Yesterday's dubious Globe op-ed

Published Aug 12 2008, 02:51 PM by Adam Reilly

I didn't read this Globe op-ed on "linguistic paranoia" until yesterday evening. But when I did, my sympathy for the author's goal was pretty much negated by her deeply questionable reasoning.

Nataly Kelly--"a senior analyst with Common Sense Advisory, a market research firm specializing in business globalization"--thinks Americans should learn more languages. And in advancing her argument, she invokes the Founding Fathers:

Linguistic paranoia seems to have reached unprecedented levels in recent years, a phenomenon that would probably shock our Founding Fathers. After all, they intentionally decided not to declare an official language for America, knowing full well that linguistic dominance in the world is often in flux, and that doing so could restrict the country's ability to both compete internationally and respond to domestic needs [emph. added].

Usually, when people cite the FF's to make a point, they bolster their case with a quote or two. Kelly doesn't.

Maybe I'm wrong, but I'm guessing that this is because--when the Founding Fathers decision not to make English our official language--they weren't thinking about the ephemeral nature of linguistic dominance, international competitiveness, or domestic exigencies. Instead, they probably took it for granted that everybody in the U.S. would just speak English.

Am I missing something? If not, Kelly seems to be guilty of retroactively importing her own mindset into the FF's. Which is no way to make a completely legitimate point.

Filed Under: Boston Globe

Back to Media Log

DQM does NewsNight: Edwards and "Rockefeller"--updated!

Follow the Boston Phoenix

All Blogs

On The Download (2,174)
Dont Quote Me (525)
Talking Politics (1,529)
Outside The Frame (307)
Phlog (1,430)
Laser Orgy (35)

Filed Under: Boston Globe

Boston Phoenix
Goal rush!
Published 12/4/2009 by ADAM REILLY
How long can Boston's frenetic sports-media explosion last?

Boston Phoenix
The X factor
Published 11/27/2009 by DAVID S. BERNSTEIN
Come Monday, it's a one-week spring to the primary — and to capture the hearts of undecided voters.

more by Adam Reilly

Goal rush! | December 04, 2009

Greg Epstein, Atheist Superstar | November 27, 2009

Unmaking a bad federal law | November 27, 2009

Collateral damage? | November 13, 2009

Holy terror? | November 13, 2009

See all articles by: Adam Reilly

Latest Comments

Confirmation Of Contradiction - The variation in the margin might also come from how the ballot test question was worded. Were respondents...

By PollTalk on 12-04-2009 in Talking Politics

City Council Forums - Наш сайт - самый легкий и быстрый способ найти партнера, имеющего схожие с вашими сексуальные предпочтения...

By Merbactibrape on 12-04-2009 in Talking Politics

Totten trial chairwoman: the fix wasn't in - Hi !. You re, I guess , probably curious to know how one can make real money . There is no initial capital...

By EpirummomoHug on 12-04-2009 in Dont Quote Me

Recommended reading: Charlie Pierce on Tiger Woods - Mike Hunt's Q&A Session: Q: What is only way Tiger will get thru this? A: Tiger will have to go on...

By Mike Hunt on 12-03-2009 in Dont Quote Me

Confirmation Of Contradiction - If Coakley's poll was a smaller margin, but still bigger than what Capuano's poll is seeing it would...

By This guy on 12-03-2009 in Talking Politics

Latest Comments from Media Log

Yesterday's dubious Globe op-ed

Leave a Comment