Borges-gate revisited

Lesson One: the perils of sharing
By ADAM REILLY  |  March 8, 2007


Forget two months without Ron Borges. When the Boston Globe's latest plagiarism scandal subsides, the lasting impact could be a major change in the way the paper’s sports-notes columnists — Borges for football, Peter May for basketball, Kevin Paul Dupont for hockey, and Nick Cafardo for baseball — do their business every week.

In case you missed it, Borges — a much-read, much-reviled football writer who also covers boxing — was suspended without pay for two months on March 5, after the Web site revealed that he’d recycled material from a Tacoma News Tribune item in his March 4 “Football Notes.” The official announcement of Borges’s suspension, which was posted on Monday evening, reported that Borges subscribes to “an online notes exchange used by NFL writers, who share information with one another in advance of Sunday notebook columns that run in many newspapers.”

When Globe sportswriters Peter Gammons and Will McDonough launched their baseball and football notes columns a few decades back, of course, the Internet didn't exist — and the broad freedom accorded notes columnists meant something else entirely. There was no online cache of shared information to access, and you couldn’t Google your way to a column. Instead, Gammons and McDonough — both of whom were exceedingly knowledgeable and well-connected — had to do some serious reporting. Borges’s column closes with this disclaimer: "Material from personal interviews, wire services, other beat writers, and league and team sources was used in this report."

After Borges was suspended, sports blogger Dan Shanoff argued that the whole notes-exchange practice should be stopped. “At best,” Shanoff wrote, “this is lazy journalism. (In the online age, how hard is it to find this stuff yourself? Reporters don’t need to travel any further than their laptop or reach out to any sources beyond ‘Google’ to be on their way. At worst, this is fraud, if not plagiarism (unless you’re Borges, and you simply seem to cut-and-paste entire passages from the exchange).”

Shanoff’s got a point. For now, though, the Globe isn't ready to go quite that far, though sports editor Joe Sullivan tells the Phoenix that the notes-sharing system is being reassessed in light of Borges’s transgressions.

“We're going to be discussing the whole idea of that, and we’re in the process now,” Sullivan says. “When things like that happen, it always causes you to have second thoughts about the way we do things.” Sullivan adds that, while notes-sharing services exist for every sport, not every sportswriter uses them — but he won’t say which of the Globe’s other notes columnists do or don’t.

Two more Borges-related matters worth pondering: first, given the egregiousness of Borges’s offense — the column in question repeated the words from News Tribune sportswriter Mike Sando verbatim or near-verbatim on several occasions — it's hard to see him as a victim. But judging from this statement, which was quoted on, that’s what the Globe’s employee union seems to be doing: “The Boston Newspaper Guild stands behind Ron and the high-quality work he has done for the Globe over the years. We will work on his behalf to see that justice is served in this matter.”

1  |  2  |  3  |  4  |  5  |   next >
Related: Killer coke, The WRKO shuffle, Getaway Carr, More more >
  Topics: Media -- Dont Quote Me , Deval Patrick, Howie Carr, Jeff Jacoby,  More more >
| More

Most Popular
Share this entry with Delicious
  •   BULLY FOR BU!  |  March 12, 2010
    After six years at the Phoenix , I recently got my first pre-emptive libel threat. It came, most unexpectedly, from an investigative reporter. And beyond the fact that this struck me as a blatant attempt at intimidation, it demonstrated how tricky journalism's new, collaboration-driven future could be.
  •   STOP THE QUINN-SANITY!  |  March 03, 2010
    The year is still young, but when the time comes to look back at 2010's media lowlights, the embarrassing demise of Sally Quinn's Washington Post column, "The Party," will almost certainly rank near the top of the list.
  •   RIGHT CLICK  |  February 19, 2010
    Back in February 2007, a few months after a political neophyte named Deval Patrick cruised to victory in the Massachusetts governor's race with help from a political blog named Blue Mass Group (BMG) — which whipped up pro-Patrick sentiment while aggressively rebutting the governor-to-be's critics — I sized up a recent conservative entry in the local blogosphere.
  •   RANSOM NOTES  |  February 12, 2010
    While reporting from Afghanistan two years ago, David Rohde became, for the second time in his career, an unwilling participant rather than an observer. On October 29, 1995, Rohde had been arrested by Bosnian Serbs. And then in November 2008, Rohde and two Afghan colleagues were en route to an interview with a Taliban commander when they were kidnapped.
  •   POOR RECEPTION  |  February 08, 2010
    The right loves to rant against the "liberal-media elite," but there's one key media sector where the conservative id reigns supreme: talk radio.

 See all articles by: ADAM REILLY