This Just In: The Right to Travel ... to Israel?

Published May 29 2008, 03:38 PM by Harvey Silverglate

Following up on Harvey's post about the right to travel to Cuba, a few days ago Israeli security services detained American (ex-)academic Norman Finkelstein and refused to allow him entry to Israel for the next ten years. Salon.com's Glenn Greenwald quotes a Jerusalem Post article explaining that "the decision to deport Finkelstein was connected to his anti-Zionist opinions and fierce public criticism of Israel around the world." Even if you disagree with Finklestein's politics, there's something perverse in a country refusing admission to someone based on the content of their speech. It's one thing to keep a visiting scholar out because of real security interests, but it smacks of viewpoint censorship when scholars (like Tariq Ramadan, who writes about Islam and modernity and was denied a teaching visa by the U.S. state department back in 2004) aren't allowed to enter the marketplace of ideas. Finkelstein certainly doesn't toe the Likud party line, but it's also a stretch to call him a security threat, so it seems pretty clear why he was excluded. Ha'aretz had the right response: "It is not for the government to decide which views should be heard here and which ones should not."

Updated (6/10/08 1:30pm): Readers who access The Free For All through the old site rather than the new site might see this post misattributed below to Wendy Kaminer because of software limitations with the old system. The post was penned by James Tierney, a research assistant for Harvey Silverglate.

Filed Under: blacklisting, censorship, feminism, free speech, immigration

Back to Free For All

The Right to Travel

1 Comments

Harvey Silverglate said:

For centuries, the ancestors of present-day Israelis had to open their door (or see it kicked in) for cossacks and storm troopers. If they want to give the bird to a friend of Holocaust-deniers, that is a privilage of statehood I would not deny them.

June 19, 2008 11:07 PM

Follow the Phoenix

All Blogs

On The Download (2,352)
Outside The Frame (341)
Laser Orgy (108)
Phlog (1,548)
Talking Politics (1,646)
Dont Quote Me (581)

Filed Under: blacklisting, censorship, feminism, free speech, immigration

Boston Phoenix
This Just In: The Right to Travel ... to Israel?
Published 5/29/2008 by Harvey Silverglate
Following up on Harvey's post about the right to travel to Cuba, a few days ago Israeli security ser...

Boston Phoenix
Blacklisting and Unaccountable Executive Power
Published 2/12/2008 by Wendy Kaminer
By Wendy Kaminer One of the most expansive, flexible, and unreviewable appropriations of presidential power in the war on terror is also one...

more by Harvey Silverglate

Free speech for me, but not for thee | January 29, 2010

Free speech again quashed at Harvard | October 23, 2009

The Gates case isn't about race | August 07, 2009

Muzzle Awards: Collegiate Division | July 10, 2009

Guilty until proven guilty | June 26, 2009

See all articles by: Harvey Silverglate

Latest Comments

Tron Legacy: Serious Business - I'm really looking forward to Tron Legacy. I liked the original concept of Tron, because I'm a huge video...

By fearix on 03-20-2010 in Laser Orgy

SXSW 2010 (Wednesday) mid-day review and video: Japandroids, Morning Benders and more - Nope. Totally didn't.

By sccc on 03-19-2010 in On The Download

Fuck Rachael Ray and Her Annoying SXSW Party - Couldn't agree with you more!

By Yara on 03-19-2010 in On The Download

Q&A #8: Katherine Clark - A lawyer from the politically connected firm Mintz, Levin running as an outsider?

By capecodder on 03-18-2010 in Talking Politics

Fuck Rachael Ray and Her Annoying SXSW Party - Dude, if you're gonna slam the woman, at least check that you don't typo her name in your opening sentence...

By Brenna on 03-18-2010 in On The Download

Latest Comments from Free For All

This Just In: The Right to Travel ... to Israel?

1 Comments

Harvey Silverglate said:

Leave a Comment