The Nanny Diaries

A shrill disappointment

By PETER KEOUGH | August 22, 2007

1.0 Stars

VIDEO: Watch the trailer for The Nanny Diaries.

The rich may be different from you and me, but they’re probably not much like the grotesque stereotypes in Shari Springer Berman & Robert Pulcini’s adaptation of this glib bestseller. They’ve reduced it to the shrillest formula. Annie (Scarlett Johansson), a working-class college grad from New Jersey, becomes the punching-bag enabler for “Mrs. X” (Laura Linney), a “Fifth Avenue mother,” filthy rich, idle, neurotic, and far too busy to spend time with her charmless and spoiled four-year-old. Annie not only submits to the boy’s every whim but gamely serves as an outlet for Mrs. X’s fury at the boorish infidelities of Mr. X (Paul Giamatti as a troll). Surely, an hour and a half of such torture must end with a confrontational speech to a teddy bear, the deification of motherhood, and the vindication of PB&Js as better than coquilles Saint-Jacques? Phony from start to finish, and a shocking disappointment from the makers of American Splendor.

Related: Yankee know-how, Are we grading on a curve?, Primary concerns, More

Topics: Reviews , Celebrity News, Entertainment, Media, More

| More

Most Popular

The Current Issue

Table of Contents

Cover Archive

Masthead | Authors | Contact us

Blogs

Where To Follow Me
Talking Politics | March 24, 2013 at 11:09 AM

Mo Takes His Turn
March 21, 2013 at 12:59 PM

[Q&A] KMFDM's Sascha Konietzko on art, Columbine and having balls
On The Download | March 18, 2013 at 3:22 PM

See this film series: The Belmont World Film Series @ Studio Cinema in Belmont
Outside The Frame | March 18, 2013 at 11:00 AM

See this film: This is Spinal Tap [with post-film talk by expert from Acoustical Society of America] @ the Coolidge
March 17, 2013 at 12:00 PM

ARTICLES BY PETER KEOUGH

BUFFET DINING: THE 15TH BOSTON UNDERGROUND FILM FESTIVAL | March 19, 2013
"Copraphagy" is a key word at this year's Boston Underground Film Festival at the Brattle.

REVIEW: GINGER & ROSA | March 19, 2013
Sally Potter likes to mess around with form and narrative.

UNDERGROUND CINEMA: THE 12TH BOSTON TURKISH FILM FESTIVAL | March 12, 2013
This year's Boston Turkish Film Festival includes works in which directors ponder the relationships between the secular and the religious, between men and women, and between destiny and identity.

REVIEW: A GLIMPSE INSIDE THE MIND OF CHARLES SWAN III | March 12, 2013
In Roman Coppola's sophomoric second feature (his 2001 debut CQ was promising), Charlie Sheen shows restraint as the titular asshole, a dissolute ad designer and solipsistic whiner who's mooning over the loss of his latest love.

REVIEW: UPSIDE DOWN | March 14, 2013
Had Ed Wood Jr. directed Fritz Lang's Metropolis , he couldn't have achieved the earnest dopiness of Juan Solanas's sci-fi allegory — nor the striking images.