The debating game, part II

How will the Republican candidates stack up?
By STEVEN STARK  |  April 25, 2007


When the Republican presidential candidates gather for their first debate at the Reagan Library in California on Thursday, May 3, they may not say it openly but it will be on their minds: the party they seek to represent is in turmoil. Not only will one of the contenders inherit a GOP now discredited by the incumbent, but many voters who are dissatisfied with the current crop of candidates are hoping Fred Thompson or Newt Gingrich will enter the race.

As a result, the Republican contest so far has been rather dispirited. Five questions, to be answered on Thursday, are the key to analyzing the GOP debate. They are:

1) Does John McCain have a second act?
So far the story of the Republican race has been the failure of McCain, the former front-runner, to gain traction. Thursday night may not be make-or-break for him, but it’s close: he needs to put in a good enough performance to remind people why they once supported him, and perhaps even dissuade his old colleague, Fred Thompson, from announcing his candidacy in a few weeks.

This will be much easier said than done, since McCain not only seems shopworn, but has seemingly tied his campaign to the defense of Bush-administration policies in Iraq. That might win him some points for courage, especially among those Republicans who still support the war (and there are more than one might think), but it won’t do anything to reinvent his image as a maverick with broad appeal. This is a problem, since McCain has never been very popular with Republicans; it’s independents that gave him his base of support in 2000. Unfortunately, McCain is discovering that he can’t appeal to one group without alienating the other. On Thursday, he’ll either begin creating a coalition or his campaign will fall further apart.

2) Can a second-tier candidate do well enough to energize the Christian right and keep Fred Thompson out of the race?
If the debate isn’t quite make-or-break for McCain, it is exactly that for Sam Brownback, Tommy Thompson, Mike Huckabee, and all the candidates who rank below them in the polls. Each has the same dilemma: if he can’t somehow persuade conservative voters that he is the real thing — and let’s face it, in a debate of about ten people, that’s next to impossible — Fred Thompson will enter the race and effectively end his candidacy and that of every other also-ran.

All of these candidates are virtually unknown to the public (and to much of the press), so exceeding expectations shouldn’t be too difficult. But that won’t be enough. Take a good look at all the second- and third-tier candidates Thursday night, because chances are the next time the GOP field gathers, some of them will no longer be in the race.

3) How do the candidates handle Iraq?
When Jimmy Carter, my old boss, was running for president, he would tell his staff: “I don’t want to take any position in the primaries that will hurt me in the general election and as president.” In other words, he wasn’t going to say something for short-term gain that would cause long-term pain.

1  |  2  |   next >
Related: Rallying cries, Across the universe, The shape of things to come, More more >
  Topics: Stark Ravings , Mitt Romney, Barack Obama, Nancy Reagan,  More more >
| More

Most Popular
Share this entry with Delicious
  •   DEMOCRATS AGAINST OBAMA  |  November 03, 2010
    Now that the midterm wipeout has concluded, analysts are already sizing up the GOP challengers to a weakened Barack Obama. Not only that: some Democratic party elders are considering the once-unthinkable scenario of a debilitating challenge to Barack Obama from inside his party.
  •   THE INDEPENDENT HERD  |  October 06, 2010
    The big news in this election cycle is the rise of the Tea Party. Fair enough. But passing under the radar is an accompanying development that could have even more far-reaching consequences — the rise of an emboldened third force in our politics.
  •   THE AMERICAN IDOL PARTY  |  September 23, 2010
    Sarah Palin and Christine O'Donnell might not turn out to be good candidates, but they make great television.
  •   HAS OBAMA PEAKED? YES, HE HAS  |  November 12, 2009
    To listen to some pundits, Barack Obama's public image began taking a serious beating when the off-year election returns came in a week ago. Or maybe it was the undeserved Nobel Prize, his approach to the war in Afghanistan, or when he revved up his pursuit of national health-care reform.

 See all articles by: STEVEN STARK