Of course, Wahl is speaking from an advocate’s perspective. But his argument makes sense journalistically, too. Think of the six basic questions that news stories are supposed to answer. Two of these — the “what” and the “why” — can only be adequately pursued if Marzilli’s illness is subjected to continued reporting. Did Marzilli have a history of mental problems? If so, what sort of treatment had he previously received? Just how often do individuals with bipolar disorder act in a sexually inappropriate manner? What sorts of socially aberrant behavior aren’t attributable to mental illness? (To cite another recent case involving a politician: is Elliot Spitzer a sex addict, or just a cad?) And when an individual is diagnosed with a severe psychiatric condition like bipolar disorder, how responsible should we hold them for what they say and do?
The first two questions feel intrusive. The last two lead, pretty quickly, into some weighty philosophical deliberations. But all of them are relevant. Not to pursue them in earnest would be, well, crazy.
To read the “Don’t Quote Me” blog, go to thePhoenix.com/medialog. Adam Reilly can be reached at areilly@phx.com.
Related:
Rise of psychosurgery, Arbitrary imprisonment, Reporter-turned-psychiatrist pans Virginia Tech coverage, More 
- Rise of psychosurgery
This article originally appeared in the March 11, 1972 issue of the Boston Phoenix.
- Arbitrary imprisonment
Joseph Steinberger thought he had won one of the most important trials of his legal career.
- Reporter-turned-psychiatrist pans Virginia Tech coverage
A searing backlash followed NBC’s airing of videos made by Seung-Hui Cho, who last month killed 32 Virginia Tech students and then himself.
- RI’s mental-health system is unraveling
More than 120 uninsured Rhode Islanders are waiting for mental health services at the Allen Berry Health and Dental Center on Prairie Avenue in Providence, according to one of its administrators.
- Bad sports
When historians trace the rise of the blog as the dominant journalistic form of the 21st century, they’ll pay close attention to two recent developments.
- Words as music
He originally set out to be a jazz critic.
- Sexual Politics
Duchovny, now 48 and with a nearly complete doctorate from Yale in English lit, says he is back in rehab for sex addiction.
- Three years and counting
For the past three years, Portland Phoenix contributing writer Lance Tapley has been the only reporter in Maine to pay attention to the appalling conditions suffered by inmates in the Maine State Prison
- Blowing up
Everyone’s got the bad-economy blues these days — but the mood among peddlers of the printed word is especially bleak.
- Strange bedfellows
Wait, lemme get this straight: Was that Howie Carr — who's known for accompanying on-air references to homosexuality with a crude audio approximation of gay sex — happily schmoozing with guest Randy Price this past week?
- He's number three
The conditions seem perfect for Kevin McCrea's latest YouTube video : warm for February, reasonably sunny, no sonic competition from nearby construction.
- Less
Topics:
Media -- Dont Quote Me
, U.S. Government, Wendy Murphy, Michael Levenson, More
, U.S. Government, Wendy Murphy, Michael Levenson, Michael Levenson, National Alliance on Mental Illness, sex, U.S. State Government, Health and Fitness, Crime, Harvard Medical School, Less
