Why the Senate must defeat the constitutional amendment prohibiting ‘desecration’
By EDITORIAL | June 21, 2006
SPIRIT OF ’06: The timing of the flag-desecration amendment reflects deep insecurity about what this nation stands for. |
The United States is on the verge of joining China, Cuba, and Iran as the only nations in the world where “desecrating” the flag is a national crime. Sometime in the next several days, the Senate is expected to vote on a constitutional amendment, already approved by the House, that would put this nation — the world’s oldest constitutional republic — in the same league as Communists and Islamist theocrats. It’s a staggering development. A year ago, a joke like this would be too bizarre for even The Daily Show’s Jon Stewart. But television comedians apparently don’t have a sense of the absurd as finely developed as that of the US Congress.At the moment, the Senate is one vote away from adopting the measure. Senate majority leader Bill Frist, the right-wing Republican from Tennessee who is flogging the amendment, says it is every bit as important to our national well-being as outlawing same-sex marriage. That dubious proposal went down in flames just a few weeks ago. The prospects for the desecration amendment are too close to call. Both measures, however, share a disturbing common denominator: they are a base and sleazy move by fundamentalists of both parties to pander to the know-nothing elements of the electorate. In the name of protecting the physical symbol of the stars and stripes, proponents violate the expansive — and occasionally uncomfortable — principles that animate its spirit. The object is to corner the market in uninformed and misdirected patriotism just months ahead of what is shaping up to be the most closely contested midterm elections in recent memory. The exercise offers pathetic testimony to the wisdom of Samuel Johnson’s observation, “patriotism is the last refuge of scoundrels.”
The sad news is that among the scoundrels this time, there are a number of usually sensible and often admirable elected officials, such as Democratic senators Dianne Feinstein of California and Jay Rockefeller of West Virginia, and Republican senators Olympia Snowe and Susan Collins, both of Maine. The Democratic senators from Massachusetts, Vermont, Connecticut, and Rhode Island all oppose the amendment, as does Republican Lincoln Chaffee of Rhode Island. Also in opposition is Democratic senator Hilary Clinton of New York, the co-sponsor of another less sweeping but equally wrong-headed piece of legislation that may stop short of the drastic step of amending the constitution but would outlaw flag desecration nonetheless — in vague-yet-still-disturbing ways. All that can be said in favor of her measure is that it at least provides an element of political cover for those without the guts to stand by freedom of expression, even when it takes on deeply troubling forms. If that’s consolation, it is sad indeed. It also reflects the kind of wishy-washy vision she brings to her presidential campaign.
Related:
Mike Dillon's Go-Go Jungle, Gays and the GOP, Yayo for president?, More 
- Mike Dillon's Go-Go Jungle
The opening “Go-Go’s Theme,” with its heavy backbeat and bar-band tenor-sax theme, screams: “We’re jazz, but not boring!”
- Gays and the GOP
The latest chapter of the Log Cabin Republicans launched on December 30 in Portland.
- Yayo for president?
Bad news for cokeheads everywhere: the chances of Bolivia becoming for cocaine users what Amsterdam is for pot smokers are slim.
- Love and politics
In Boleros for the Disenchanted , Puerto Rican–born José Rivera looks beyond the fairy dust and sexual spark to probe the full meaning of “till death do us part.”
- Vandal-in-chief
Shepard Fairey and his show "Supply and Demand" arrive at the Institute of Contemporary Art like a guerrilla general emerging from the jungle after his forces have taken the capital.
- Hey guv: stop slashing!
It seems as if there’s no light at the end of the state’s gloomy fiscal tunnel.
- Maine-ufacturing consent
Typical of the exposure given 77-year-old MIT linguistics professor and philosopher Noam Chomsky by most American news media, he was blanked out by the Portland Press Herald , and there was no coverage by the Portland TV news shows or Maine Public Radio.
- The 100 unsexiest men 2007: 100-91
These guys couldn't turn on a radio
- The 100 unsexiest men 2007: 60-51
These guys couldn't turn on a radio
- After the room clears
Somebody really smart wrote this, four years ago: “Maine’s influence in determining the next occupant of the White House will be somewhere between minimal and undetectable.”
- Advantage: Whitehouse
It was just one more in a steady stream of campaign stops, efforts that might land Sheldon Whitehouse six months from now in the most exclusive club in the nation.
- Less
Topics:
The Editorial Page
, U.S. Government, Election Campaigns, U.S. Congressional News, More
, U.S. Government, Election Campaigns, U.S. Congressional News, Elections and Voting, Politics, George W. Bush, Hillary Clinton, Jon Stewart, Olympia Snowe, Susan Collins, Less
