The Phoenix Network:
 
 
About  |  Advertise
Adult  |  Moonsigns  |  Band Guide  |  Blogs  |  In Pictures
 

J.K. Rowling Brings a Grandfatherly Harry Potter Fan To Tears


Before the Breakdown: Steven Jan Vander Ark at Sectus

Serious drama is afoot in the Wizarding World of Harry Potter! We wrote about what the end of the series meant for some local HP disciples last summer, but there's a new, extremely serious rift in superfan land happening right now. It's between author J.K. Rowling and Steven Jan Vander Ark, a sweet 50-year-old librarian and who runs the obsessive Harry Potter Lexicon, a go-to HP online encylopedia. Even Rowling has used it, she has said, when writing on the road and without her own books to refer to. She even gave the Lexicon her fan site award a few years back. Recently, after Rowling learned that Vander Ark had been tapped by the tiny RDR Books to publish the Lexicon as an HP encyclopedia, she decided to sue for copyright infringement. You see, she's planning on penning her own Harry Potter glossery, and assumes nobody will care to purchase hers if they've already got Vander Ark's! Plus, the billionaire author contends the print verrsion of the site merely repackages her own work, and unlike a free site, is intended to churn out a profit.

The Leaky Cauldron, one of the top HP fan sites, has severed ties with the Lexicon -- they'd previously maintained a friendly webby allegiance grounded in HP love. But it hasn't stopped there. The Times reports on the heartbreak:
On the witness stand in Federal District Court, he [Vander Ark] portrayed the famous writer as his idol, his true literary love, who had been unaccountably bewitched by the evil, money-grubbing forces of publishing, like one of Voldemort’s vassals. One day, he testified, Ms. Rowling was singling out his Harry Potter Lexicon Web site, out of “hundreds of thousands” of Potter fan sites on the Web, for praise; the next, she was accusing him of plagiarism for wanting to turn it into a book.

“I did,” Mr. Vander Ark said, his face reddening, as he turned away from Ms. Rowling, who was sitting 10 feet away at the plaintiff’s table, listening intently.

Then he burst out crying. “Sorry,” he said, regaining his composure. “It’s been difficult because there’s been a lot of criticism, obviously, and that was never the intention.”

Rowling has a real knack toying with her fans' emotions. This is upsetting, considering some of us still aren't over Dumbledore.

| More

Leave a Comment

Login | Not a member yet? Click here to Join
 Friends' Activity   Popular   Most Viewed 
All Blogs
ADVERTISEMENT
Related Articles

J.K. Rowling Brings a Grandfatherly Harry Potter Fan To Tears
Boston Phoenix
J.K. Rowling Brings a Grandfatherly Harry Potter Fan To Tears
Published 4/16/2008 by Sharon Steel
Before the Breakdown: Steven Jan Vander Ark at SectusSerious drama is afoot in the Wizarding World of Harry Potter! We wrote about what the end...

Spaced finally coming to DVD in the US
Boston Phoenix
Spaced finally coming to DVD in the US
Published 3/6/2008 by Ryan Stewart
MTV's Movies blog reports that the English comedy Spaced, created by Simon Pegg and Edgar Wright (a/k/a the people behind Shaun of the Dead and...

more by Sharon Steel
Girls talk | June 18, 2010
Hearts of glass | April 09, 2010
Interview: Leanne Shapton | March 24, 2009
Interview: Joss Whedon | February 09, 2009
Review: Dollhouse | February 09, 2009

 See all articles by: Sharon Steel

Follow the Phoenix
  • newsletter
  • twitter
  • facebook
  • youtube
  • rss
Latest Comments
GOP 2012 Rankings, New Year Update - Great analysis. You have given us a good primer of the names to watch--given how parochial the politics...

By beachmama94 on 01-05-2011 in Talking Politics

GOP 2012 Rankings, New Year Update - I cannot believe you really made a conscious choice to completely leave off Ron Paul and Gary Johnson...

By Matt on 01-03-2011 in Talking Politics

Ask Deval Anything! - Is there any way to get the state legislature to understand what ethics means and to behave accordingly...

By ben starr on 01-03-2011 in Talking Politics

Ask Deval Anything! - MassDOT has made great progress on transportation reform, saving $130 million so far. But those savings...

By RP on 01-03-2011 in Talking Politics

GOP 2012 Rankings, New Year Update - Really interesting names on the list. I like Paul Ryan...dynamic character and definitely has that "it"...

By mcarleo on 01-03-2011 in Talking Politics

Latest Comments from Phlog
Most Viewed
NYC Guerrilla Literary Reading
Stars Read Just Like Us!
People Holding Infinite Jest
New Donna Tartt in the Works
Paperback Roundup
Follow this! Boston nightlife spots on Twitter
Ticket on-sale alert: NKOTB/BSB, Lauryn Hill, Bon Jovi, Elton John, Aziz Ansari, Neko Case, and more
Most Viewed from Phlog
Search Blogs
 
Phlog Archives
Thursday, January 06, 2011  |  Sign In  |  Register
 
TODAY'S FEATURED ADVERTISERS
thePhoenix.com
Phoenix Media/Communications Group
Copyright © 2011 The Phoenix Media/Communications Group