The battle to rescue the historic Providence Public Library system from financial collapse, and perhaps to end years of controversy about its operation, may be nearing potential resolution.
A variety of sometimes-competing library supporters — a former banker, trustees, bookworms of every stripe, librarians in and outside the Providence system, academicians, and even an Episcopal priest — have been working to put the library on an steadier financial and emotional footing.
The focus currently is on an 11-member “Municipal Library Working Group.” Its members were appointed by Mayor David N. Cicilline last summer to draft a three- to five-year agreement between the city and the nonprofit corporation that owns and runs the library.
The Reverend Maria DeCarvalho, the dean for seven years of the Episcopal Cathedral of St. John, and who now runs a consulting service to facilitate organizational communication, is the volunteer facilitator of the mayor’s committee.
She tells the Phoenix that the group, cognizant that the library needs financial certainty, wants to have a draft proposal soon. A temporary funding agreement, which is keeping the downtown Central Library and nine branches running, will expire at mid-year.
The group’s plan will address the city’s annual contribution to the library (now about $3.3 million of the more than $8 million budget); a reporting system between the library and the city; operation of the branches; and library “governance.”
On Monday, a Library Advocates Coalition, whose members aren’t part of the working group, issued its own list, calling for retention of all library branches, a 15 percent increase in city funding, and a 15 percent reduction in overhead. Its most dramatic proposal was the replacement of Dale Thompson, the library’s director, and her administrative team, plus the replacement of five trustees with five Providence residents and library users to be appointed by the city.
The administration has lost the “confidence and trust” of public officials, library patrons and much of its staff, the group says.
That echoes a theme sounded by Neil Steinberg, a former Bank of America executive now at Brown University, who studied the library last summer. He said “the deteriorating relationship between PPL leadership, the city and various community advocacy groups has been negatively impacted by the approach taken by the PPL leadership.”
Library spokeswoman Tonia Mason says she finds it “ironic” how the advocates’ group is criticizing an administration that has created a library system the group now wants to preserve. The sooner the working group plan is in place, the sooner the uncertainty plaguing the library can be resolved, she says.
DeCarvalho says the working group understands the urgency and has “enormous empathy for the trustees of the library, who have been working very hard, under extremely challenging circumstances.”
One issue resolved for now is a drive by 90 library employees to be represented by the United Service and Allied Workers of Rhode Island following a round of layoffs in 2004. The workers voted last month, 62 to 7, to ratify their first contract. It provides raises of three to three-point-five percent over three years, through mid-2009.
Related:
The incredible shrinking library, PPL drama continues, Library critics press for more oversight at the PPL, More 
- The incredible shrinking library
When a leaky roof closed the Washington Park branch of the Providence Public Library in January, a small number of children’s books were moved to a nearby former Benny’s store on Broad Street, and the branch’s literacy and after-school services fanned out to other locations.
- PPL drama continues
The saga of the financially stressed Providence Public Library sometimes seems like a story being written by multiple authors.
- Library critics press for more oversight at the PPL
Calling the management of the Providence Public Library (PPL) arrogant and disinterested in providing library services, library critics continue to press for more public control of the nonprofit corporation.
- Time Machines
There is a golden formula in photography: photo plus time equals increasing allure. Old books and poetry, old television and movies can turn stilted, tedious. But photos seem to grow ever more compelling with age, even if the shots were boring when they were first made.
- Should Americans Send Books to Iraq?
Sending books to Iraq to promote civic culture in Iraq might help you to sleep more soundly. But do small-scale efforts make more than a symbolic impact?
- 91. George W. Bush
What, did you think we were done ripping the Neanderthal who set the country back five decades in just eight years, just because he’s out of office? Well, we want to be the first to mock all of those involved in building a library commemorating America’s first illiterate president. We’d also like to recommend the first book for inclusion in the project: The Pet Goat .
- S.O.S. in the Biggest Little
What a joyful time in the Ocean State.
- AG should probe BPL
Political innocents who discount allegations that Boston Mayor Thomas Menino is politicizing the Boston Public Library’s board of trustees so that he can directly control the nation’s oldest free municipal library received a rude awakening recently.
- Come together
Anyone who’s ever truly needed peace and quiet, understand the incredible sanctity of a public library.
- Censorship for Me, Penelope
Lisa Jahn-Clough's young-adult novel Me, Penelope is the subject of a recent dispute at Tavares Middle School in Orlando, Florida.
- Casa D. slate storms the primary
While P&J do not see eye to eye with most of Bob “Cool Moose” Healey’s libertarian leanings, he is a truly thoughtful contributor to the body politic.
- Less
Topics:
This Just In
, Media, Brian Jones, Brown University, More
, Media, Brian Jones, Brown University, Libraries, Providence Public Library, David N. Cicilline, Tonia Mason, Dale Thompson, Maria DeCarvalho, Neil Steinberg, Less
