LISTINGS |  EDITOR'S PICKS | NEWS | MUSIC | MOVIES | DINING | LIFE | ARTS | REC ROOM | CLASSIFIEDS | VIDEO

The million-dollar widow

Why is the Niki Tsongas juggernaut heading backward? Plus, ignoring global warming close to home.
July 26, 2007 12:11:13 PM

0707020_politics_main
DARLING NIKI: The widow of Senator Paul Tsongas has raised more money than her rivals, but is losing ground in the polls.

The powerhouses of Massachusetts’s Democratic Party have rallied behind Niki Tsongas’s bid to succeed Fifth District US Congressman Marty Meehan, and their support has helped bring an impressive million dollars in contributions to her campaign’s coffers. Those party elites assumed that their support and cash, combined with her name recognition, should by now have made her a shoo-in for the nomination: competitors should be dropping out, unions should be clamoring to join her winning team, and polls should show her widening her lead.

But that doesn’t seem to be happening. According to a number of people following the race, the Democratic nomination appears to be as wide open as ever.

In fact, a recent poll conducted by competitor Eileen Donoghue, the former mayor of Lowell, showed that, since the start of the race, Tsongas’s support has dropped from 35 to 26 percent among likely voters in the September 4 Democratic primary. In response, her campaign replaced its field director (in what seemed to be an admission that the campaign was stumbling), hiring Augustus Bickford this past week to improve the ground organization that will make or break the get-out-the-vote effort come Election Day. (Please see Editor's Note, below.)

In a way, Tsongas’s failure to dominate the race is unsurprising — if anything, it’s surprising that the party powers flocked to Tsongas despite her obvious flaws as a candidate. Aside from having been married to the late former senator Paul Tsongas, she has little relevant experience for the job, having never held public office nor played a significant role in any government agency. (Currently she serves as dean of external affairs at Middlesex Community College.) Tsongas also has been living outside the district, and her generally progressive ideology is almost indistinguishable from that of the other major candidates, including Donoghue and State Representatives Barry Finegold and Jamie Eldridge.

That’s not to say that Tsongas would be a poor choice to represent the Fifth District. If their conversations with the Phoenix are any indication, even other campaigns’ staffers seem to like her. But some observers are wondering: why did all the party powerhouses take her side in a race that features several strong Democratic candidates?

Some of the other candidates’ staffs and supporters are miffed that so many top Dems lined up behind Tsongas so quickly. After all, Tsongas’s contributors comprise a virtual Who’s Who of the state’s Democratic fundraisers (Ronald Ansin, Steve Grossman, Alan Solomont, Barry White), former officeholders (Cheryl Cronin, Scott Harshbarger), lobbyists (Thomas O’Neill, Robert White), developers (Robert Beal, Jay Cashman), and cultural leaders (Charles Ansbacher, Susan Paine, Josiah Spaulding).

Plus, many of the most influential women in the state have jumped on her bandwagon. JudyAnn Bigby, Mary Breslauer, Nonnie Burnes, Elyse Cherry, Jane Garvey, Barbara Grossman, Swanee Hunt, Gloria Larson, Barbara Lee, Jesse Mermell, and Elaine Schuster have all contributed to the Tsongas campaign.

It’s the kind of coordinated women’s support you might expect to converge around a promising female politician, but not when two viable women are running against each other. And it’s particularly odd to see politically influential women rejecting Donoghue, the more experienced woman in the race, in favor of the candidate known mostly by her husband’s work. Even EMILY’s List, which routinely promotes women running for office, has taken the unusual step of endorsing and raising money for Tsongas — as if Donoghue didn’t exist.

The explanation may be that Democratic insiders, though not necessarily convinced that Tsongas is the best candidate, got behind her because of early signs that she was going to romp in the primary. That’s the view of one political consultant, who is not working for any of the candidates. Others see it the other way around: those donors are trying to clear the path to victory, by creating a sense of inevitability with their support.

Either way, comparisons to Tom Reilly are increasingly heard. Like Tsongas, Reilly had the early support, and funding, of the Democratic elites when he ran for governor in 2006. He finished third in September’s primary. A similar fate befell Deb Goldberg in the primary for lieutenant governor. If what happened to her happens to Tsongas, will the Democratic insiders have any credibility left?

Tsongas’s monopoly on those party insiders has seriously hurt Donoghue’s ability to raise money — but, according to one of her campaign advisors, she’s willing to spend whatever it takes from her own pocket to compete. Finegold has been a juggernaut, raising more than $700,000, with $450,000 still on hand — almost as much as Tsongas, when you subtract over-the-limit contributions she can’t use until the general election. Eldridge, meanwhile, has carved out a niche as the lefty candidate, and has raised more than a quarter-million, which is impressive for a relative unknown.


pages: 1 | 2
COMMENTS

I find it odd that this article is being represented as news. First, all of the "sources" are anonymous. Second, why wasn't the Tsongas campaign contacted for comment? And third, most of this article seems to be personal attacks. The only source of credibility that this article tries to lend to itself is an internal poll of another candidate. When read in its entirety, this article seems biased and also indicates the strong possibility that some other campaign has the ear of Bernstein. The only news that this article displays is that Bernstein is trying to fabricate a loss of steam in one campaign through the unsubstantiated and uncredited thoughts of others. Ridiculous.

POSTED BY JBlank AT 07/19/07 1:57 PM
I think this article really points out the obvious flaws in the Tsongas campaign. If it is biased, it is only biased against Tsongas, not to favor someone else. Bernsteing brings up some valid criticisms of both the politicians who have jumped on the bangwagon and their rush to get on board with Niki. Who do you support Jblank? You obviously have a bias.

POSTED BY Factcheck AT 07/19/07 2:13 PM
I think the author got it right when he questions Tsongas's supposed appeal to prominent political backers. Never held public office, little relevant experience, few accomplishments in public agencies — it seems like the Tsongas "brand" is her main asset for the post. However, just a name with lots of money will not win a race. Having seen her in a debate, I find her answers to be spoken well, but lacking in deep analysis and short on political courage. Eileen Donoghue has a solid record of achievement in the Merrimack Valley, and addresses each issue with an incisive intellect and compassionate values. She also has the organization to produce the voters that will tell the tale on Primary Day. If money and a name were all that was required to win, Ross Perot would be president!

POSTED BY Claudia Nangle AT 07/19/07 2:30 PM
You dismiss an awful lot of people as "insiders" and take very little time to cover Niki Tsongas' experiences which just don't happen to be in elective office. Niki and Paul Tsongas were a team to look up to in terms of their ethics, intellect, courage and mutual respect. We could do a lot worse than to endorse and vote for those qualities. Paul Tsongas was hardly an insider. When did Niki become one? Maybe when she had the nerve to raise enough money to win? Finally, when did Eileen Donoghue become Eleanor Roosevelt and Ann Richards rolled into one. I mean she's a multi-term City Councilor in Lowell. JA

POSTED BY johnny appleseed AT 07/21/07 12:53 AM

Login to add comments to this article
Email

Password




Register Now  |   Lost password

MOST POPULAR

 VIEWED   EMAILED 

ADVERTISEMENT

BY THIS AUTHOR

PHOENIX MEDIA GROUP
CLASSIFIEDS







TODAY'S FEATURED ADVERTISERS
   
Copyright © 2008 The Phoenix Media/Communications Group