Congress's war on toys

By LISSA HARRIS  |  February 9, 2009

The CPSC is stuck in a hard place, says Gidding — they're legally bound to enforce the law as written, no matter how flawed. If they overstep their authority by weakening it, they face possible lawsuits from the consumer-safety groups (Consumers Union, Consumer Federation of America, and US PIRG among them) who have been the CPSIA's biggest supporters. The law also leaves open the possibility that some crusading state attorney general could decide to enforce the testing requirements starting next week, even though the CPSC has backed off.

Truckloads of toys
Though last week's announcement was meant to give manufacturers a break, it may already be too late for some. Gidding says he has clients (he declines to name them) who have quietly sent truckloads of toys to the landfill.

"The manufacturing community is concerned," he says, "that, if they challenge the law, they will be branded as heartless baby-killers."

So far, the CPSIA's sponsors in the House, Democrats Henry Waxman from California and Bobby Rush from Illinois, have been content to let the CPSC take most of the heat for the confusion over the law. But there is some hope that Congress might fix the bill. Republican South Carolina senator Jim DeMint has introduced an amendment to narrow the scope of the CPSIA considerably, a proposal that might make for bizarre political alliances between South Carolina small-government zealots and hippie knitters from Somerville.

No matter what happens in the end, says Wilson, the consumer groups have lost a lot of credibility among the indie artisans, organic advocates, and environmentalists that should have been their biggest supporters on children's safety.

Says Wilson: "I'm canceling my Consumer Reports subscription."

Lissa Harris is a freelance journalist living in Boston. She can be reached at lissa.e.harris@gmail.com.

< prev  1  |  2  |  3  |  4  | 
Related: Congress bans kids from libraries?, Obama explained, Camelot: The Next Generation, More more >
  Topics: News Features , Business, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Congress,  More more >
| More


Most Popular
ARTICLES BY LISSA HARRIS
Share this entry with Delicious
  •   SURVIVE THE ECONOPOCALYPSE  |  June 11, 2009
    If you're like the more than nine percent of Americans currently unemployed, your "Yes We Can!" has lately lost some of its gusto. You've hit up everyone you know for work, including your mom, your ex, and your ex's ex.
  •   SURVIVING THE ECONOPOCALYPSE  |  June 11, 2009
    If you're like the more than nine percent of Americans currently unemployed, your "Yes We Can!" has lately lost some of its gusto. You've hit up everyone you know for work, including your mom, your ex, and your ex's ex.
  •   CAP AND TRADE EXPLAINED  |  May 06, 2009
    The general idea behind cap and trade is pretty simple: put a tax on pollution, and the market will crank out less of it. But if a pollution tax is a lever, cap and trade is a vast, rickety Rube Goldberg contraption. Ingenious? Yes. Complicated? Fiendishly.
  •   CONGRESS'S WAR ON TOYS  |  February 09, 2009
    Incredible, but true: until this past Friday, America was on a fast track to outlaw grandmothers selling children's sweaters for charity.
  •   CONGRESS BANS KIDS FROM LIBRARIES?  |  January 09, 2009
    Is it possible that Congress has just inadvertently turned millions of children’s books into contraband?

 See all articles by: LISSA HARRIS