Review: Pom Wonderful Presents: The Greatest Movie Ever Sold

Reviews

A Good Woman

Rating: 2 stars

By CHRIS WANGLER | February 2, 2006

2.0 Stars

The past catches up with an ageing seductress in Mike Barker’s flaccid version of Lady Windermere’s Fan, Oscar Wilde’s classic comedy of manners. Newly arrived in Amalfi, Lady Erlynne (Helen Hunt) jumps into an affair with a young businessman who turns out to be married to her long-lost daughter, Meg Windermere (Scarlett Johansson). Keeping her identity under wraps, but finally ready to be “a good woman,” Erlynne almost ruins her own fortunes to prevent Meg from cheating on her husband in retaliation. Although Wilde’s tasty one-liners still crackle (e.g., “We are all in the gutter, but some of us are looking at the stars”), you wonder whether this superfluous genre exercise, which includes far too many bored British playboys, wouldn’t have worked better in the stuffy confines of Victorian London, its natural habitat, and with no Americans whatsoever. Please God, let this be the last period piece for ScarJo.

Related: The war games, Wilde thing, No alibi needed, More

Topics: Reviews , Entertainment, Performing Arts, Scarlett Johansson, More

| More

ARTICLES BY CHRIS WANGLER

REVIEW: CRANK: HIGH VOLTAGE | April 21, 2009
Chinese triads. Corey Haim. Porn actors on strike. REO Speedwagon. Yes, the creators of this nearly unwatchable sequel will use anything to achieve their twisted goal: to shock ADHD teenagers.

REVIEW: SUNSHINE CLEANING | March 18, 2009
What lifts this tasty little dramedy above Sundance mediocrity is a pathos that overcomes all the "quirky" dysfunctional contrivance.

REVIEW: PUSH | February 11, 2009
Teens with special powers? A government conspiracy?

REVIEW: CHANDNI CHOWK TO CHINA | January 13, 2009
Director Nikhil Advani's quirky Chinese-Indian collaboration is the widest release ever of a Bollywood film, and the first ever kung fu Bollywood comedy.