Moonsigns  |  Band Guide  |  Blogs  |  In Pictures  |  Adult
Boston  |  Portland  |  Providence
CD Reviews  |  Classical  |  Download  |  Live Reviews  |  Music Features  |  New England Music News

The Big Hurt: Chinese Democracy at last!

Why you should consider not caring
By DAVID THORPE  |  April 22, 2008


Reports have surfaced that Chinese Democracy, the long-awaited album by former rock gods Guns N’ Roses, has been completed and delivered to Geffen. After years of missed release windows, it seems likely that the record will finally see the light of day. This ought to be one of the biggest music events of the year: a true comeback album, more than a decade in the making, from one of the biggest rock bands in history. Unfortunately, all the years of hype can’t stand up to the massive erosion of the band’s relevance. To spoil your fun well in advance, I’m offering this list of reasons why you shouldn’t give a shit.

Dismal line-up
Guns N’ Roses have always had a turnover problem. By the time they entered the public eye, they’d already undergone an extensive line-up shuffle. Even Tracii Guns, who gave the band the first half of their name, was gone before they released any material. Since then, Izzy, Slash, Duff, and Steven Adler have all left and been replaced (in Duff’s case replaced with a Replacement). You may cling to the hope that Axl is the one who matters, but keep in mind that nearly all of GNR’s classic singles had significant songwriting input from Izzy and/or Slash, and that, left to his own devices, Axl had a tendency toward overblown symphonic ego ballads like “November Rain.” In the end, we’re left with an Axl Rose solo project backed by a sad posse of B-listers, studio musicians, and Love Spit Love alums ( . . . and Tommy Stinson).

. . . and even Buckethead’s gone
If there’s anything more aggressively destructive to rock than an overcooked gimmick, it’s gotta be idiot-savant guitar virtuosity. Buckethead (Slash’s replacement from 2000 to 2004) has plenty of both to spare, what with his KFC hat and his nerdy shredding. He may not be the best fit for a mainstream rock band — better to stick him in some weirdy-beardy avant-metal outfit where he won’t annoy the populace — but as a colorful oddball, at least he added a flamboyant non-Axl personality to the line-up. Buckethead’s musical contributions may have been all wrong, but the ridiculous masked dude worked as a last-ditch effort to keep GNR amusing on some level.

Dr. Pepper is wicked gross
Last month, Dr. Pepper announced a bold, bizarre, and potentially expensive marketing stunt: if Chinese Democracy is released this year, the company will give everyone in America a free Dr. Pepper. Although the marketing folks probably never thought they’d have to make good on that promise, it now appears we might all have a free drink coming our way. (Unfortunately, Dr. Pepper tastes like children’s cough syrup, so I’ll have to scratch that off the list of reasons to care.)

Godawful post-heyday studio output
A lot of us tend (or try) to forget that GNR have released some studio tracks since The Spaghetti Incident, their last major album. In 1994, we were subjected to “Sympathy for the Devil” on the Interview with the Vampire soundtrack, a mostly literal cover distinguished only by Axl’s misguided, hammy vocal performance. Even less memorable: in 1999, they released “Oh My God,” a track featured in the apocalyptic Schwarzenegger vehicle End of Days. That film’s entire soundtrack was mired in the dregs of rock’s most deplorable era, with contributions from Creed, Korn, and Limp Bizkit. “Oh My God” fits right in, a ridiculous flurry of new-metal/industrial bilge without the merest hint of a tune. Absent Axl’s screeching, you might easily mistake it for Powerman 5000 or Rob Zombie, and it somehow manages to sound decades more outdated than any late-’80s GNR material. Given that, I’m not sure why we should care about Chinese Democracy any more than we’d care about an upcoming Mudvayne album.

The horrifying leaked songs
Over the years, several tracks from the Chinese Democracy sessions have surfaced on the Internet — and they sound like a direct continuation of the nauseating new-metal direction of “Oh My God,” filled with electronic flourishes, processed guitars, industrial beats, and non-existent melodies. “Better” crosses the line into humiliating, dad-thinks-he’s-cool mega-squareness — what we’re dealing with here is the sonic equivalent of Axl’s pathetic “I’m not bald!” cornrows. Worse yet, Buckethead’s unwieldy, inappropriate technical leads are shoehorned into most of the tracks; he’s funny as a concept, but God help us if we have to listen to him play. Maybe the saddest part is that the tracks aren’t even funny-bad: they’re just stupid, forgettable, and outmoded. If I were you, I’d cross “desire to hear the album” off your give-a-shit list.

When it’s released, the fun’s over
What’s more amusing: a colossal dud of an album by a long-irrelevant artist or a never-ending saga of wasted money, acrimonious firings, disastrous tours, awful Internet leaks, and unchecked egos? Now that all hope of a decent record has long since faded, I think most of us would gladly give up our Dr. Peppers for 10 more years of this incredible soap opera.

  Topics: Music Features , Guns N' Roses , Music , New Music Releases ,  More more >
  • Share:
  • RSS feed Rss
  • Email this article to a friend Email
  • Print this article Print
The Big Hurt: Chinese Democracy at last!
Buckethead isn't gone. Axl said in a recent interview that his guitar parts are still on the album. Brain is hardly a B-lister. He was in Primus!!! Most of the other guys are also first-rate musicians. Duff is no big loss. I'm excited for the new album. I thought the leaked tracks were pretty decent.
By Jackvan on 04/23/2008 at 3:03:32
The Big Hurt: Chinese Democracy at last!
I don't think that this will be as good as classic GNR. Well get over it. This is not GNR. It's an Axl Rose solo album as GNR. It's only a name. He shouldn't call it a GNR album. And so What? It's only a name. It's sounds like you have already heard the album. You haven't? Maybe you should listen to the album when (if?) it comes out and THEN comment on the album. BLAH BLAH Axl's a jerk. And so... That means NOTHING. Lot's of people with talent are jerks. I've heard the leaks as well. I don't think that they are the trainwreck you make them out to be. As good as AFD - NO! Good in their own right - YES! Have a open mind because it sounds like you have already made your decision.
By Identity_unknown on 04/23/2008 at 7:21:52
The Big Hurt: Chinese Democracy at last!
"Brain is hardly a B-lister. He was in Primus!!!" hahahahha this is the most amazing piece of cognitive dissonance i've ever seen
By rigmarock on 04/24/2008 at 8:45:29
The Big Hurt: Chinese Democracy at last!
I think the leaks are great. All my friends love listening to "IRS" and "Better." The new band isn'b "B-listers," they're a supergroup. If you don't "give a shit," David Thorpe, then why did you spend so much time writing this "colossal dud" of an article. Did Axl fuck your mom back in '89?
By surforia on 04/25/2008 at 5:31:18
The Big Hurt: Chinese Democracy at last!
A supergroup? Ahahahahahahahaha That's adorable.
By Mr. Kennedy on 04/27/2008 at 3:37:54
The Big Hurt: Chinese Democracy at last!
Well I know that when I hear the word "supergroup" I think of a team of distinguished musicians coming together to combine the best traits of their respective bands into a truly amazing album, not a bunch of egotistical has-beens creating some vain and overproduced clusterfuck of a record. No, I never think that at all.
By Jon A. on 04/27/2008 at 8:03:51

election special
Share this entry with Delicious

 See all articles by: DAVID THORPE

RSS Feed of for the most popular articles
 Most Viewed   Most Emailed 

Featured Articles in News Features:
Tuesday, October 07, 2008  |  Sign In  |  Register
Phoenix Media/Communications Group:
Copyright © 2008 The Phoenix Media/Communications Group