FIND MOVIES
Movie List
Loading ...
or
Find Theaters and Movie Times
or
Search Movies

Wasted again

Factory Girl isn’t the bio-pic Edie deserves
By GARY SUSMAN  |  February 7, 2007
2.0 2.0 Stars

070209_factory_main1
DON’T BLAME SIENNA AND GUY: It’s the writing and the direction that come up short.

Who was Edie Sedgwick? Was she a muse who inspired some notable work by Andy Warhol and Bob Dylan or just a footnote in their careers? Did she have any talent or accomplishments of her own? Why, in short, does she deserve a bio-pic?

Alas, Factory Girl answers none of these questions. Despite a committed performance by Sienna Miller, the film’s attempts to explain Sedgwick fall frustratingly short. We learn about her old-money family, her horrific upbringing (marked by family tragedy, institutionalization, and hints of sexual abuse), and her early art-school aspirations. Arriving in New York and hooking up with Warhol, she seems to want only to be famous — and who better than Mr. 15 Minutes to make that happen? Later, she befriends Dylan, though it’s not clear what he sees in her. She falls out of favor with both men, spirals into drug addiction and depravity, and drops out of the scene — at which point the movie loses interest in its own subject.

Factory Girl almost works as an accidental bio-pic about Warhol. The movie re-creates the atmosphere of the Factory, the tin-foiled studio where he cranked out his art and served as ringmaster to a circus of hangers-on. Director George Hickenlooper even emulates the look and feel of a Warhol film, with ennui and outrageousness trying to pass themselves off as excitement and glamor.

The screenplay by Captain Mauzner (Wonderland) doesn’t really get at Warhol’s importance as an artist (or even whether he was any good), but it does dissect his personality and character. Guy Pearce makes the most compelling movie Warhol since Jared Harris in I Shot Andy Warhol, plumbing depths even Harris didn’t reach. Pearce gets at Warhol’s alternating self-confidence and insecurity, his radicalism and ordinariness (he has some wonderful moments in a Catholic confessional and at home with the artist’s Polish mother), his gift for collecting friends and his inability to attach to any of them. This Warhol is also a manipulative cheapskate who nickel-and-dimes his associates and tosses them aside if they’re disloyal or if someone more interesting comes along.

According to the movie, Warhol vied with Dylan for Edie’s soul. (Thanks to legal threats from Dylan, the character is never referred to by name, but Hayden Christensen’s scowling rebel is pretty clearly Dylan, or maybe James Franco.) The film is no more interested in Dylan’s music than in Warhol’s art, only in what he represents: authenticity and emotion. (Dylan claims the affair depicted here never happened; Christensen is no more convincing in this romance than he was by the lake on Naboo, despite what you’ve read about the movie’s undeservedly notorious sex scene.) Although Warhol and Dylan are supposed to be opposites (as is apparent in the film’s best scene, an awkward confrontation at the Factory), they seem a lot alike here, both cryptic and elusive in discussing their work, both vampires who suck up the enthusiasm of others and discard them when they’re finished. The moment when Edie is forced to choose between them is supposed to be the turning point of her life, but they seem equally disastrous.

1  |  2  |   next >
  Topics: Reviews , Entertainment, Health and Fitness, Movies,  More more >
| More


Most Popular
ARTICLES BY GARY SUSMAN
Share this entry with Delicious
  •   REVIEW: SALT  |  February 24, 2011
    "Who is Salt?" ask the promos for this movie. Doesn't really matter — all you need to know is that she's the latest Angelina Jolie heroine.
  •   FANBOYS  |  February 19, 2009
    Bonus points to director Kyle Newman for upping Kristen Bell's already solid geek cred (and for squeezing her into Princess Leia's gold bikini).
  •   ‘HELL’ YEAH!  |  November 11, 2008
    The richness of Guillermo del Toro's vision as a filmmaker is even more visible in Hellboy II: The Golden Army than it was in 2004’s Hellboy , the last movie he made before Pan's Labyrinth .
  •   DARJEELING UNLIMITED  |  October 03, 2007
    Movie miniaturist Wes Anderson ( The Royal Tenenbaums , Rushmore ) expands his horizons in The Darjeeling Limited.
  •   BECOMING JANE  |  August 01, 2007
    Anne Hathaway is game enough as Jane, though she has to spend an awful lot of time on the verge of tears.

 See all articles by: GARY SUSMAN