Peanut Butter Wolf Presents 2K8: B-Ball Zombie War

CD Reviews

Fiery Furnaces

Widow City | Thrill Jockey

By RICHARD BECK | December 3, 2007

1.5 Stars

Ever since the release of their 76-minute sophomore album, Blueberry Boat (Rough Trade), Brooklyn’s Fiery Furnaces — the brother-and-sister duo of Matthew and Eleanor Friedberger — have been lauded as one of indie rock’s more ambitious, idiosyncratic bands. On that disc, they moved on from the guitar/drums immediacy of garage rock to a more textured approach that deployed dozens of instruments (keyboards, drum machines, and a whole bucket of samples and loops) and topped it off with references as disparate as pirates, Damascus, and the White Sox. Then in 2005, they got their grandmother involved by soundtracking her storytelling on Rehearsing My Choir (Rough Trade). Both releases contributed to their reputation as a band with an overflow of ideas. On Widow City, however, the duo’s intellectual expansiveness leads into shallow waters. They’ve developed an annoying penchant for alliteration: lyrics like “Mopes in the moonlight on the mesa in March,” references to “the petrol pump” and a “crazy quilts and collectibles collection,” song titles like “Wicker Whatnots” abound. And it’s not clear what any of it means. Loquacity is no crime, but Fiery Furnaces are trying too hard to be clever. Not much is going on in the music, either, as they switch clumsily back and forth between raucous guitars and tinkling pianos. There’s plenty in the way of ambition on Widow City, but little substance to back it up.

Fiery Furnaces + MGMT + Michael Goodman and the Mike | Great Scott, 1222 Comm Ave, Allston | December 10 | 617.566.9014

Deadboy and the Elephantmen
We Are Night Sky | Fat Possum
The Fiery Furnaces
Bitter Tea | Fat Possum
Guest lists
What 30 of the Phoenix 's music critics liked this year
More

Topics: CD Reviews , The Fiery Furnaces , Eleanor Friedberger

Comments

Add a Comment

ARTICLES BY RICHARD BECK

THE PLAY’S THE THING | June 30, 2008
The audial oddities of Blevin Blectum

SILVER JEWS | June 24, 2008
Lookout Mountain, Lookout Sea | Drag City

DIMINISHING RETURNS | July 09, 2008
The Hold Steady make it hard to Stay Positive

IRI-DECENT | May 29, 2008
Kanye West and Rihanna at Tweeter Center, May 15, 2008

BANGERS + MUSH | May 21, 2008
Dizzee Rascal and El P at the Middle East Downstairs, May 11, 2008

See all articles by: RICHARD BECK

Most Viewed

Most Emailed

PHOTOS: NORTH KOREA'S SURREAL MASS GAMES
While everyone else watches the Olympics, Asia's weirdest sporting event transpires in the world's most secretive country

PHOTOS: LOLLAPALOOZA 2008
Rage Against the Machine, Radiohead, Gnarls Barkley, Girl Talk, Broken Social Scene, Cat Power, Grizzly Bear, and more

IN HARM'S WAY
The tragedy of Rakan Hassan and the impossibility of a Hippocratic Oath for journalists

POT LUCK
No guilt trips in Pineapple Express

CHINA, TIBET, AND THE OLYMPICS
Buddhist scholar Robert Thurman explains the Dalai Lama’s political wisdom, the myopia of the Chinese, and the essence of the Olympics

IN HARM'S WAY
The tragedy of Rakan Hassan and the impossibility of a Hippocratic Oath for journalists

CHINA, TIBET, AND THE OLYMPICS
Buddhist scholar Robert Thurman explains the Dalai Lama’s political wisdom, the myopia of the Chinese, and the essence of the Olympics

THE REIGN OF SPAIN
Never mind the Olympics — the Spanish are the big winners of 2008. Are Obama and McCain aware of this new European powerhouse?

MURDER, SHE WROTE
Interview: Tana French's deep crime novels

BEIJING STING
Exposed: A top-secret government memorandum, obtained this past week by the Phoenix, gives the games away

BEIJING STING
Exposed: A top-secret government memorandum, obtained this past week by the Phoenix, gives the games away

HOT TOPICS

Boston Symphony Orchestra , Kim Deal , Radiohead , Massachusetts Institute of Technology , Harvard University , Kurt Weill , James Levine , James Robinson , John Harbison , Brian Eno

CD Reviews

Fiery Furnaces

Boxed and ready

Cult Cargo

Kaiser Chiefs

Dean and Britta

Elvis Perkins