Review: Scribblenauts

The pen is not so mighty
By MITCH KRPATA  |  October 7, 2009
2.5 2.5 Stars


Scribblenauts | For Nintendo DS | Rated E10+ for Everyone 10 and Older | Developed by 5th Cell | Published by Warner Bros. Interactive
If knowledge is power, and words are the vessels for ideas, then the appeal of Scribblenauts is easy to understand. This is a game that takes your words and makes them real — at least, real in the gamespace. Whatever you can imagine, Scribblenauts can conjure. Simply use the Nintendo DS's stylus to write your word, either freehand or on an on-screen keyboard. The in-game noun dictionary claims to have some 20,000 words, or considerably more than the average person's vocabulary. And it's hard to stump: brand names, profanity, and references to drugs and alcohol are verboten, but the game kept surprising me with how much it seemed to know, such as the difference between an ordinary motorcycle and a superbike (specifically, bad-ass styling on the latter).

Scribblenauts just gets tripped up when it comes to what you actually do with all those nouns. Although there's not much of a story, the premise has you controlling a cute lil' cartoon fellow named Maxwell in a quest to collect "starites," which are sort of like the power stars in Super Mario games but even more useless. Still, a puzzle game needs only the most tenuous thread of an objective, and starites are as good as any.

Gameplay takes two forms: "Action Mode," in which Maxwell needs to find a way to reach a starite somewhere in the level, and "Puzzle Mode," in which he must accomplish a goal for a non-player character, like helping a shepherd protect his flock from a wolf. The game types are not so different, yet Puzzle Mode is more satisfying, because its levels take the shape of a story, however rudimentary. Still, both modes require the same approach, which is to use your imagination to solve the puzzles. Sometimes this is very easy, such as typing in the word "ax" when you need to cut down a tree. More-complicated puzzles soon require a more advanced approach.

It's here that Scribblenauts' weakness starts to show. In theory, anything you conjure can be used with anything else, and setting up complex interactions is the key to success. But nothing ever seems to work quite right. When faced with a troublesome bee, I half-jokingly attempted to call forth a bee-eater bird. To my surprise, the bird, with its characteristic bright colors, popped right up. It then demonstrated no interest in eating the bee. Instead, I shot the bee with a crossbow. (In fact, it was distressing how often puzzles could be solved by shooting, burning, or exploding them, but that may say more about me than it does about the game.)

Many logical interactions don't work right, lots of objects appear out of proportion, and pluralization confounds the dictionary. "Termites" baffled it, though I was allowed to summon a single termite the size of a shih tzu. Many puzzles require you to manifest and pilot a vehicle, and though you can ride in a hovercraft, a bobsled, or the space shuttle, the control scheme ensures that you'll never go where you want. The vehicles often flip over for no apparent reason.

Scribblenauts deserves credit for taking a chance on something new. Turning a player's words into interactive playthings is too intrinsically appealing an idea to abandon in future games. The title screen offers nothing more than a blank canvas for players to write whatever words they want, with no objective, and it's the most fun part. In that sense, Scribblenauts is a heck of a toy. But it's not much of a game.

Related: Review: Chrono Trigger DS, Review: Afro Samurai, Review: Street Fighter IV, More more >
  Topics: Videogames , Culture and Lifestyle, Games, Hobbies and Pastimes,  More more >
| More

Most Popular
Share this entry with Delicious
  •   GET ON YOUR SNOW (RE)BOOTS: VIDEO GAME MAKEOVERS IN 2013  |  December 21, 2012
    With the PlayStation 3 and Xbox 360 now in their seventh and eighth years of existence, they've been around far longer than previous console generations.
  •   THINKING MAN'S ACTION: TOP GAMES OF 2012  |  December 19, 2012
    At some point, it stopped being a trend and became the reality: the most interesting, thought-provoking games aren't mega-budget retail releases, but smaller downloadable titles.
  •   BEYOND SHOOTERS  |  September 18, 2012
    In an era of scripted set pieces and action sequences that are no more than glorified shooting galleries, Dishonored aims to give players the tools to author their own experiences.
  •   REVIEW: DARKSIDERS II  |  September 04, 2012
    "Gentlemen, I'm not going to mince words. THQ is in trouble. We're bleeding cash, and we need a hit game to save our ass. I want you to tell me what you're going to do to make Darksiders II that game."
  •   REVIEW: ORCS MUST DIE! 2  |  August 21, 2012
    We're all happy to see more games that deal honestly and maturely with questions of life and death, and that question the player's role in perpetuating the cycle of violence.

 See all articles by: MITCH KRPATA