Another perspective

The view from Mexico on Immigration
By AMY LITTLEFIELD  |  April 2, 2008
"Behind the immigration debate: Stella Carrera helps newcomers navigate a rigid bureaucracy." By Amy Littlefield.
OAXACA, Mexico — Carmen Romero, a resident of this capital in the southern state of Oaxaca, says the idea of immigrating to the United States is “a Mexican obsession,” though the reality of immigration for many is different from the dream.
 
It is difficult, if not impossible, for Mexicans to get a visa to go to the US. Work visas require prior arrangements with employers, and an appointment to get a tourist visa costs $131. If they can pay, applicants must then convince the US Embassy that they can actually afford to be tourists.
 
“They only have to look at the hands of a campesino [a small farmer] to know what they do for a living,” says Romero, who is hosting me as part a study abroad program. If so many people could get visas, she believes, the whole Oaxacan countryside would leave for the US.
 
Aurelio Maceda, who works for an indigenous rights’ coalition, the Frente Indígena de Organizaciones Binacionales (FIOB), disagrees. He believes that many of the hundreds of thousands of Oaxacans living in the US would return home if the US government made it easier to cross the border. 
 
Oaxaca is the second poorest of Mexico’s 31 states. Many of the poorest people in Mexico are indigenous farmers living in the campo, rural areas where economic opportunities are often nonexistent, and migration may be the only option to find employment.
 
During a visit to a rural community in the Mixteca region of Oaxaca, I spoke with a farmer whose family earns a living by raising and selling goats. He told me about local residents who had left for the US, gesturing up into the dry hills to illustrate how they had gone north, through the desert, hiring “coyotes” to guide them on the perilous trip across the border.
 
Jesús León Santos, program coordinator an organization that promotes sustainable agriculture in the Mixteca region, says that the idea of immigrating to the US has become contagious in some nearby communities. Young people return home with cars and money, talking about their adventures. They often focus on their successes, not on the difficulties they may have faced.
 
Asked if the campesinos with whom he works know about the immigration debate in the US, León Santos laughs.
 
They know that the United States doesn’t like them, he says, but most of the poor migrants see it as a racial question. They don’t know about the debate over legal policy, national security, or the militarization of the border. They may be unaware that many in the US support the use of a wall — traditional or high-tech — to keep them out.
 
Miguel Pickard, who works for a social-research organization in the southern Mexican state of Chiapas, says that the mainstream US media often overlooks how neo-liberal policies like the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) have contributed dramatically to the rise in Mexican immigration. Following NAFTA’s implementation in 1994, subsidized US agricultural products flooded the Mexican markets, and Mexican farmers couldn’t compete with the cheap imports.
 
Immigration to the US became a “survival strategy,” Pickard says, for campesinos that could no longer make money selling corn and other agricultural products, as they had for many years. As a result, immigration to the US from Mexico tripled after 1994, leading “millions” of people to make the trip, he says.
 
NAFTA’s impact illuminates how the source of the Latino immigration “problem” is sometimes closer to home than we are willing to admit.
Related: A brief history of shopping, Ted Kennedy's real record, It’s global class war, More more >
  Topics: News Features , Politics, Business, Domestic Policy,  More more >
| More


Most Popular
ARTICLES BY AMY LITTLEFIELD
Share this entry with Delicious
  •   SEX ED 101  |  January 24, 2012
    If you're in the market for a steaming slice of sex advice, local sexologist Megan Andelloux is the woman you want to know.
  •   A BOX, A PICTURE, AND A LIFE REVEALED  |  November 09, 2011
    Several years ago, photographer Scott Indermaur came up with a novel way to connect with his subjects: give them each a wooden box — six inches square and four inches deep — and ask them to fill it with objects that represent their beliefs.
  •   SEX AND JEALOUSY, RHODE ISLAND-STYLE  |  September 14, 2011
    Francesca Gregorini, co-director of the film Tanner Hall , which was shot in Rhode Island and opens here this week, drove a vintage Porsche while she was a student at Brown University . . . or so I had read. I asked her whether this was true.
  •   HERE’S THE PITCH: CLOTHING IS BROKEN  |  September 07, 2011
    If you're one of the investors who received an invitation to Betaspring's Demo Day September 8, you might see Jamal Motlagh threatening to turn the clothing industry on its head with a blast of light.
  •   STYLEWEEK PROVIDENCE GETS READY TO STRUT  |  August 24, 2011
    The pink dress with white daisies was a thrift-shop muumuu before Nicole Lebreux refurbished it. Now it's headed for the runway.

 See all articles by: AMY LITTLEFIELD