The Phoenix Network:
About  |  Advertise
Adult  |  Moonsigns  |  Band Guide  |  Blogs  |  In Pictures

Difference of opinion

Peter Canellos reinvents Globe ’s editorial page. Plus, Tom Menino’s campaign gets late-breaking help from the Banner and Herald .
By ADAM REILLY  |  November 6, 2009

OP HEAD: New editorial-page editor Peter Canellos brings a new aesthetic — and sharper rhetorical elbows — to the back of the Globe.
It’s been three months since Peter Canellos replaced Renée Loth as editor of the Boston Globe’s editorial page. In that time, readers have received a bevy of cues that, on Canellos’s watch, the paper’s op-ed section will be a radically different beast — marked by a new aesthetic, sharper rhetorical elbows, and a contrarian streak that just might challenge the long-standing conflation of the Globe with knee-jerk liberalism.

My own “Eureka!” moment came in late August, when I flipped to the back of the “A” section and found myself staring — right in the middle of the editorial page — at a picture of Leon Wieseltier, literary editor of the New Republic, slack-jawed and hoisting a hefty glass of white wine. The image itself was noteworthy: under Loth (who, like Canellos, is a Phoenix alum), the editorial hole was reliably a prose-only zone.

The snarky tone of the accompanying commentary — which mocked Wieseltier for a recent foray into Boston-bashing — was even more striking. In a column by the New York Times’ Maureen Dowd, Wieseltier had been quoted likening the Internet to “closing time at a blue-collar bar in Boston. Everyone’s drunk and ugly and they’re going to pass out in a few minutes.”

Cue the Globe’s editorial retort, which was craftily titled “Elitist Opinion: This Grudge Is for You.” Therein, the Globe compared Wieseltier to Frasier Crane, pop culture’s best-known effete intellectual snob, and ridiculed his fondness for chardonnay. (And you thought the Budweiser reference was gratuitous!) The piece closed with a modest proposal: “Bostonians will work on holding back their Sam Adamses and Harpoons and Washingtonians can work on holding back Leon Wieseltier.”

When people think of the Globe’s op-ed pages, they don’t usually think of populist pugnacity. But the Wieseltier piece wasn’t an anomaly. Instead, it hinted at Canellos’s broader vision for the section.

Start with the specific fight the editorial page chose to pick. According to the entrenched stereotypes, Wieseltier was an unlikely target. After all, he’s a member of the East Coast liberal establishment — and so are the members of the Globe’s editorial board (or so the thinking goes). But Canellos seems determined to prove that, conventional wisdom notwithstanding, the Globe editorial page isn’t reflexively liberal (my phrase, not his). “Our positions,” he says, “should reflect the general posture of Massachusetts citizens and Globe readers, which is definitely on the liberal side, but is also independent.”

Globe bashers — many of whom seem not to actually read the paper — may find this implausible. Of late, however, Globe editorials have panned the Boston Teachers Union, ripped President Barack Obama’s recent foray into economic protectionism, and whacked Acting US Attorney Michael Loucks for dropping an illegal-marijuana-possession charge against Atlantic senior editor Andrew Sullivan. Bear in mind, too, that the paper’s August 27 editorial on Ted Kennedy’s death began with the following provocative assertion: “Ted Kennedy was not a great man.”

1  |  2  |  3  |  4  |   next >
  Topics: Media -- Dont Quote Me , Barack Obama, Politics, Media,  More more >
  • Share:
  • Share this entry with Facebook
  • Share this entry with Digg
  • Share this entry with Delicious
  • RSS feed
  • Email this article to a friend
  • Print this article
Re: Difference of opinion
Remarkable that the fact a major US daily's failure to carry Obama & co.s water and to actually write an objective editorial warrants a story. Subscriptions to most US daily newspapers should generate political contribution tax receipts.
By queeno_the_howler_monkey on 11/05/2009 at 3:22:17
Re: Difference of opinion
QtH, the editorial you're referring to wasn't the hook for the story. It is, however, one of several pieces of evidence that the Globe's liberal orthodoxy is greatly overstated.
By Adam Reilly on 11/05/2009 at 3:49:30

Today's Event Picks
Share this entry with Delicious
  •   DIFFERENCE OF OPINION  |  November 06, 2009
    It’s been three months since Peter Canellos replaced Renée Loth as editor of the Boston Globe ’s editorial page.
  •   THE IMPORTANCE OF BEING ERNIE  |  October 19, 2009
    Media feuds don’t come any nastier than the metastasizing spat between Boston Herald columnist Howie Carr and one “Ernie Boch III,” the pseudonymous blogger at the liberal Web site Blue Mass. Group. (Note: the blogger is no relation to the car dealer.)
  •   LATTER DAY TAINT  |  October 10, 2009
    Fifteen years ago, Glenn Beck was a small-market DJ with a drinking problem, no friends, and bleak professional prospects. Today, he’s a Fox News superstar averaging 2.4 million viewers, an inexorably successful author, and the leader of a popular movement that condemns government in general and President Barack Obama in particular.
  •   PHILADELPHIA STORY  |  October 01, 2009
    The local-media story line of the moment is the push by Stephen Taylor — Milton resident, Yale media lecturer, and former Boston Globe executive VP — to recapture the paper his family ran for more than a century, a goal he's pursuing with the backing of (among others) his cousin Benjamin Taylor, the former Globe publisher.
  •   MENINO'S JUNKED MAIL  |  September 16, 2009
    Two years ago, when I wrote a column griping about the Boston media's apathy-inducing disinterest in city politics, Boston Globe metro editor Brian McGrory told me his paper had given the lackluster 2007 elections as much coverage as they deserved, but hinted that things would be different in 2009.

 See all articles by: ADAM REILLY

RSS Feed of for the most popular articles
 Most Viewed   Most Emailed 

  |  Sign In  |  Register
Phoenix Media/Communications Group:
Copyright © 2009 The Phoenix Media/Communications Group