Mahmoud Ahmadinejad

Tenure protects job security when free expression may be challenged in academia. An unspoken code of courtesy between campus rivals also prevails; professors with opposing views argue over lunch or spar over coffee. They may discreetly avoid each other or have heated debates. Public insults, however, are rare and are frowned upon as irrelevant to scholarly discourse.
Business competitors, courtroom rivals, political opponents, and the like also seek respectful exchange, publicly giving each other sufficient polite space. However deep antipathies may go, professionals learn to be courteously cool and detached.
Columbia University president Lee Bollinger failed miserably recently in all these areas. His stunningly rude and base remarks to Iranian president Mahmoud Ahmadinejad denigrate the academic freedom that Bollinger pretends to represent. Stinging, emotional insults aimed at a guest — who was invited by Bollinger — teach students nothing of intellectual or social value. Worse, Bollinger inflicts damage beyond Columbia, potentially dragging American academics through the mud of broad disdain.
There was risk in Columbia’s inviting the Iranian leader to speak, as there was in Ahmadinejad’s acceptance. But Ahmadinejad agreed to attend, to speak for a predetermined length of time, and to accept uncensored questions from the audience — actions that George W. Bush would doubtless avoid, were he invited to Tehran University.
Bollinger’s use of his podium to prejudge his guest’s remarks and to engage in name-calling — to appease alumni, donors and others — only shows Columbia’s students and the world how immature, how inept, and how insecure we can be.
The First Amendment protects Bollinger’s right to be a boor, just as it protects Ahmadinejad’s hyperbolic categorical belief that there are no gays in Iran. Real learning experiences come from listening to free discourse, digesting it, and re-examining it in discussions on and off campus.
There is already too much global disrespect for the United States. Caught in the hypocrisy of our deeds in Abu Ghraib and Guantanamo, versus our chastisement of other countries’ human-rights’ records, America is enslaved by a hopeless war it created, wasting a currency devalued throughout the first world.
Bollinger’s post 9/11 assault on an invited guest, insulted for what he might say even before he might say it, embarrassed all of us.
If, as speculated, threats from enraged alumni, trustees and/or donors fueled Bollinger’s bad judgment, then what happened at Columbia happens too often on US campuses.
Controversy unsettles contributors or trustees, and economic demands push ethics and philosophical commitments aside. A phone call is made, a threat implied, and sacrifices may be made, so the fund drive can reach its goal. In such cases, the educational experience is not the one that Bollinger envisioned in inviting Ahmadinejad, but that described by Shakespeare:

Who steals my purse steals trash . . .
But he that filches from me my good name
Robs me of that which not enriches him
And makes me poor indeed.

Related: Iran: the next crisis, Iran’s blogosfear, Innocent abroad, More more >
  Topics: This Just In , Politics, George W. Bush, World Politics,  More more >
| More

Most Popular
Share this entry with Delicious
  •   FERRARO, A PHOTO, AND A LEGACY  |  March 30, 2011
    Geraldine Ferraro's photograph stands proudly in a silver frame, inscribed to my daughter with the words, "You are my hero."
  •   TWO MURDERS AND AN UNHEEDED CALL  |  December 29, 2010
    When Rhode Islanders mention former Rhode Island Supreme Court Chief Justice Thomas Fay, they often focus on the scandal that forced him to resign from the bench.
    Angel Taveras may soon be Providence’s first Latino mayor. But his victory in the recent Democratic primary is much more than a triumph of the city’s growing Hispanic population.
    Recently OB-GYN Associates, a respected women's health care practice with offices in Rhode Island and Massachusetts, admitted to Rhode Island Department of Health officials that it had implanted in patients birth control intrauterine devices (IUDs) apparently manufactured in Canada and not approved by the United States Food and Drug Administration (FDA).
    Low-numbered plates may be Valhalla for Rhode Island’s vainglorious. But they are hard to come by. So for the average driver looking for attention, “vanity” and “special category” plates are the way to go.

 See all articles by: MARY ANN SORRENTINO