The Papitto controversy reveals some ingrained truths about race and institutions
By IAN DONNIS | July 25, 2007
|
The fall from grace of Ralph R. Papitto was remarkable in its speed and force. Just four days after his use of the N-word became public, the prime benefactor of Rhode Island’s only law school — the 80-year-old founder of a Fortune 500 company — asked that his name be severed from the institution he helped create at Roger Williams University in Bristol.
For some, who saw the backlash as wholly out of proportion to Papitto’s cumulative man-of-action accomplishments, it was unreal. To others, particularly the throng of RWU law school students who sparked the push to remove Papitto’s name, it represented nothing less than justice.
It was a curious situation, to be sure. Papitto, the creator of Nortek, one of a relatively small number of big-deal economic success stories in Rhode Island, has donated more than $2 million to the law school at Roger Williams University. At the same time, the octogenarian’s explanation — that the ugly racial epithet “just slipped out” and that he had first heard it “on television, in rap music or something” — inspired widespread incredulity.
The use of the N-word word during a board of trustees’ meeting of a university, and one named for Rhode Island’s founder, no less, guaranteed national exposure after the Providence Journal’s Jennifer Jordan broke the dramatic story on Saturday, July 14.The reaction swiftly broke into two sharply divided schools of thought: One, the seemingly broader view, was that Papitto and his allies on the RWU board had tried sweeping the matter under the rug while punishing the three trustees who spoke against him. A less widely subscribed view, albeit one maintained by a spokesman for the board, is that RWU was acting to correct shortcomings in institutional stewardship, and that a dissident trustee enflamed the situation, damaging the university’s reputation in the process, by going public.
Regardless, four days later, after mounting an unsuccessful defense during two July 16 appearances on talk-radio, Papitto effectively deflated the controversy when he requested that his name be removed from RWU’s law school. Media interest in the story mostly faded, with reporters and talk-show hosts gravitating to the alcohol-related death of a 17-year-old in Barrington and a charitable fund established by the owners of the Station nightclub.
In time, there will be stories charting changes in the composition of RWU’s board of trustees, and perhaps looking at how well the boards of other Rhode Island institutions reflect the communities that they serve. Yet even now, it’s clear that the Papitto controversy reflected some familiar lessons.
A bad response is worse than the offense
For a striking example of how expertly private educational institutions process their own dirty laundry, consider how it has taken Brown University a few hundred years to try to come to terms with its own considerable involvement in the slave trade. Whether this would have happened without the presence of the first black female president of an Ivy League university is another question.
Still, the response to Papitto’s use of the N-word during a May 2 RWU board meeting is far from a textbook example of crisis-management.
Mike Doyle of the RDW Group, the Providence-based public-relation company, who was hired as a spokesman for the RWU trustees, squarely puts the blame, without naming her, on trustee Dr. Barbara Roberts’s decision to go public via the ProJo. “I think the board was addressing this in a discreet manner from the get-go,” Doyle says. “There was never a matter of accepting this. One board member chose to make this a public spectacle. She acted on her own, unilaterally, in a manner that ultimately tarnished the reputation of the university.”
Related:
Little Papeet can't jump, RWU board: A classic case of inaction, Separate Cultures, More
- Little Papeet can't jump
L’affaire Papitto is one of those stories so stupid and ridiculous that no one could have made it up.
- RWU board: A classic case of inaction
If you are a Rhode Islander who happens to know the principals, it’s a blockbuster.
- Separate Cultures
In the late 1980s, when the plans for the mosque were first taking shape, it was intended to be developed by and for a primarily black Muslim population in Greater Roxbury.
- Uh, race still matters, folks
In a few short days Barack Obama will go from being our first black president-elect to our first black president. Yes siree, the black guy is finally going to be in charge. We finally did it. Welcome to post-racial America!
- All in the family
The December 1 New Yorker featured a five-page story by Henry Louis Gates Jr. on his efforts to use DNA testing to clarify his ancestry.
- As white as they come
It seems to be Maine's turn again to be the least racially diverse state in the nation.
- Rainbow Nation
After a torturous history of being treated like second-class citizens, the black population in this country stunned the world by pulling off the unimaginable: voting a black man in as president.
- Ask a Black Woman: Harry Reid edition
Just in time for Black History Month, another installment of "Ask a Black Woman," thanks to JT in Portland who in early January asked me: What's your take on the Harry Reid thing?
- Review: Rebound!
According to Boston Herald writer Michael Connelly, the deep racial wounds opened up by the Boston busing crisis of the mid '70s first began to heal when whites and blacks came together to support the Boston Celtics' championship team of 1981.
- Mixed Magic's When Fate Comes Knocking
It's been said before and it'll be said again: the election of Barack Obama casts a new light on the Civil Rights Movement. Or, in Ricardo Pitts-Wiley's words, "We get to tell the story in a different way."
- Deal me in
In fact, let's just talk about one card in particular.
- Less
Topics:
News Features
, Education, Ivy League, Cornel Young, More
, Education, Ivy League, Cornel Young, Keith Stokes, Julian Bond, Ralph Ellison, Special Interest Groups, African-American Issues, Racial Issues, Social Issues, Less