The circumstances surrounding Margolis’s removal cannot make finding a replacement easier — that is, if the goal is to get a professional, rather than a hack or an efficient but pliant clerk.
Forcing the library to surrender the modest degree of fiscal autonomy it enjoys — Menino wants the city to dictate on a case-by-case basis how funds are spent, rather than approve lump sums for the library to use at its discretion, as has been done in the past — is not going to make the BPL presidency any more attractive.
His heavy-handedness with the library throughout the past year or so is not about improving the institution. It is about control. Menino should leave the trust funds alone. If he doesn’t, the trustees should resist his destructive meddling.
The nine members of BPL board of trustees, each appointed by the mayor, have two essential jobs: to make sure the institution is well managed and to insulate the library from undue political influence. The most vigorous defenders of an independent library have been State Representative Angelo Scaccia and former State Senate president William Bulger. So far, they have been silent on the issue. But then, that is their style. They tend to pursue a closed-door strategy, making their arguments in private rather than in public.
Friends of the library hope Scaccia and Bulger will fight this political takeover, which is being proposed under the bogus banner of good management. Too many of the recent trustees see their roles as servants of Menino rather than as stewards of the public trust, which the library represents.
There is no clash of big ideas in this confrontation. It is a rather primitive situation. The library has been — oddly enough — the only sector of the municipality (as opposed to a union) that has tried to resist Menino when it believes that principle is at stake. It’s curious that it is the battle for library independence that brings Menino’s style of governance into such sharp relief.