The taste of sanctimony

Animal-rights activists flavor their philosophy with purity in Year of the Dog and a vegetarian food fest
By BRIAN DUFF  |  May 9, 2007
YEAR OF THE DOG: Molly Shannon cuddles up with emptiness.

Future generations, should they arrive, will look back on us with perplexed shame much the way we look back on our ancestors. But which of our habits (the use of incendiary weapons on civilians, abortion, failure to live according to the dictates of Sharia, capitalism, homophobia, the destruction of the environment) will they choose to excoriate?

Both the Maine Animal Coalition’s recent Vegetarian Food Festival and Mike White’s new film Year of the Dog (screening at the Nickelodeon in Portland) explore the idea that the confinement and killing of animals is the great moral shame of our time. It certainly might be. It is impossible to encounter the evidence of cruelty offered by animal-rights activists, or to ponder the statistics they wield, and not feel affected. In Peter Singer the animal-rights movement has the most persuasive and clear-minded philosopher to lead a political cause since Karl Marx represented the working class. In Ingrid Newkirk, head of People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals, they have one of the most compelling, funny, creative, and resilient activist leaders at work in the world.

But it is the stories of the rank and file that dominate both the film and the rhetoric on hand at the festival. The true victims of animal cruelty cannot speak, or even think, for themselves. So the stories of activists — the conversion narratives conveying how they came to abhor cruelty — carry a special burden in this movement. While freed slaves and Holocaust survivors wrote moving tales of liberation and the return to humanity, animal-rights activists can only offer other humans a sort of ascetic ideal. But promises of purity always carry the danger of self-righteousness and contempt. Based on film and festival, these activists don’t so much love animals as disdain the rest of us.

It might not please political vegans that in becoming passionate about protecting animals Peggy Spade (Molly Shannon), at first the most pleasant and well adjusted character in Year of the Dog, becomes humorless, dishonest, thieving, emotionally abusive to children, and potentially murderous. The film opens with scenes of Peggy’s happy tolerance of coworkers and family — each of whom unknowingly convey the busy meaninglessness of life’s human pursuits, especially love, parenthood, and career. Peggy’s own meaning comes from a healthy partnership with her beagle Pencil. When Pencil is accidentally poisoned, Peggy begins to trade the messy empathy of being human for the purity of advocacy for the innocent.

White, who has written several films but makes his directorial debut here, has always fixated upon the funny-sad emptiness of modern life. His characters seem heroic for attempting to redeem existence even if they do so in ways that are quirky, misguided and doomed to fail. In giving Peggy the most righteous task White makes her the least sympathetic. He managed to depict someone more compelling in a woman engaging in marital infidelity with a teenager (The Good Girl), a man stalking a married friend he once fellated as an adolescent (Chuck and Buck), or an adult manipulating fourth graders (School of Rock). While White’s previous characters misstep in the name of human connection, in her embrace of animal rights Peggy (and perhaps White) gives up on difficult work of loving her own species.

1  |  2  |  3  |   next >
Related: Cattle call, Dale Bozzio's life is so strange, 31. Ron Prentice, More more >
  Topics: Food Features , Entertainment, Culture and Lifestyle, Food and Cooking,  More more >
| More

Most Popular
Share this entry with Delicious
  •   LIMITS OF LANGUAGE  |  November 03, 2014
    Is it enlightened or provincial that we Mainers hear “ethnic” and don’t think, as many do, exclusively of non-Europeans?
  •   INFINITE BROOKLYNS  |  October 24, 2014
    Last year some national magazine said that Biddeford is to Portland as Brooklyn is to New York. No. Biddeford is a mash-up of Newburg and Poughkeepsie. It is East Bayside that is our Brooklyn.
  •   START DIGGING HERE  |  October 03, 2014
    Because music is now basically free (thanks to torrents, Pandoras, Spotifies, etc.), the only way for musicians to make money is through constant touring and related merchandise sales. Or they can appear as a judge on The Voice. Food, on the other hand, will still cost ya...
  •   PICK YOUR POISON  |  October 01, 2014
    The National Institutes of Health just published a randomized study that confirms the rumors: carbohydrates are poison and should be avoided. So how should we feel about Slab Sicilian Streetfood?
  •   A LITTLE WHINE  |  September 05, 2014
    The lessons of Lolita are that something simpler and less challenging can be lovely, and that some cheap wine could really loosen things up.

 See all articles by: BRIAN DUFF