The Phoenix Network:
About  |  Advertise
News Features  |  Talking Politics  |  This Just In

Strange bedfellows: The right and left team up on criminal-justice reform

Away from the spotlight, criminal-justice-reform advocates are making progress - with the help of their new friends, the conservatives
By DAVID S. BERNSTEIN  |  January 26, 2011

CELL BLOCK GOP Criminal-justice reform, once a traditional cause of the left, has drawn the attention of such iconic conservatives as (clockwise, from top left) William Bennet, Grover Norquist, Ed Meese, and Newt Gingrich.
The practical result of the new spirit of political civility is still an open question, but there is one area where small-government conservatives and do-gooder liberals might really be moving toward significant policy agreement, compromise, and action: criminal-justice reform.

With the spotlight on bigger issues of economy, war, and health care, this usually hot-potato issue is arguably getting more serious attention than it has in years. Policy makers are trying to determine what really reduces crime and what doesn't — and how we might shift from simply locking up as many people as possible to a more effective, and cost-efficient, model.

It's a subject long thought to be the purview of liberals. But now, conservatives are helping to drive this backstage discussion — and not just any conservatives, but right-wing icons like Newt Gingrich, William Bennett, Ed Meese, and Grover Norquist, to name a few.

They are not all newcomers to criminal-justice reform. But a month ago, for the first time, they teamed up to form an organization — Right on Crime — that will advocate the way conservative foundations have previously done on such issues as gun rights, low taxation, and restriction of abortions.

Longtime activists — most of them liberals — tell the Phoenix that Right on Crime could be a game-changer, just what's needed to find bipartisan consensus on new policies — even if left and right are coming to the same answers through very different motivations.

And that they are. Left-leaning groups tend to be seeking justice and fairness for the underprivileged who disproportionately get caught in the tentacles of America's prison system.

These conservatives, by contrast, are driven by a desire to shrink government spending; a libertarian view toward decriminalizing personal behavior; and a belief in faith-based rehabilitation programs.

"Their number-one concern is that the criminal-justice system is a bloated big-government program that has run amok," says Julie Stewart, executive director of Families Against Mandatory Minimums in Washington. "And frankly, I agree with that."

It's making for some odd collaborators. Long-time reform advocates are expressing guarded optimism that this new right-wing effort might change the political calculus that has long impeded their efforts. But at the same time, they are skeptical of what these conservatives are really up to.

"We're optimistic," says Jennifer Bellamy, criminal-justice lobbyist for the American Civil Liberties Union in Washington, "but we're also realists."


There have always been some voices for reform on the right, and conservative lawmakers have crossed over at times, including on the 2010 Fair Sentencing Act, which reduced the disparity between punishment for powder and crack cocaine.

But the timing is right for a much bigger engagement, particularly at the state level, where newly elected Republican governors and legislators are facing financial crises. Suddenly they're willing to consider "smart on crime" policies that can reduce the corrections budgets that have soared unchecked for decades.

1  |  2  |  3  |   next >
Related: Split atop the RI Tea Party, 2009 had some redeeming qualities - really, A lawyer’s adventures in bad judgment, More more >
  Topics: News Features , Politics, Jim Webb, American Civil Liberties Union,  More more >
| More

 Friends' Activity   Popular   Most Viewed 
Share this entry with Delicious
  •   BUS STOPPED?  |  January 11, 2012
    The media mob will have high-tailed it out of New Hampshire by the time you read this.
  •   ELIZABETH WARREN'S NEW CHAPTER  |  January 11, 2012
    A book about middle-class bankruptcy, being published this week, includes a chapter co-authored by US Senate candidate Elizabeth Warren.
    Our operatives bring you live-on-the-ground dispatches, live from the Granite State.
  •   ROMNEY RAMBLES ON  |  January 05, 2012
    Republicans are aflame with urgency about removing Barack Obama from the White House, but they just can't seem to get enthused about any of the available replacements.
  •   THE YEAR AHEAD IN MITT  |  December 28, 2011
    Here's a quick look at some key dates for Romney, and what you might want to keep an eye on when his face pops up on your TV screen. Remember, there's a lot at stake: if he wins, you get at least four more years of Mitt-watching.

 See all articles by: DAVID S. BERNSTEIN

RSS Feed of for the most popular articles
 Most Viewed   Most Emailed