CD Reviews

R.E.M. | Part Lies, Part Heart, Part Truth, Part Garbage: 1982-2011

Warner Bros (2011)

By ZETH LUNDY | November 16, 2011

2.0 Stars

Now R.E.M. have died two deaths: first, when drummer and founding member Bill Berry split for the comforts of country life in 1997, and then nail-in-the-coffin style, when the Athens, Georgia, band announced its official break-up two months ago. Cue the definitive best-of compilation album. A two-disc career overview of the most formative American rock band of the late 20th century should be easy enough, but Part Lies, Part Heart, Part Truth, Part Garbage fails by making the obvious choice at every turn. Sure, there's plenty here that can't be denied, no matter who you are: "Gardening at Night," "Talk About the Passion," "Fall on Me," "Country Feedback," etc. But where's "Wolves, Lower"? "These Days"? "Everybody Hurts" instead of "Drive"? Only one track from the band's unfairly maligned Monster? Neophytes may be the target here, but as a long-form mixtape, Part Lies could go deeper. It doesn't help that the obligatory new tracks aimed at longtime fans — "We All Go Back to Where Belong," "A Month of Saturdays," and "Hallelujah" — are weak bait. This ain't all bad — it's just that the real truth is that R.E.M. were better.

KT Tunstall | Tiger Suit
The KT Tunstall of Tiger Suit is tougher, louder, and more electronically endowed than the KT Tunstall of its poppy predecessor, 2007's Drastic Fantastic , and Eye to the Telescope three years before that.
The Sounds | Something To Die For
The recent news that British electronic act Faithless have called it a day no doubt left dejected ravers reaching for extra MDMA to stave off the tears.
Emmylou Harris | Hard Bargain
Anyone with a passing knowledge of Emmylou Harris will recognize that "The Road," the opening track on Hard Bargain, is about Gram Parsons and the relationship that kicked off her career 40 years ago.
Fountains of Wayne | Sky Full of Holes
Sky Full of Holes, the first Fountains album in four years, is another reminder of why the band deserve some limelight of their own.
Grace Jones | Hurricane
Seriously: you'll probably refuse to believe me when I say that a one-time Bond villainess is behind this near-masterpiece, a collection of way-heavy grooves packed with wit, wisdom, and ballsier-than-ballsy vocal takes.
St. Vincent | Strange Mercy
The pretty/ugly dichotomy at the heart of Annie Clark's St. Vincent moniker is in full tug-of-war on her third and most challenging full-length.
Mates of State | Mountaintops
As the sequenced synths and handsome beats unfold, matched in merriment by the husband-and-wife vocals of Jason Hammel and Kori Gardner, your mind is miles away from the raging fires of the underworld.
Twin Sister | In Heaven
It's one of 2011's finest pop records: 10 tracks of dreamy, weirdo hi-fi pop that grooves, sparkles, and hums with clipped beats and smooth drums.
Clap Your Hands Say Yeah | Hysterical
Deploying the magic touch of indie producer-superhero John Congleton, these five musicians have never sounded more like a rock band, and these 12 spacious, dreamy excursions benefit from the added muscle.
Bjork | Biophilia
What the hell is Biophilia ?
The Good Natured | Skeleton
The seven-song Skeleton EP is a combination of two previous import EPs, sounding already like an immediate best-of, compiling six Good Natured studio tracks and a (throwaway) remix.
Less

Topics: CD Reviews , Music, R.E.M., R.E.M., More

| More

Friends' Activity

Popular

Most Viewed

See more deals

view all

ARTICLES BY ZETH LUNDY

SMASHING PUMPKINS | GISH/SIAMESE DREAM | November 29, 2011
Billy Corgan's zeitgeist whine, so omnipresent via high-charting Siamese Dream tracks "Today" and "Disarm," was the true sound of the alterna-'90s.

THE WHO | QUADROPHENIA: THE DIRECTOR'S CUT | November 22, 2011
Pete Townshend's working demos for the Who have long been sought in bootleg circles, often for the simple reason that the songwriter's vulnerable vocals offer relief from the barbaric yawp of lead singer Roger Daltrey.

R.E.M. | PART LIES, PART HEART, PART TRUTH, PART GARBAGE: 1982-2011 | November 16, 2011
Now R.E.M. have died two deaths: first, when drummer and founding member Bill Berry split for the comforts of country life in 1997, and then nail-in-the-coffin style, when the Athens, Georgia, band announced its official break-up two months ago.

KURT VILE | SO OUTTA REACH | November 09, 2011
This six-song, 30-minute companion EP serves as a victory lap for long-haired Philadelphian Kurt Vile, whose vacillating and absorbing Smoke Ring for My Halo is certainly one of the year's best albums.

VARIOUS ARTISTS | PHIL SPECTOR PRESENTS THE PHILLIES ALBUM COLLECTION | November 02, 2011
Before finding infamy as a perm-'fro courtroom crazy, the guy who held the Ramones at gunpoint, or the dude who dared helm murky post-Beatles waters, Phil Spector was synonymous with '60s-pop Wall of Sound production.

See all articles by: ZETH LUNDY

CD Reviews

R.E.M. | Part Lies, Part Heart, Part Truth, Part Garbage: 1982-2011

The Mighty Mighty Bosstones | The Magic of Youth

Charlotte Gainsbourg | Stage Whispers

The Black Keys | El Camino

Jedi Mind Tricks | Violence Begets Violence

Florence + the Machine | Ceremonials