The Phoenix Network:
 
 
About  |  Advertise
 
Features  |  Reviews
Best2012Vote-1000x50

Review: The Lemon Tree

A sometimes engaging allegory
By PETER KEOUGH  |  April 29, 2009
2.5 2.5 Stars


VIDEO: The trailer for The Lemon Tree

Message gets entangled with melodrama to the benefit of neither in Eran Riklis's sometimes engaging allegory of the Israeli/Palestinian standoff. Widowed Salma (Hiam Abbass) lives off the old lemon grove on the West Bank left to her by her father.

It's a lovely spot, so the new Israeli defense minister decides to plant his homestead next to it — which means, for reasons of security, that Salma's trees will have to be uprooted. Championed (and wooed, sort of) by Ziad (Ali Suliman), a young Palestinian lawyer, she takes her case to the Supreme Court. In the midst of Riklis's earnest preaching and untidy soap opera, an occasional acute detail shines. But the premise is best critiqued by the soldier who chides Salma when she brings her case to an Israeli military office.

These are people with real problems, he says, pointing to the dozens in line. True, and they're probably still waiting while Salma's bittersweet fable gets made into a movie.

Related: Company One takes on Jason Grote's whirling 1001, W. gets a B, Why so serious?, More more >
  Topics: Reviews , Politics, World Politics, Israeli Politics,  More more >
| More

 Friends' Activity   Popular   Most Viewed 
[ 02/14 ]   The Addams Family  @ Shubert Theatre
[ 02/14 ]   "Aphrodite and the Gods of Love"  @ Museum of Fine Arts
[ 02/14 ]   "Processes and Dreams"  @ Panopticon Gallery
ARTICLES BY PETER KEOUGH
Share this entry with Delicious
  •   REVIEW: THE OSCAR NOMINATED SHORT FILMS 2012: DOCUMENTARY  |  February 10, 2012
    The films in this program contain some of the most powerful images to be seen on the screen this year.
  •   REVIEW: JOURNEY 2: THE MYSTERIOUS ISLAND  |  February 07, 2012
    I liked the tiny elephants and the Rock bouncing berries off his pecs, but Brad Peyton's sequel is as bad as the 2008 original.
  •   REVIEW: CHRONICLE  |  February 02, 2012
    Poor Andrew (Dane DeHaan) has more problems than any movie teenager deserves.
  •   REVIEW: ONE FOR THE MONEY  |  January 31, 2012
    TV director Julie Anne Robinson's insipid adaptation of this first volume in Janet Evanovich's Stephanie Plum series has more in common with Young Adult than with the average gumshoe yarn.
  •   REVIEW: BIG MIRACLE  |  January 31, 2012
    Taking a tip from the oil industry, Hollywood has started exploiting Alaska. Following in the tracks of The Grey is Ken Kwapis's take on a true story from 1988 about an effort to save gray whales trapped in the Arctic ice. Surprisingly, the film offers genuine complexity.

 See all articles by: PETER KEOUGH

MOST POPULAR
RSS Feed of for the most popular articles
 Most Viewed   Most Emailed