As David S. Bernstein reports, Boston just paid a $3.8 million settlement to Anthony Powell, who spent 12 years in prison for a 1991 rape and kidnapping until he proved, through DNA testing, that he was innocent. This only happened because Suffolk County's district attorney at the time, Ralph Martin — to his credit, and demonstrating one of his rare enlightened moments — agreed to turn over the DNA evidence for testing. Similarly, current DA Daniel Conley agreed to the testing that exonerated Stephan Cowans in 2004.
But without a state law, Powell and Cowans had to rely on the largesse of the district attorney — and many prosecutors have typically refused such requests, or fought against them for years. A potentially innocent person's hopes for justice should not lie solely in the hands or at the whim of individual DAs, who are most often biased toward preserving convictions, not reconsidering them.
Bills to change the status quo have been filed by State Senator Cynthia Creem and State Representative Eugene O'Flaherty, the co-chairs of the Joint Committee on the Judiciary. Similar bills have been filed in previous years and gone nowhere. Let's not wait until we are the very last state denying the right to prove one's innocence.
Related:
Corporate accountability, Financial fallout, Tax evasion, More
- Corporate accountability
Maybe, In the wake of his landslide win at this month’s democratic caucuses, Deval Patrick Is the new front-runner.
- Financial fallout
The current US financial disaster will roil Massachusetts residents in myriad ways.
- Tax evasion
There is such a thing as a stupid question
- Meet your Massachusetts Governor's Council
In this perilous economy, Governor Deval Patrick is faced with extraordinary economic challenges.
- School politics
Public education in Boston will be a hot-button issue in this year's municipal election in ways that have not been seen for at least 10 years.
- Can Sam Yoon win?
Recent elections, as you may have heard, have been about change.
- Tone deaf
March has not been kind to Deval Patrick.
- Is it Tim time?
Whereas a few months ago it seemed that no one could pose a serious threat to any re-election campaign mounted by Governor Deval Patrick, a recent string of missteps has suddenly made him very vulnerable.
- Time to wake up
The news that Massachusetts's finances are in even worse shape than previously thought was not exactly a surprise.
- Guilty until proven guilty
The US Supreme Court's June 18 decision denying prisoners access to DNA testing — a procedure that could reliably prove innocence — adds to the high court's decades-long shameful record on criminal-justice issues.
- Patrick's opponents
Charlie Baker, former head of Harvard Pilgrim Health Care and onetime finance chief for governors William Weld and Paul Cellucci, was scheduled to file papers this week to officially open his gubernatorial campaign. With that, he also unofficially kicks off the 2010 Massachusetts election season.
- Less

Topics:
The Editorial Page
, Deval Patrick, Deval Patrick, U.S. Government, More
, Deval Patrick, Deval Patrick, U.S. Government, U.S. State Government, John Roberts (Chief Justice), Judiciary, Daniel Conley, Eugene O'Flaherty, Massachusetts Cultural Council, U.S. Supreme Court, Less