Despite Finn’s linguistic brilliance, nothing evokes the Hold Steady’s essence more than the wordless choruses that punctuate “Stay Positive” and so many of the band’s sing-along songs. “Whoah-hoah-hoah” is ripe with meaning in the quintet’s hands, a joyful and communal cathartic shout. So it’s no surprise that the band returns to the sing-along scripture on “Slapped Actress,” the album’s closing song. It begins with them locked into a locomotive groove (driven by bassist Galen Polivka), revisiting Ybor City, Florida, site of some near-fatal parties. But they return home alive, and take control of their fate with a cinematic sweep. “We’re the directors,” Finn sings, “our hands will hold steady/I’ll be John Cassavetes/Let me know when you’re ready.” Then, as the song fades, the hope-filled chorus rises — “Whoah-hoah! Whoah-hoah-hoah-hoah! Whoah-hoah-hoah-hoah-hoah!” — capping Stay Positive and an epic four-album run that secures the Hold Steady’s spot in the pantheon of great American bands.

Whoah-hoah-hoah, indeed.

< prev  1  |  2  |  3  | 
Related: The Hold Steady, Craig’s list, Raising the Bar (Rock), More more >
  Topics: Music Features , Entertainment, Music, Music Reviews,  More more >
| More

Most Popular
Share this entry with Delicious
  •   BECK ON BECK  |  July 16, 2014
    "Every song has its own kind of life, its own gestation, its own way of working itself out."
  •   STAYING POSITIVE  |  April 09, 2014
    "When we started this band, we wanted to build something that was very inclusive."
  •   XL  |  August 15, 2012
    American Gothic was a subterranean shithole bar known for its existentially tortured clientele and extreme indifference to the minimum drinking age.
  •   'PEOPLE WANTED SOMETHING HONEST'  |  July 28, 2010
    In a world that's changing at the speed of light, the Gaslight Anthem reaches into the past to forge classic elements into a timeless rock and roll sound.
  •   FLANAGAN’S EMPIRE  |  February 05, 2010
    Once a staple of the pages of The NewPaper (original incarnation of The Providence Phoenix ), Warwick-born Bill Flanagan went on to become a prominent rock journalist whose credits include U2: At the End of the World , the definitive portrait of one of the world's biggest bands.

 See all articles by: MICHAEL ATCHISON