This Just In: Pandering Porn -- and Romeo & Juliet

Published May 19 2008, 05:38 PM by Harvey Silverglate

This morning, the Supreme Court ruled that a law that outlaws promoting or advertising -- "pandering" -- child pornography is constitutional and does not interfere with First Amendment freedoms. In the case, United States v. Williams, decided 7-2, the justices declared that there is no free speech right that protects "offers to provide or requests to obtain child pornography," even if (in fact) there is no pornography to be provided. Free speech expert and blogger Eugene Volokh explains that the case is actually more interesting than a simple child pornography case, as the court has, in his reading, recognized that the First Amendment does not protect solicitations (or offers) to commit a crime. He writes: "[t]rying to buy illegal drugs, for instance, by soliciting someone to sell them to you is generally a criminal attempt even if the solicited seller was only going to deliver fake drugs rather than real ones."

Wendy Kaminer wrote about this case on The Free For All back in November.

Updated (6/10/08 1:30pm): Readers who access The Free For All through the old site rather than the new site might see this post misattributed below to Wendy Kaminer because of software limitations with the old system. The post was penned by James Tierney, a research assistant for Harvey Silverglate.

Filed Under: censorship, cyberspace, First Amendment, free speech, indecency

This Just In: Pandering Porn -- and Romeo & Juliet

Anti-Noose Laws

Follow the Boston Phoenix

All Blogs

On The Download (2,163)
Laser Orgy (33)
Dont Quote Me (518)
Talking Politics (1,523)
Outside The Frame (305)
Phlog (1,419)

Filed Under: censorship, cyberspace, First Amendment, free speech, indecency, pornography

Boston Phoenix
Critical Mass
Published 11/20/2009 by KYLE SMEALLIE AND HARVEY SILVERGLATE
Over the years, UMass Amherst has proven to be a reliable hotbed for political hypocrisy and squelching of free speech

Boston Phoenix
Courthouse bomber to speak about social change
Published 11/13/2009 by RICK WORMWOOD
Censorship averted

more by Harvey Silverglate

Free speech again quashed at Harvard | October 23, 2009

The Gates case isn't about race | August 07, 2009

Muzzle Awards: Collegiate Division | July 10, 2009

Guilty until proven guilty | June 26, 2009

Sotomayor's mixed message on free speech | June 05, 2009

See all articles by: Harvey Silverglate

Latest Comments

Lee Ranaldo picks his favorite albums of the decade - @mike i was wondering the same

By Matías on 11-26-2009 in On The Download

Lee Ranaldo picks his favorite albums of the decade - why is the camera facing the interviewer the whole time?

By mike on 11-26-2009 in On The Download

Khazei Sneaking Up? - As voters learn more about Alan Khazei, they will want to vote him in. He is an extraordinary public...

By vicki kennedy on 11-25-2009 in Talking Politics

Khazei Sneaking Up? - ****Updated Nov 25** with copies of letters from Privacy Commissioner of Canada and an audio. Suppressed...

By Mar on 11-25-2009 in Talking Politics

PODCAST: David Plouffe on the early days of the Obama campaign - **Updated Nov 25** with copies of letters from Privacy Commissioner of Canada and an audio. Suppressed...

By Mar on 11-25-2009 in Phlog

Latest Comments from Free For All

This Just In: Pandering Porn -- and Romeo & Juliet

Leave a Comment