CD Reviews

The Roots | Rising Down

Def Jam

By RICHARD BECK | May 12, 2008

2.5 Stars

Following 2002’s Phrenology, a stylistically schizophrenic album that left no pop-musical stone unturned, the Roots adopted the principle of addition by subtraction, and on Rising Down that ethos has reached a kind of logical conclusion. Drummer Amir “?uestlove” Thompson’s vision of political despair makes for some unrelentingly bleak shit: paranoid, roiling bass lines, ferocious breakbeat attacks, and little else. Black Thought, working with a team of guest MCs that includes Talib Kweli and Saigon, is as technically skilled as always, even if he does have a tendency to state the obvious. (What’s that you say? Global warming is bad?) For all their well-placed anger, these rappers seem a little paralyzed. Sure they can evoke school shootings, substance addiction, and terrorism, but what to do with all that vivid description? Still, Rising Down is a grim mirror of a particular time and place, one that will still be worth the look when (if?) things get better somewhere down the line.

Related: Bubbling under, An abridged history of the Roots' collabs, They get ill, More

Topics: CD Reviews , Entertainment, Hip-Hop and Rap, Music, More

| More

ARTICLES BY RICHARD BECK

PLUCK AND DETERMINATION | March 09, 2010
People have always thought that Joanna Newsom was indulgent. At first, it was about her voice — the kind of nasal yelp that usually keeps a performer from getting on stage at all. Then, on her second album, it was about her vocabulary and her instrumentation.

SONG OF HERSELF | August 05, 2009
"Listen, I will go on record saying I love Feist, I love Neko Case. I love that music. But that shit's easy listening for the twentysomethings. It fucking is. It's not hard to listen to any of that stuff."

DJ QUIK AND KURUPT | BLAQKOUT | June 15, 2009
LA hip-hop has two threads, and DJ Quik pulls both of them. The first is g-funk, a production style that relies on deep, open grooves and an endless parade of funk samples.

FLIPPER | LOVE | May 26, 2009
Flipper formed in San Francisco in 1979, and they're remembered three decades later because of a song called "Sex Bomb" that's one of the funniest pieces of music I've ever heard.

ST. VINCENT'S ACTOR GETS A RUN-THROUGH | May 26, 2009
There were not one but two clarinets on stage at the Somerville Theatre on Tuesday night, and that gives you some idea of how intricate Annie Clark's chamber-pop compositions can be.