This Just In

The Journal wants it both ways on scrutiny of the media

As the ProJo turns

By IAN DONNIS | August 15, 2007

There was a bit of unintended irony in the Providence Journal’s publication Monday of Sydney Schanberg’s spot-on op-ed piece about Rupert Murdoch.

The main point of Schanberg, who has had a distinguished journalistic career at the New York Times and elsewhere, was that Murdoch’s platitudes about preserving the editorial quality and reputation of the Wall Street Journal should be taken with a grain of salt. The writer based this point of view on Rupe’s track record and how his promises “have a very short life span.”

In fleshing this out, Schanberg described how, when he was an op-ed writer at the Times in the late ’80s, he wrote a column about Murdoch, headlined, “The Tasmanian Devil.” In quick order, Schanberg learned that Arthur “Punch” Sulzberger Jr., then the publisher of the paper, had called the editorial page editor, Max Frankel, to complain about the tone of the piece, and wanted it removed from later editions. Sulzberger was talked out of this by Frankel.

“[Then] the publisher called a late-afternoon conference in his digs on the 14th floor,” Schanberg wrote. “In a polite fashion, I was being called on the executive carpet. In addition to the publisher, Sydney Gruson, Punch’s right-hand man, was there, as was Max. Drinks were poured and Punch explained his stance. He felt that other publishers were our colleagues and therefore not proper material for critical columns. I posited that newspapers were major opinion shapers and therefore centers of power and that if my column was going to examine the establishment, media chiefs should not be left off the list.”

“Punch then got right to his point. ‘Sydney,’ he said of Murdoch, ‘I have to do business with him.’ I understood him completely and said no more.”

The irony here is that the ProJo, which looks into any number of things in Rhode Island as its mission, doesn’t much like being looked into itself. This was the case during the four-year labor dispute between management and the Providence Newspaper Guild, and it continues to be so, as demonstrated by the unwillingness of ProJo publisher Howard Sutton and other top execs to speak with the Phoenix.

Freedom of speech, of course, includes the freedom not to speak.

Yet it’s the height of institutional hypocrisy for the ProJo (which ran Schanberg’s piece in cooperation with the Nation) to tacitly endorse scrutiny of the media elsewhere, while rejecting it at home. And the blame for this goes to the top man.

This item was posted August 14 on www.thephoenix.com/notfornothing.

Related: The Kristol method, Dance, Monkey: Robert Schimmel, When Rupert came to Boston, More

The Kristol method
Journalistic atrocity or savvy hire?
Dance, Monkey: Robert Schimmel
What would really be great would be if, at the end of the show, everyone was dead, except one comic, who is literally the last one standing. He wins.
When Rupert came to Boston
Just how badly will Rupert Murdoch screw up the Wall Street Journal ?
The Fox and the Wolff
No point in looking for an explanation or asking "why" something was said or done; Murdoch has no demonstrated ability to do so.
55. Richard Johnson
A five-star general in Rupert Murdoch’s war against intelligence, this lizard-faced, pinstriped New York Post Page Six gossip-whore has done as much as any single person toward the stupidization of American society. Maybe he’s pregnant! Maybe he’s anorexic! Or maybe, just maybe, he cries himself to sleep knowing that, however good he is at his profession, he’ll never be better than a 13-year-old girl.
Mr. Respectable
Last Wednesday, oft-vilified media mogul Rupert Murdoch announced that News Corp. — parent company of (among others) the Times of London, the New York Post , and Fox News — will soon begin charging readers for access to all its news sites.
Murdoch mulls Hub's Herald
This article originally appeared in the October 26, 1982 issue of the Boston Phoenix.
Is Murdoch’s WSJ being snubbed?
This year’s Pulitzer Prize box score has the Washington Post taking four prizes (international reporting, feature writing, commentary, and criticism) and the New York Times snagging three (explanatory, national, and investigative reporting).
Through a glass darkly
Predicting a Super Bowl winner doesn't make you a genius: after all, given a pool of 32 teams, one of them is bound to capture the trophy. But predicting the future for an industry that's been buffeted by new technologies and economic vicissitudes, and sometimes seems to have all the substance and staying power of sea foam? That's an accomplishment.
Worse than Afghanistan
At almost the same moment that Rolling Stone was reordering the political landscape with its devastating profile of the now-resigned Afghanistan commander General Stanley McChrystal, a smaller, lesser-known political monthly, The American Conservative (TAC), was publishing a blockbuster that by all rights should have had an even bigger impact.
Your ombuddy
Part internal-affairs cop, part complaint department, American news ombudsmen are truly a unique breed.
Less

Topics: This Just In , Rupert Murdoch, Arthur Sulzberger, Max Frankel, More

| More

ARTICLES BY IAN DONNIS

RHODY'S LOCAL FOOD MOVEMENT FINDS ITS GROOVE | February 23, 2009
Five years ago, when Farm Fresh Rhode Island (FFRI) launched its mission of promoting Ocean State-produced food, co-founder Noah Fulmer discovered a curious disconnection in the local food chain.

TICKET TO RIDE | February 11, 2009
In April 1999, two weeks after I started on the job at the Providence Phoenix , the FBI raided City Hall, formally unveiling the federal investigation that would land Vincent A. "Buddy" Cianci Jr., Rhode Island's rascal king, behind bars.

ADVOCATES RENEW PUSH FOR PUBLICLY-FINANCED RI ELECTIONS | February 04, 2009
During a news conference Tuesday afternoon in the State House rotunda, proponents of significantly expanding publicly financed elections in Rhode Island — a concept they call "Fair Elections" — cited a litany of reasons for why it would be good for the Ocean State and its citizens.

THE UPSIDE OF HOPE IN RHODE ISLAND | January 29, 2009
Everywhere one turns these days, there's seemingly more bad news about Rhode Island: the unemployment rate, one of the highest in the nation, tops 10 percent — and the state's running out of unemployment assistance.

BROGAN TAKES ON TEENS, SOCIAL NETWORKING IN TEASER | January 28, 2009
Former Providence Journal reporter Jan Brogan is out with her fourth mystery, Teaser .