The Phoenix Network:
 
 
About  |  Advertise
 
Features  |  Reviews
Best2012Vote-1000x50

Academy Award Nominated Shorts 2007

Unchallenging and underwhelming
By NINA MACLAUGHLIN  |  February 13, 2008
2.0 2.0 Stars
inside_madame
“Madame Tutli-Putli”

The selection of live-action and animated shorts nominated for Oscars this year is an unchallenging and underwhelming lot. Two exceptions: Chris Lavis & Maciek Szczerbowski’s stop-motion animation piece “Madame Tutli-Putli,” about a woman on a nightmarish night train, has the look of an animated Egon Schiele drawing — menacing, delicate, macabre. And Alexander Petrov’s “My Love” is a dreamy Russian love story. But in the animated batch, “Peter and the Wolf” and “I Met the Walrus,” a pen-and-ink version of an interview with John Lennon, are unamusing, and though “Même les pigeons vont au Paradis/Even Pigeons Go to Heaven” is visually exciting (time machines, crooked salesmen), it’s also predictable. The live-action selections range from the maudlin (a cancer ward in “At Night”) to the exuberant (students and teacher in “Il supplente|The Substitute”). And “The Tonto Woman” could be a romantic subplot to There Will Be Blood, albeit with phony accents. Russian + French + Italian + Danish + English | 222 minutes | Coolidge Corner Theatre
Related: Here, there, and everywhere, Affirmative action, Portland scene report: August 22, 2008, More more >
  Topics: Reviews , John Lennon, Egon Schiele
| More

 Friends' Activity   Popular   Most Viewed 
[ 02/15 ]   The Addams Family  @ Shubert Theatre
[ 02/15 ]   "Aphrodite and the Gods of Love"  @ Museum of Fine Arts
[ 02/15 ]   Green Eyes  @ Ames Hotel
ARTICLES BY NINA MACLAUGHLIN
Share this entry with Delicious
  •   ON CARPENTRY AND COLLEGE  |  October 20, 2011
    Age 30, I quit the Phoenix and ended up with a job as an apprentice to a carpenter. Sawing, chiseling, hammering, nail-gunning, tiling, sanding, slotting, framing, hauling, measuring, and sweeping are less obvious outcomes of an undergraduate career in the liberal arts. College, in strange and unexpected ways, prepared me for this sort of work. And in others, did not prepare me at all.
  •   PHDISASTERS  |  April 27, 2011
    I knew a man pursuing a PhD in literature. His dissertation had to do with humor as a form of dissent in 20th-century literature. And how enthused he was at first! How passionate and excited.
  •   DAVID FOSTER WALLACE'S THE PALE KING  |  April 13, 2011
    All I can do is tell you how I read the book.
  •   THE HOUSE THAT HOUSE OF SAND AND FOG BUILT  |  February 25, 2011
    Andre Dubus III collected me at the Newburyport train station last month when the snow piles were already high. We stopped first for a coffee for the road; he asked all the questions: siblings, hometown, are you married?
  •   DON'T BE AN IDIOT  |  January 27, 2011
    We're all idiots when we're 18. We're all idiots for the first half of our 20s, and longer, for some. By saying so, we're not trying to insult anyone.

 See all articles by: NINA MACLAUGHLIN

MOST POPULAR
RSS Feed of for the most popular articles
 Most Viewed   Most Emailed