Moonsigns | Band Guide | Blogs | Adult

Boston | Portland | Providence

Features | Reviews

The Life before Her Eyes

Reviews

Mio Fratello È Figlio Unico|My Brother Is an Only Child

Brotherly amore

By BRETT MICHEL | April 23, 2008

3.0 Stars

MY_BROTHER_IS_inside

Elio Germano and Riccardo Scamarcio

“A Fascist in the family is always handy.” Unless it’s a family of leftists in a small Italian town during the turbulent “anni di piombo” (“years of lead”). Beginning in 1962 as young anti-hero Accio (first played by the scrappy Vittorio Emanuele Propizio and later by the talented Elio Germano) is thrown out of seminary and ending in 1978, Daniele Luchetti’s spirited adaptation (written with La meglio gioventú|The Best of Youth scribes Sandro Petraglia and Stefano Rulli) of Antonio Pennacchi’s novel Il fasciocomunista pits the impetuous youth’s political awakening against the Communist convictions of his charismatic older brother Manrico (Gioventú’s Riccardo Scamarcio) as they fall for the same girl (Diane Fleri). Compared in the press notes to period classics like Bertolucci’s Prima della rivoluzione|Before the Revolution and Bellocchio’s I pugni in tasca|Fists in the Pocket, it also echoes Shane Meadows’s 2006’s This Is England, but political doctrines pale next to sibling bonds, at least for Accio, who’s blind to the hazards ahead. Italian | 108 minutes | Kendall Square + West Newton

Related:

Kid stuff
An idyllic Summercamp!, a brutal This Is England
Speed Racer
Another faulty family film
Mongol
An idealized portrait of Genghis Khan
More

Topics: Reviews , Elio Germano , Shane Meadows

Share:
Rss
Email
Print

Comments

ARTICLES BY BRETT MICHEL

Share this entry with Delicious

WALL•E | July 01, 2008
Hopeful and engaging

HANCOCK | July 01, 2008
Comedy or existential drama?

MONGOL | June 18, 2008
An idealized portrait of Genghis Khan

GHOST OF FUTURE PAST | June 19, 2008
Keir Dullea, gone tomorrow

KUNG FU PANDA | June 04, 2008
A colorful wuxia comedy

See all articles by: BRETT MICHEL

MOST POPULAR

SLIDESHOW: 50 BANDS, 50 STATES
Posters, records, and other memorabilia trace the history of our nation's most important bands

BAD SPORTS
While old and new media are mending many fences, they’re still squaring off in jockland

SLIDESHOW: BETH ORTON AT THE MFA
Beth Orton at the Museum of Fine Arts, July 2, 2008

CRIMINAL INTENT
Ed Burns on writing Iraq

IS ANYBODY PAYING ATTENTION TO MCCLATCHY'S POWERFUL GUANTÁNAMO EXPOSÉ?
An old-media triumph sheds new light on Bush’s terror policy

MODERN ROMANTICS
Mark Morris’s Romeo & Juliet ; Lar Lubovitch at the Pillow

FOLK TRAILS
Peter Walker’s sound circles the world

HERE COMES THE NEIGHBORHOOD
The Midway Café stretches its legs

URBAN MYTHS
Maddin’s Winnipeg is the city that always sleeps

STOP THE BASTARDS!
African exiles get political.

Featured Articles in Reviews:

080704_herzog_list

Werner’s world

Herzog’s End justifies his means

Gonzo: The Life and Work of Dr. Hunter S. Thompson

An entertaining, if hagiographic portrait

Wall•E

Hopeful and engaging

080628_heaven_list

Crossing over

Fatih Akin’s blue Heaven

My Father My Lord

Hushed, dun-colored, and beautifully shot

Wednesday, July 09, 2008 | Sign In | Register

thePhoenix.com:

Phoenix Media/Communications Group:

StuffAtNight Latest:

FNX Latest:

TODAY'S FEATURED ADVERTISERS

Copyright © 2008 The Phoenix Media/Communications Group