Vote the rock

Prince bows to King Dylan
By LANCE GOULD  |  July 16, 2008

The Republican and Democratic conventions are still more than a month away, but that doesn’t mean the summer has been an electoral wasteland. In fact, the Phoenix presided over three peaceably held elections this month — contests that were remarkable for their lack of mudslinging, stump slips, and negative ads. And we didn’t even need Jimmy Carter to step in and monitor this shit.

The run-offs were a part of our first-annual “50 States, 50 Bands” July 4th music-tacular, in which we picked 150 fights by picking the all-time best band, all-time best solo artist, and best new band for each state (to see all the results, go to We saved three of the most contentious slots —Minnesota solo artist (Bob Dylan vs. Prince), New Hampshire solo artist (Ronnie James Dio vs. Jon Spencer), and New Jersey band (Misfits vs. Four Seasons) — for you, our readers, to determine the winners, both by text and online voting.

Leading off with the North Star State, Dylan cruised to a surprisingly easy victory. The Hibbing troubadour carried the day with 65 percent of the vote. His Gibberish-Talk Express was consistent in various battlegrounds, winning 65 percent of the Web vote and 64 percent of the text vote.

In the Granite State, Ronnie James Dio rode the Devil Horns platform to victory over the Pussy Pulpit proffered by Jon Spencer, capturing 56 percent of the overall vote. Dio took 55 percent of the Web ballots, and an astounding 79 percent of the texts. Jon Spencer, sir, apparently your fans need a new friends-and-family texting plan.

And in the Garden State, Glenn Danzig’s Misfits notched a “W” over Frankie Valli’s Four Seasons, taking 54 percent of the overall vote. Online, Danzig’s horror-punk crew out-slugged Valli’s well-coiffed Jersey Boys 54 percent to 46 percent, while further demolishing them 68 percent to 32 percent in the text arena.

Exit polls were scarce, but here are eight reasons why Dylan so handily won:

1) Dylan probably never wrote a single song that used “U” for “you,” “R” for “are,” “2” for “two,” “too,” or “to,” or “4” for “for.”

2) David Bowie never wrote a song about Prince.

3) When Prince went electric, no maniacs screamed “Judas!” at his concerts.

4) Dylan never recorded with Wendy or Lisa, Appolonia or Vanity, or the New Power Generation. His band was simply called The Band.

5) Dylan (thankfully) never wore a purple jumpsuit with his ass cheeks exposed.

6) Dylan’s keyboardist was Richard Manuel. Prince’s keyboardist was a guy who looked like Weird Al Yankovic wearing surgery scrubs.

7) Dylan’s politically charged lyrics — from “The Times They Are a Changin’,” to “With God on Our Side,” to “Hurricane,” among tons of others — led a generation to question authority. Prince’s politically charged lyrics? (from “Annie Christian”): “Somebody say ABSCAM!”

8) Look at the cover of Dylan’s Desire album (pictured): Dylan was pimped out before Prince was out of high school!

  • Musical melee
    An old, grizzled white guy, once considered a maverick but now an entrenched member of the establishment, is challenged by a younger, popular African-American upstart.
  • Keys to our hearts
    "I’ve never been someone that goes to the ‘it’ places and does the ‘it’ things and goes to the ‘it’ restaurant and go to the ‘it’ club. I like more off-the-beaten-path kind of things."
  • Painting My Bloody Valentine
    Thump! The needle hits the record with an abrasive scratch and then the music begins.
  • More more >
  Topics: Music Features , Elections and Voting , Politics , Entertainment ,  More more >
| More
Featured Articles in Music Features:
Share this entry with Delicious
  •   HIGH AND LOW CULTURE FROM JAPAN  |  June 02, 2010
    Attention, admirers of quirky kitsch and over-the-top aesthetics: hit PAUSE on that Belle and Sebastian record for a second.
  •   GOING FOR GOLD GLOSSARY  |  February 17, 2010
    The Summer Olympics are fairly easy to comprehend for the average couch tuber: people running, hoisting, swimming in synch — all fairly quotidian activities.
  •   THE PHOENIX CLEANS UP AT NENPA  |  February 10, 2010
    Was 2009 a good year for newspapers?
  •   RAINBOW NATION  |  January 28, 2010
    After a torturous history of being treated like second-class citizens, the black population in this country stunned the world by pulling off the unimaginable: voting a black man in as president.
  •   INTERVIEW: OZZY OSBOURNE  |  January 29, 2010
    Long before he bit the heads off bats and doves, Ozzy Osbourne worked in a cheerless abattoir in the hardscrabble Aston section of Birmingham, England, where for 18 months he held such titles as "cow killer," "tripe hanger," "hoof puller," and "pig stunner."

 See all articles by: LANCE GOULD