"The story is mine"

Published Mar 10 2008, 04:04 PM by webteam

Daniel Mendelsohn (The Lost: A Search for Six of Six Million) wrote what we thought was a depressing but super-smart Op-Ed piece in the Sunday Times. He makes excellent points about the fake-memoir trend, but even more important, he explains what it means to the opressed classes of individuals whose identities are being stolen in the process. Much has already been written about how race and oppressed minorities play into these book scandals (most recently, Jews and African-Americans). Mendelsohn brings that in, and makes a key connection to our culture's reality-worship. The observations he makes about our obsession with the fantasy, and the satisfaction of experiencing a "redemeptive" situation -- regardless of its validity -- are particularly chilling. An excerpt from the last part of the essay (read the whole thing if you have the time, though!):

In an era obsessed with “identity,” it’s useful to remember that identity is precisely that quality in a person, or group, that cannot be appropriated by others; in a world in which theme-park-like simulacra of other places and experiences are increasingly available to anyone with the price of a ticket, the line dividing the authentic from the ersatz needs to be stressed, rather than blurred. As, indeed, Ms. De Wael has so clearly blurred it, for reasons that she has suggested were pitiably psychological. “The story is mine,” she announced. “It is not actually reality, but my reality, my way of surviving.”...

“My reality” raises even more far-reaching and dire questions about the state of our culture, one in which the very concept of “reality” seems to be in danger. Think of “reality” entertainments, which so unnervingly parallel the faux-memoirists’ appropriation of others’ authentic emotional experience: in them, real people are forced to endure painful or humiliating or extreme situations, their real emotional reactions becoming the source of the viewers’ idle gratification. Think of the Internet: an unimaginably powerful tool for education but also a Wild West of random self-expression in which anyone can say anything about anything (or anyone) and have it “published,” and which has already made problematic the line between truth and falsehood, expert and amateur opinion, authentic and inauthentic identities, reality and fantasy.

That pervasive blurriness, the casualness about reality that results when you can turn off entire worlds simply by unsubscribing, changing a screen name, or closing your laptop, is what ups the cultural ante just now. It’s not that frauds haven’t been perpetrated before; what’s worrisome is that, maybe for the first time, the question people are raising isn’t whether the amazing story is true, but whether it matters if it’s true. Perhaps the most dismaying response to the James Frey scandal was the feeling on the part of many readers that, true or false, his book had given them the feel-good, “redemptive” experience they’d hoped for when they bought his novel — er, memoir.

Filed Under: Book Scandal, Essays, Lit Gossip, NYT

Back to WordUp

Back to WordUp

Follow the Phoenix

All Blogs

On The Download (2,244)
Laser Orgy (86)
Phlog (1,510)
Dont Quote Me (561)
Talking Politics (1,599)
Outside The Frame (326)

Filed Under: Book Scandal, Essays, Lit Gossip, NYT

Boston Phoenix
Lynne Spears memoir "will not be a parenting book."
Published 6/12/2008 by Importer
So says People, which delivered the news that Mama Spears's manuscript -- put on hold after the tee...

Boston Phoenix
Lynne Spears memoir "will not be a parenting book."
Published 6/12/2008 by Sharon Steel
So says People, which delivered the news that Mama Spears's manuscript -- put on hold after the tee...

more by webteam

MP3 of the Week: Conservative Man, "The Heist" | January 08, 2010

Cocaine, corpse desecration, and mysterious spoon deaths: Why Sherlock Holmes still excites | December 27, 2009

To Dark Stars by Hard Ways: Alien screenwriter Dan O'Bannon dead at 63 | December 19, 2009

MP3 of the Week: Jesse Dee, "Underneath the Christmas Tree" | December 18, 2009

The Twelve Frights of Christmas: A Dozen Deadly Holiday Horror Films | December 12, 2009

See all articles by: webteam

Latest Comments

Tell us more about what happened to Phoebe Prince - Using Facebook is not illegal, but harassment is irregardless of what form. This girl was obviously trying...

By Camille Tuason Mata on 02-07-2010 in Dont Quote Me

The Touching Tale Of Labor And Scott Brown - Blocking nominations is a time honored tradition that both parties partake in, most recently by Barry...

By Fake Name on 02-06-2010 in Talking Politics

MP3 of the Week: Vikesh Kapoor, "Newspress Scare" - stream the 7" here: vikeshkapoor.bandcamp.com/.../newspress-scare-7-2 tickets to the show here:...

By hootenanny on 02-05-2010 in On The Download

Dear Rush Limbaugh: Please Drop Dead. Love, Twitter - Shows the kind of exemplary trash that festers under the banner of the Democrat party. Wishing ANYONE...

By pirogue on 02-05-2010 in Phlog

Thugs and goons: Howie Carr explains--updated! - Can someone please explain to me what the heck a "moonbat" is supposed to be - I know Carr...

By Derek on 02-05-2010 in Dont Quote Me

Latest Comments from WordUp

"The story is mine"

Leave a Comment