Catholic Tilt

James Carroll justifies his faith
By ADAM REILLY  |  April 2, 2009


Click here for the full transcript of Adam Reilly's interview with James Carroll.
If, sometime in the next few decades, humanity kicks the religion habit once and for all, the current crop of atheist agitators (Hitchens, Dawkins, etc.) will deserve plenty of credit. But they'll need to share that credit with the faithful who helped make faith absurd — and the hierarchy of the Catholic Church should get the first thank-you note.

Just last month, for example, Pope Benedict XVI kicked off a trip to Africa by announcing that condoms make the problem of AIDS worse — a statement that would be comical if its implications weren't so lethal. Earlier this year, the Pope rescinded the excommunication of Bishop Richard Williamson, the Holocaust-denying Catholic schismatic, and then seemed genuinely baffled at the ensuing furor. And let's not forget the priest sex-abuse scandal that began here in Boston, spread throughout the world, and revealed the mortifying extent to which the Catholic higher-ups had privileged a desire to keep up appearances over the safety of children.

And yet — despite deep dissatisfaction with much of Catholicism's status quo — a remarkable number of thoughtful, progressive men and women choose to remain in the Church. From the outside, this is a perplexing choice: if you're a frustrated Catholic liberal, why not cut your losses and go Episcopal? Or Unitarian? Or just bag religion altogether?

Enter James Carroll, the author and Boston Globe columnist, whose new book — Practicing Catholic (Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, $28) — could become, for Catholics of a certain stripe, what Bertrand Russell's essay "Why I am not a Christian" has long been for atheists.

Along with polymathic ex-Jesuit Garry Wills, Carroll is possibly the best-known contemporary example of a Catholic dissenter who remains deeply committed to the Church. But even if you're familiar with Carroll's oeuvre — or, given his scathing assessment of the Catholic past and present, especially if you know his work — you'd be hard pressed to say why he does so. (I worked for Carroll as a research assistant when he was writing Constantine's Sword: The Church and the Jews, which argued that Christian and Catholic anti-Judaism and anti-Semitism helped pave the way for the Holocaust, and never quite figured it out.)

Practicing Catholic is Carroll's attempt to explain his stubborn faith, both to his readers and to himself. Constantine's Sword was "a sad, tragic story," Carroll says today. "And one of the great questions I faced everywhere I went, and still face, was, 'Knowing this history, and being so clearly affected by it, how can you still be a Catholic?'

"I go to mass regularly because I need to and want to; it's a source of consolation and support and strength in my life," he adds. "But I'm not the kind of Catholic I was as a child, or a young man, or even a middle-aged man. I'm 66 years old — I'm able to imagine the end of my life in a way that I didn't used to be able to, so the meaning of the tradition is different now. And I knew that I would only be able to actually understand that meaning if I wrote this book."

1  |  2  |  3  |   next >
Related: Interview: James Carroll, Same-sex marriage, The problem with the Church's selective embrace, More more >
  Topics: Media -- Dont Quote Me , the Pope, Leonard Feeney, Pope John XXIII,  More more >
| More

Most Popular
Share this entry with Delicious
  •   BULLY FOR BU!  |  March 12, 2010
    After six years at the Phoenix , I recently got my first pre-emptive libel threat. It came, most unexpectedly, from an investigative reporter. And beyond the fact that this struck me as a blatant attempt at intimidation, it demonstrated how tricky journalism's new, collaboration-driven future could be.
  •   STOP THE QUINN-SANITY!  |  March 03, 2010
    The year is still young, but when the time comes to look back at 2010's media lowlights, the embarrassing demise of Sally Quinn's Washington Post column, "The Party," will almost certainly rank near the top of the list.
  •   RIGHT CLICK  |  February 19, 2010
    Back in February 2007, a few months after a political neophyte named Deval Patrick cruised to victory in the Massachusetts governor's race with help from a political blog named Blue Mass Group (BMG) — which whipped up pro-Patrick sentiment while aggressively rebutting the governor-to-be's critics — I sized up a recent conservative entry in the local blogosphere.
  •   RANSOM NOTES  |  February 12, 2010
    While reporting from Afghanistan two years ago, David Rohde became, for the second time in his career, an unwilling participant rather than an observer. On October 29, 1995, Rohde had been arrested by Bosnian Serbs. And then in November 2008, Rohde and two Afghan colleagues were en route to an interview with a Taliban commander when they were kidnapped.
  •   POOR RECEPTION  |  February 08, 2010
    The right loves to rant against the "liberal-media elite," but there's one key media sector where the conservative id reigns supreme: talk radio.

 See all articles by: ADAM REILLY