The Phoenix Network:
 
 
About  |  Advertise
Adult  |  Moonsigns  |  Band Guide  |  Blogs  |  In Pictures
 

Yesterday's dubious Globe op-ed

I didn't read this Globe op-ed on "linguistic paranoia" until yesterday evening. But when I did, my sympathy for the author's goal was pretty much negated by her deeply questionable reasoning. 

Nataly Kelly--"a senior analyst with Common Sense Advisory, a market research firm specializing in business globalization"--thinks Americans should learn more languages. And in advancing her argument, she invokes the Founding Fathers:

Linguistic paranoia seems to have reached unprecedented levels in recent years, a phenomenon that would probably shock our Founding Fathers. After all, they intentionally decided not to declare an official language for America, knowing full well that linguistic dominance in the world is often in flux, and that doing so could restrict the country's ability to both compete internationally and respond to domestic needs [emph. added].

Usually, when people cite the FF's to make a point, they bolster their case with a quote or two. Kelly doesn't.

Maybe I'm wrong, but I'm guessing that this is because--when the Founding Fathers decision not to make English our official language--they weren't thinking about the ephemeral nature of linguistic dominance, international competitiveness, or domestic exigencies. Instead, they probably took it for granted that everybody in the U.S. would just speak English.

Am I missing something? If not, Kelly seems to be guilty of retroactively importing her own mindset into the FF's. Which is no way to make a completely legitimate point.

Filed Under:
  • Share:
  • Share this entry with Facebook
  • Share this entry with Digg
  • Share this entry with Delicious
  • Email this article to a friend
  • Print this article

Leave a Comment

Login | Not a member yet? Click here to Join
Follow the Phoenix
  • newsletter
  • twitter
  • facebook
  • youtube
  • rss
All Blogs
Filed Under:
Related Articles

1003_terrier_list
Boston Phoenix
Bully for BU!
Published 3/12/2010 by ADAM REILLY
A curious conflict of interest is followed by a legal threat — from a journalism center!

Boston Phoenix
War over piece
Published 2/26/2010 by BOSTON PHOENIX LETTERS
Letters to the Boston editor, February 26, 2010

more by Adam Reilly
Bully for BU! | March 12, 2010
Stop the Quinn-sanity! | March 05, 2010
WBUR's new, improved "Radio Boston" | March 01, 2010
Pew takes stock of the brave new media world | February 28, 2010
My impending departure | February 26, 2010

 See all articles by: Adam Reilly

ADVERTISEMENT
Latest Comments
SXSW 2010 (Wednesday) mid-day review and video: Japandroids, Morning Benders and more - Nope. Totally didn't.

By sccc on 03-19-2010 in On The Download

Fuck Rachael Ray and Her Annoying SXSW Party - Couldn't agree with you more!

By Yara on 03-19-2010 in On The Download

Q&A #8: Katherine Clark - A lawyer from the politically connected firm Mintz, Levin running as an outsider?

By capecodder on 03-18-2010 in Talking Politics

Fuck Rachael Ray and Her Annoying SXSW Party - Dude, if you're gonna slam the woman, at least check that you don't typo her name in your opening sentence...

By Brenna on 03-18-2010 in On The Download

RIP Alex Chilton, 1950 - 2010 - It's news out of New Orleans where Chilton had lived for the last 20+ years

By jazzlunatique on 03-18-2010 in On The Download

Latest Comments from Media Log
Most Viewed
MP3: Aziz Ansari and Dave Sitek, "AAAAAAAANGRY"
Massachusetts #Idol: Are you voting for Cape Cod's Siobhan Magnus or Chelsea's Ashley Rodriguez?
"On behalf of every man, looking out for every girl"....watch out. John Mayer and his racist dong are coming to town
Booty Advisory: Thaw-some
FYI: Thom Yorke has renamed his band and they're playing Boston on April 8. Tickets on sale next week!
Cartoon angst revisited: Daria set for May DVD release
Bushwallas: Or, 21 of the most unfortunate imaginary cover bands we could think of
Most Viewed from Media Log
Search Blogs
 
Media Log Archives
Saturday, March 20, 2010  |  Sign In  |  Register
 
TODAY'S FEATURED ADVERTISERS
thePhoenix.com
Phoenix Media/Communications Group
Copyright © 2010 The Phoenix Media/Communications Group