Moonsigns | Band Guide | Blogs | Adult

Boston | Portland | Providence

Features | Reviews

Reviews

Academy Award Nominated Shorts 2007

Unchallenging and underwhelming

By NINA MACLAUGHLIN | February 13, 2008

2.0 Stars

inside_madame

“Madame Tutli-Putli”

The selection of live-action and animated shorts nominated for Oscars this year is an unchallenging and underwhelming lot. Two exceptions: Chris Lavis & Maciek Szczerbowski’s stop-motion animation piece “Madame Tutli-Putli,” about a woman on a nightmarish night train, has the look of an animated Egon Schiele drawing — menacing, delicate, macabre. And Alexander Petrov’s “My Love” is a dreamy Russian love story. But in the animated batch, “Peter and the Wolf” and “I Met the Walrus,” a pen-and-ink version of an interview with John Lennon, are unamusing, and though “Même les pigeons vont au Paradis/Even Pigeons Go to Heaven” is visually exciting (time machines, crooked salesmen), it’s also predictable. The live-action selections range from the maudlin (a cancer ward in “At Night”) to the exuberant (students and teacher in “Il supplente|The Substitute”). And “The Tonto Woman” could be a romantic subplot to There Will Be Blood, albeit with phony accents. Russian + French + Italian + Danish + English | 222 minutes | Coolidge Corner Theatre

Related:

Here, there, and everywhere
Uncle Earl’s Kristin Andreassen multi-tasks
On the racks: October 17, 2006
Diddy, Danzig, and Badly Drawn Boy
On the racks: October 3, 2006
Beck, the Decemberists, Lindsay Buckingham, Evanescence
More

Topics: Reviews , Egon Schiele , John Lennon

Share:
Rss
Email
Print

Comments

ARTICLES BY NINA MACLAUGHLIN

Share this entry with Delicious

MY FATHER MY LORD | June 25, 2008
Hushed, dun-colored, and beautifully shot

CONFESSIONS OF AN EDITOR | June 20, 2008
DeWitt Henry's candid new collection of essays meditates on manhood

A JIHAD FOR LOVE | June 25, 2008
Potent subject matter overshadowed by special effects

BIGGER, STRONGER, FASTER* | June 04, 2008
Steroids and a culture of competition

REFUSENIK | May 28, 2008
Potent but trudging

See all articles by: NINA MACLAUGHLIN

MOST POPULAR

SLIDESHOW: 50 BANDS, 50 STATES
Posters, records, and other memorabilia trace the history of our nation's most important bands

BAD SPORTS
While old and new media are mending many fences, they’re still squaring off in jockland

SLIDESHOW: BETH ORTON AT THE MFA
Beth Orton at the Museum of Fine Arts, July 2, 2008

CRIMINAL INTENT
Ed Burns on writing Iraq

IS ANYBODY PAYING ATTENTION TO MCCLATCHY'S POWERFUL GUANTÁNAMO EXPOSÉ?
An old-media triumph sheds new light on Bush’s terror policy

MODERN ROMANTICS
Mark Morris’s Romeo & Juliet ; Lar Lubovitch at the Pillow

FOLK TRAILS
Peter Walker’s sound circles the world

HERE COMES THE NEIGHBORHOOD
The Midway Café stretches its legs

URBAN MYTHS
Maddin’s Winnipeg is the city that always sleeps

STOP THE BASTARDS!
African exiles get political.

Featured Articles in Reviews:

080704_herzog_list

Werner’s world

Herzog’s End justifies his means

Gonzo: The Life and Work of Dr. Hunter S. Thompson

An entertaining, if hagiographic portrait

Wall•E

Hopeful and engaging

080628_heaven_list

Crossing over

Fatih Akin’s blue Heaven

My Father My Lord

Hushed, dun-colored, and beautifully shot

Wednesday, July 09, 2008 | Sign In | Register

thePhoenix.com:

Phoenix Media/Communications Group:

StuffAtNight Latest:

FNX Latest:

TODAY'S FEATURED ADVERTISERS

Copyright © 2008 The Phoenix Media/Communications Group