The Phoenix Network:
 
 
About  |  Advertise
Adult  |  Moonsigns  |  Band Guide  |  Blogs  |  In Pictures
 
News Features  |  Talking Politics  |  This Just In

I stand by what I said

The speech Harvard's Larry Summers should have given six months ago
By HARVEY SILVERGLATE  |  February 23, 2006

Harvard's Larry SummersMy dear Harvard students, administrators, faculty, and alumni:

We find ourselves in what we academics call “a teachable moment.” A struggle is afoot for control of the soul of the academy — at Harvard and every other liberal-arts campus. Unfettered debate and inquiry are under grave assault.

From the outset, my tenure as Harvard’s president has been punctuated by a series of phony crises. Some of these episodes were blamed on my lack of personal sensitivity, others on my misconception of a university president’s role vis-à-vis the faculty. This is deeply troubling to me, not because my social reputation is at stake, but because something larger hangs in the balance: whether or not academic freedom will remain intact. I take seriously the duty bestowed on me, and I welcome robust criticism; reciprocally, I reserve the right, indeed the duty, to voice my unvarnished views about the directions in which I feel Harvard must move.

Let me recount a few of the more highly publicized events of my presidency thus far. It began with my calling into question Harvard’s hostile attitude toward the military in general and the university’s refusal specifically to allow ROTC on campus because of the military’s “don’t ask/don’t tell” policy — a policy that I personally find offensive and counter-productive. In the same speech, delivered as a personal guest sermon in Harvard’s tradition of encouraging members of the community to speak out on moral and ethical issues, I questioned whether calls for the university to disinvest in companies that do business with Israel were engaging in a hypocritical double standard that might be deemed “anti-Semitic in their effect, if not in their intent.” Faculty authoritarians revolted against my right to deliver my speech, yet I stand by what I said.

My spat with Afro-American-studies professor Cornel West — a private conversation leaked to the news media — likewise drew the spirited disapproval of my faculty critics. It was deemed insensitive, if not outright racist, for a university president to inquire whether a scholar should contribute more to the body of knowledge in his stated field than to rap music. Mind you, I like rap music and think it has a place in the cultural canon, yet I stand by what I said.

And then there were my remarks to a September 2004 conference on Native American studies at Harvard, in which I noted that significantly more indigenous people died not from the settlers’ weapons but from their pathogens. For stating this empirical fact, I was lambasted as insensitive to the plight of Native Americans and an apologist for colonialism — a genocide denier. I stand by what I said. Facts, it has been wisely said, are stubborn things.

1  |  2  |  3  |   next >
Related: 2010 Muzzle Awards on campus, Why the Imus cave-in is bad for free speech, radio, and the whole society, Free speech again quashed at Harvard, More more >
  Topics: News Features , Education, Harvard University, Massachusetts Institute of Technology,  More more >
| More
4 Comments / Add Comment

sisyphus00

Bravo, Mr. Silverglate! It's about time someone said something about the utter hyprocrisy that permeates so many of our colleges and universities. It is unfortunate that Mr. Summers didn't have the cajones to stand up to the PC nazis in the faculty of arts & science.
Posted: February 23 2006 at 2:41 PM

frank

It is interesting that Summers could be the coarchitect -- along with Rubin -- of the 8 years of Clintonian prosperity and, along the way, help steer the world through two major financial crises and he can't govern Harvard. Is the problem with Summers, or with Harvard?
Posted: February 23 2006 at 5:43 PM

Hugo S. Cunningham

Through board elections, Harvard alumni have a substantial voice, whether the faculty putschists at Harvard get away with it. Will a cipher like Derek Bok continue to punch their meal-tickets? Or will the broader Harvard community demand a president who can stand up to them? Only partially in jest, I offer the following campaign poster: RUDI GIULIANI for President of Harvard University WILLIAM BRATTON for Dean of the Faculty of Arts and Sciences (FAS) Turf the squeegie-persons out of the FAS Faculty Lounge!
Posted: February 23 2006 at 11:18 PM

joxygen

Seems to reveal a man who was not very politically astute and who perhaps might take a few chances to stand up suddenly while in a duck blind with Dick Cheney. While the above point is valid -- for surely being politic is at least part of the job of anyone who is the president of Harvard -- I like the bigger question better. Was he right? Partially I think Summers was right to go after Cornel West & perhaps say the things that he might have said about women in Science etc ... It does seem to me like he got his ass kicked a little too hard and unfairly for some of this stuff. What is left off the page tho is how The University institution as a whole is becoming more and more corporate and that at least some of these actions -- i.e. trying to allow the military on campus, critiquing a stand against Israel & even the critique of Cornel West can be seen as a move to edge the power of the institution away from faculty and their concerns and more towards the administration and their concerns. Not enough has been written about how academia is moving more towards the top down corporate, professional school money-making consumer model and further away from a more idealistic model of creating educated, informed, critically minded citizens. (One book though that does outline the issue very clearly is Steal This University.) So while I don't disagree that Summers is something of a victim to over-zealous political-correctness, on the other hand, I applaud the faculty (and more surprisingly the board of directors) at Harvard for the small victory of not allowing themselves to get bowled over by an over-zealous, nation-wide campaign to suck the power away from the people who are most engaged and most powerfully motivated by the desire to understand the world better -- the faculty.
Posted: February 23 2006 at 11:21 PM
Add Comment
HTML Prohibited

 Friends' Activity   Popular   Most Viewed 
[ 03/26 ]   "A Little Nightmare Music"  @ Berklee Performance Center
[ 03/26 ]   Boston Symphony Orchestra conducted by Thomas Adès  @ Symphony Hall
ARTICLES BY HARVEY SILVERGLATE
Share this entry with Delicious
  •   DOJ TURNS ON TURNER, FIRST AMENDMENT  |  January 26, 2011
    The sentencing memorandum filed by Boston federal prosecutors last week, seeking between 33 and 41 months of incarceration for convicted former Boston City Councilor Chuck Turner, is no ordinary document.
  •   TERROR AND THE MBTA: YOU DON’T LOOK HARMLESS  |  December 29, 2010
    Racial profiling meets war on terror: The highest federal court in New England has said it’s okay for government officials single out dark-skinned people for searches,  as long as they can concoct some cover rationale, ginned up with vague allusions to terrorism.
  •   SUPREME JUDICIAL COURT QUASHES CASH-FOR-TESTIMONY  |  October 06, 2010
    The Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts made a pronouncement last week that, to rational citizens, should be obvious: it's a bad idea for the state to be complicit in a scheme to pay criminal trial witnesses for their testimony — and for those witnesses to receive a bonus if the defendant is convicted.
  •   THE FBI'S SPY PROBLEM  |  July 07, 2010
    I've been following the latest Russian spy saga with great interest, partly because of the local color and partly because of my prior experience with the FBI.
  •   2010 MUZZLE AWARDS ON CAMPUS  |  June 30, 2010
    Harvard and Yale universities felt the sting of the global economic collapse firsthand in 2009, as the endowments of these stalwart New England Ivy League members dropped by nearly a third. The schools didn’t fare much better in the free marketplace of ideas, either.

 See all articles by: HARVEY SILVERGLATE

MOST POPULAR
RSS Feed of for the most popular articles
 Most Viewed   Most Emailed 



  |  Sign In  |  Register
 
thePhoenix.com:
Phoenix Media/Communications Group:
TODAY'S FEATURED ADVERTISERS
Copyright © 2011 The Phoenix Media/Communications Group