The Phoenix Network:
About  |  Advertise
Adult  |  Moonsigns  |  Band Guide  |  Blogs  |  In Pictures
Media -- Dont Quote Me  |  News Features  |  Talking Politics  |  This Just In

Desert Storm: How the GOP and the Sunset State nurture the lunatic fringe

Tragedy in Tucson re-opens the question of the GOP's dangerous embrace of extremists
By DAVID S. BERNSTEIN  |  January 12, 2011


Two days before Saturday's horrific shooting in Tucson, Arizona, which gravely wounded Congresswoman Gabrielle Giffords and left six people dead, a woman disrupted the reading of the US Constitution on the floor of the US House of Representatives by loudly appealing to Jesus to intercede against the foreign-born usurper of the presidency, Barack Obama. Hours after that deranged outburst, Brian Williams of NBC News gave Republican Speaker John Boehner an opportunity to firmly distance himself and his party from such lunacy, in a televised interview. Boehner declined:

WILLIAMS You've got 12 members co-sponsoring legislation [that questions Obama's American birth]. Would you be willing to say, "This is a distraction, I've looked at it to my satisfaction. Let's move on?"

BOEHNER The state of Hawaii has said that President Obama was born there. That's good enough for me.

WILLIAMS Would you be willing to say that message to the 12 members in your caucus who seem to either believe otherwise or are willing to express doubt and have co-sponsored legislation?

BOEHNER. . . there are 435 of us. We're nothing more than a slice of America. People come, regardless of party labels, they come with all kinds of beliefs and ideas. It's the melting pot of America. It's not up to me to tell them what to think.

This nod-and-wink embrace of insane conspiratorial anti-government ranting is the danger I outlined this past April — a blurring of lines on the political right between honest disagreement and paranoid delusion. Forget the violent imagery of Sarah Palin's (clearly inappropriate) crosshair-targeted map of Democrats like Giffords. The Republican and conservative establishment engages in something far more sinister: validating and justifying the increasingly widespread belief that Democrats are running an evil, illegitimate, unconstitutional tyranny.

READ: "'Tea' is for terrorism: When even the most ‘legitimate’ voices of the right validate dangerously unhinged anti-government rhetoric — DUCK!," by David S. Bernstein

We don't yet know the exact path that led Jared Loughner to his attempted assassination of his Democratic representative, and to then fire at those attending her public appearance. But the very real recent assaults and death threats, against Giffords and others, suggests the danger of mentally unstable people being drawn to, and focused by, the kinds of extreme right-wing conspiracies that have been allowed to thrive and flourish, to win votes and sell books to those vulnerable to anti-government anger.

In few places do those extremes flourish as they do in Arizona, where I was born and raised. It is a place of big spaces and hostility to government; the last of the contiguous 48 states to join the union (in 1912), and about as far as one can get from federal authorities within those states. Polygamous Mormons, reconstruction-era Southerners (Arizona was a confederate territory during the Civil War), and, yes, ammunition-stockpiling militia nuts have all gone to Arizona to escape the reach of federal government. (Others, including Native Americans and Japanese-American internees, were moved there unwillingly.)

Timothy McVeigh went to Arizona to plot the bombing of the Murrah Federal Building in Oklahoma City. Now, 16 years later, Arizona has again spawned a killing.

1  |  2  |  3  |  4  |   next >
Related: Poor reception, The Road to 2012: The New New Hampshire, Bridge to somewhere, More more >
  Topics: Talking Politics , Republicans, Arizona, Timothy McVeigh,  More more >
| More
5 Comments / Add Comment


So far there has been no evidence presented that the perpetrator ever watched Fox News, but you condemn Fox as a promoter of hate-think that would spawn such a heinous action. Based upon the description provided by the friends of Jared Loughner he would have been just as likely to read the Phoenix as to watch Glenn Beck or listen to Rush Limbaugh. If you fail to establish a positive correlation you have only acted to promote your own liberal views that would presumably suspend the First Amendment in order to preclude episodes such as this.

You imply that the facts as we know them support your view that Hate-mongers (anyone you disagree with) caused Loughner to go on a premeditated killing spree. You may be right. But I could use the same bits of information we know to argue that Loughner suffered from schizophrenia. He's male and in his early twenties. His friends describe extreme changes in his personality over the past several years. These facts fit his actions just as well as the notion that Glenn Beck made him do it.

Maybe your argument is that Glenn Beck made Jared Loughner a schizophrenic. I suppose that would be a good thing because it would give medical science more information regarding the illness, hopefully providing clues to treat it.

Until Loughner is able or willing to explain why he did what he did, it's probably insincere to try to make a political gain out of this tragedy. If this is the act of a mentally ill person, it's probably unlikely that the purported civility of New England makes us safer at home than in Arizona.
Posted: January 13 2011 at 11:01 AM


Arizona is filled with crazy people who don't trust the government; Republicans are politically motivated to tolerate anti-government nuts; we can be pretty sure that Laughner was crazy; he lived in Arizona; therefore the Republicans made him do it. I think that is what you said.
Posted: January 13 2011 at 9:37 PM


This humorous essay states, "In today's American landscape, there is little or no extreme-left equivalent to the extremes of the right." Huh? That reminds me of the journalist who asked a fish what he thought of the water he was swimming in. The fish asked, "Where?"
Posted: January 18 2011 at 6:07 AM


This nut job could not tell the difference between Sarah Palin and Sarah Lee coffeecake. Yet she was blamed almost as much as the killer. Lets face it if you want to get political, democrats commit murder much more in this country than republicans. Don't forget Liberal Hollywood and their mindless murder filled movies that glorify violence. I bet Phoenix is a much safer city than many east coast metros.
Posted: January 18 2011 at 6:25 PM


great historical content and analysis. History does matter in the develpment of values and beliefs.
Posted: January 19 2011 at 12:48 AM
Add Comment
HTML Prohibited

 Friends' Activity   Popular   Most Viewed 
[ 04/28 ]   Alkaline Trio + An Horse + Marathon  @ Lupo's Heartbreak Hotel
[ 04/28 ]   "Awesome Foundation Party"  @ Middlesex Lounge
[ 04/28 ]   Boston Ballet  @ Opera House
Share this entry with Delicious
    Mark this down: Tom Menino, already the longest-serving mayor in Boston history, will run for re-election in 2013.  
  •   CHOOSING SIDES  |  April 14, 2011
    Over the next two weeks, New Hampshire will quietly transform into a proving ground for the Republican 2012 race to recapture the White House. At least 10 potential candidates, from heavyweights like Mitt Romney to obscurities like Fred Karger, are scheduled to visit this month.  
  •   ROMNEY RIDES AGAIN  |  April 14, 2011
    Mitt Romney has been running for president more or less nonstop for the past seven years — and still hasn't figured out how to do it.
    Gaming bills have plagued the last two legislative sessions on Beacon Hill.
  •   AFTER CLINTON  |  March 23, 2011
    With a world full of crises in full flower, Secretary of State Hillary Clinton surprised a lot of people last week by declaring, in an interview with CNN's Wolf Blitzer, that she will not continue to serve beyond 2012, should Barack Obama win a second term as president.

 See all articles by: DAVID S. BERNSTEIN

RSS Feed of for the most popular articles
 Most Viewed   Most Emailed 

  |  Sign In  |  Register
Phoenix Media/Communications Group:
Copyright © 2011 The Phoenix Media/Communications Group