, Criminal Sentencing and Punishment, Protests and Demonstrations, Maine State Legislature, Hillary Lister, Less
