Critics slam plan to imprison juveniles at the ACIHard time July 2,
2007 6:14:52 PM
With the state planning to imprison some 17-year-old offenders at the Adult Correctional Institutions — in what has been plainly billed as a cost-saving move — critics warn that the move could bring a raft of negative consequences.
“I think people should be absolutely outraged,” says Teny Gross, executive director of the Institute for the Study & Practice of Nonviolence in South Providence, who works with young people in the city. “Some people in the Senate have told us that this was the worst part in the budget.” And with Providence being a minority-majority city, too many people have the outlook, Gross adds, that young people are expendable.
On the surface, trying 17 year olds as adults, and keeping these offenders at the ACI, rather than the state Training School, is about half as costly. Yet Gross notes how the plan also threatens to make younger offenders “more institutionalized,” in part by putting them into contact with more serious offenders. “None of us who work with young people doubt that this will have costly effects,” he says. “If it saves money, how about we start at 14?”
With the new measure slated to take effect at 12:01 a.m. this past Sunday, no juveniles had been brought to the ACI as of lunch time on Monday, according to Tracey Z. Poole, a spokeswoman for the Rhode Island Department of Corrections.
While Corrections officials were still figuring out the new regulations, Poole says, it was her understanding that newly arrested 17 year olds who are held by the state prior to trial will now wind up at the ACI, unless judges waive them out of adult court.
The plan to save money by trying 17 year olds as adults was developed by the state Department of Children, Youth and Families (DCYF). “The governor recognizes that there are no easy answers to resolving the budget deficit, and this proposal demonstrates that,” says Michael Maynard, a spokesman for Governor Donald L. Carceri. At the same time, notes Maynard, “Not every 17 year old who is convicted is going to go to the ACI.”
For 17 year olds now tried as adults, their juvenile records will not be considered at sentencing. This means, Maynard says, that individuals convicted in such cases would be first-time offenders, making them most likely to receive probation as a sentence. “It’s not as cut and dried as where every 17-year-old who commits a crime is going to go to the ACI,” he says.
To critics, though, the idea of even putting some juveniles in an adult prison represents a slippery slope.
Gross describes the measure as a double-whammy for disadvantaged young people in the state, since they enjoy fewer benefits while growing up and will now face the prospect of stiffer punishment for crimes committed as a juvenile.
While changes seem unlikely in the short term, advocates plan to continue organizing and working behind the scenes. As Gross puts it, “This is a very sobering one for me. I am not negotiating the 17. This is non-negotiable for me.”
|
 |
|
- Ever higher
- Why can’t more writers be smart enough to be beautiful, handsome, or at least cute
- What is it about The Globe’s Dan Shaughnessy that makes ordinary, peaceable people want to kick his ass?
- These guys couldn't turn on a radio
- Better than a Duck Tour
- Freedom Watch
- Why can’t more writers be smart enough to be beautiful, handsome, or at least cute
- ‘Whither goest thou, America, in thy shiny car in the night?’ . . . Lowell?!
- The 20 best musical moments on the original Muppet Show.
- Or why the FCC should go fuck itself
- Shakespeare navigates Brustein’s English Channel
- Will Brattle Street torpedo him again?
|
-
The long-dormant IWW raises its profile in Rhode Island
-
Got Beer?
-
Activism
-
As the ProJo turns
-
A Rhode Island icon sails back into the limelight
-
Talking politics
-
The Papitto controversy reveals some ingrained truths about race and institutions
-
Techies and digital innovators are injecting fresh life into the Rhode Island economy
-
Talking politics
|
|