St. Vincent | Strange Mercy

4AD (2011)
By ZETH LUNDY  |  September 13, 2011
3.0 3.0 Stars


The pretty/ugly dichotomy at the heart of Annie Clark's St. Vincent moniker is in full tug-of-war on her third and most challenging full-length. Clark's fragile, Siouxsie-esque voice contrasts sharply with her thorny, provocative guitar, and Strange Mercy is truly honey-on-sandpaper stuff. On songs like the nimble "Cruel," with its misshapen showtune asides, and the nearly funky "Neutered Fruit," that contrast is beguiling. Other tunes — like the pounding "Northern Lights" and early-Prince headtrip "Hysterical Strength" — are more confrontational. As a whole, Strange Mercy is slower and denser than Clark's stellar second album, Actor, and loaded with more compulsive repetition. Choruses are not so much choruses as near-melodic mantras: "I, I, I, I/I don't want to be a cheerleader no more," she sings in album standout "Cheerleader," a hand knocking on a door. Likewise, the title of "Chloe in the Afternoon" becomes its simple broken-record refrain. It's post-punk dream-pop catharsis, with all the good and bad that that implies, sometimes frantically interrupted by a fuzz-toned, quick-drawn six-string. Sonically, the album is rich and inventive, if at times a noisy cluster. Fleetwood-style dead drums, big-sky synths, and a guitar that cuts closer to avant-jazz than indie rock provide the lush backdrop for a collection of songs about the deceptions in human interaction. Knotty and enigmatic as it is, Strange Mercy becomes more intriguing the more you listen to it — even if that means you also get further away from comprehending its idiosyncrasy.
Related: KT Tunstall | Tiger Suit, The Sounds | Something To Die For, Emmylou Harris | Hard Bargain, More more >
  Topics: CD Reviews , Music, Annie Clark, CD reviews,  More more >
| More

Most Popular
Share this entry with Delicious
  •   BROWN BIRD | FITS OF REASON  |  March 18, 2013
    Brown Bird, a boundary-pushing Americana duo from Rhode Island, make music that touches upon that can't-put-my-finger-on-it amalgamation of past and future sounds.
  •   NICK CAVE & THE BAD SEEDS | PUSH THE SKY AWAY  |  February 20, 2013
    Much like the similarly low-key The Boatman's Call , Cave's highly anticipated 15th album with the Bad Seeds manages the puzzling feat of making a great band seem inconsequential, if not entirely absent.
  •   SCOTT WALKER | BISH BOSCH  |  November 27, 2012
    Scott Walker's late-period about-face is one of the strangest in the annals of pop music.
    Bill Withers has always been the down-to-earth, odd-man-out of the '70s soul brothers: he's the one who came bearing a lunch box on the cover of his relaxed 1971 debut, Just as I Am .
  •   R.E.M. | DOCUMENT [25TH ANNIVERSARY EDITION]  |  September 19, 2012
    Fans of R.E.M. enjoy arguing over which album was the band's true shark-jump, but 1987's Document was inarguably the end of a groundbreaking era.

 See all articles by: ZETH LUNDY