Interview: Brett Morgen defends his Chicago 10
By PETER KEOUGH | February 27, 2008
One of the great principles of American jurisprudence, though not necessarily of film criticism, is a defendant’s right to confront his accuser in a court of law. I’m no accuser, but I did have some criticisms of Brett Morgen’s innovative new documentary Chicago 10, which uses archival footage and animation to dramatize the bloody demonstrations at the Democratic National Convention in Chicago in 1968 and the subsequent trial of the alleged ringleaders. Since I’m an admirer of some of Morgen’s previous work, in particular his portrait of Hollywood mogul Robert Evans in The Kid Stays in the Picture (winner of the Boston Society of Film Critics’ Best Documentary award in 2002), I thought I’d give him a chance to respond to some of my reservations in the Phoenix’s version of a court of law — “Back Talk.”I saw this movie with a bunch of geezers like myself, and one of the biggest criticisms was the soundtrack. Why use anachronistic music instead of music from the ’60s, a time when the music was so interconnected with the politics?
Because it’s not a movie about 1968. I thought that by using contemporary music over images that are almost 40 years old it brought the past into the present the way that wouldn’t happen if I’d used Buffalo Springfield at that moment. I think the music of the ’60s has become so clichéd.
Like it’s all being used in SUV commercials?
Exactly — it no longer has the impact that it had at the moment. It would ultimately alienate a young audience, which I’m trying to get at with this film. I didn’t want to use the soundtrack of my parents’ generation. I wanted to use the soundtrack of my generation. [Morgen was born in October, 1968, two months after the Democratic Convention.] There wasn’t music in 1968 that, to me, would capture the energy . . . what was I going to use, Phil Ochs? I mean, it was after Chicago that music got a little angrier and a little darker. Certainly, I open myself up for criticism in doing this — and it would have been a lot safer to use traditional music of the era. For every boomer I alienate, though, I believe that I’m engaging a younger audience. When you’re dealing with archival imagery, the only way to modernize it is through sound design and score. So you take that scene with the Beastie Boys and it doesn’t seem 40 years old anymore.
Another problem I had was that the film offers little political context. What were the issues in the convention itself, and what were the consequences of the demonstrations for the country? Despite their intentions, you could say they got Richard Nixon elected.
One of the things I wanted to do was make a movie that’s rooted in ’68 but that’s really, ultimately, about today. Chicago 10, as you noticed, has very little context in the year ’68. The movie is more of a parable or fable for all times.
Related:
Face off, Review: The Boys Are Back, City of Angels at Lyric Music Theater, More 
- Face off
If you were an ordinary Catholic boy in parochial school, giving nuns as hard a time as you were getting, you probably ended up with the usual stories of ruler-rapped knuckles. If you grew up to be talented playwright John Patrick Shanley, you ended up writing Doubt: A Parable , a fascinating exploration of the quicksand of certainty.
- Review: The Boys Are Back
Director Scott Hicks ( Shine ) returns to warm hearts with the saga of Joe Warr, a journalist (based on real-life columnist Simon Carr, and played by Clive Owen) whose second wife (Laura Fraser) dies of cancer, leaving him a single father with a hands-off parenting style.
- City of Angels at Lyric Music Theater
It's 1940s Hollywood, and we swerve between Stine's reality and Stone's parallel one, in City of Angels , a musical comedy-cum-musical noir , directed by Mary Meserve for South Portland's Lyric Music Theater.
- Earning his wings
Delroy Lindo is only 6’3”, but he plays a lot bigger on screen.
- After Pauline
“Why Aren’t There More Women Film Critics?” was the subject of a January 31 forum at the Boston Public Library, and nobody on our panel came up with much of an answer.
- Review: Gomorrah
Matteo Garrone's Gomorrah is a jolting and utterly original take on the gangster movie.
- Review: Me and Orson Welles
With Orson Welles, it's all in the voice — which over the course of four decades could sell anything from a Martian invasion to Paul Masson wine.
- Review: Gentlemen Broncos
Having peaked with his debut, Napoleon Dynamite , Jared Hess has settled into being a family-friendly John Waters — which is redundant, since Waters is already rated PG-13.
- Review: Whatever Works
It happens to everyone: getting old means getting more annoying. Those endearing little quirks degenerate into insufferable pathologies, the funny stories become less funny with repetition, and in general the same old self-depreciating ironies and obsessive-compulsive hedges against mortality stop working.
- World without end
By the time it got to the anthropomorphic bunnies acting out a sit-com to a laugh track (or are they donkeys? subscribe to www.davidlynch.com to learn more), I knew that Inland Empire was David Lynch at his most seductive and a film I’d be thinking about for a lot more than the rest of the afternoon. Watch the trailer for Inland Empire (YouTube) Say ‘cheese’: Milking Laura Dern’s performance. By Peter Keough
- Too close for comfort?
The cast and crew of V for Vendetta speaks; you download.
- Less
Topics:
Features
, Politics, U.S. Politics, Political Parties, More
, Politics, U.S. Politics, Political Parties, U.S. Democratic Party Politics, Entertainment, Movies, Richard Nixon, Democratic National Committee, Movie Reviews, The Beastie Boys, Less
